<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>

<!--XBRL Document Created with the Workiva Platform-->
<!--Copyright 2024 Workiva-->
<!--r:2fb9894e-8f75-4b20-8e2b-9265c1319bc5,g:c59f9eb3-ccd8-4a5e-8bbd-f35fbbe99260-->
<link:linkbase xmlns:link="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/linkbase" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:xbrldt="http://xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/linkbase http://www.xbrl.org/2003/xbrl-linkbase-2003-12-31.xsd">
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#all"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#hypercube-dimension"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#dimension-default"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#dimension-domain"/>
  <link:arcroleRef arcroleURI="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="http://www.xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt-2005.xsd#domain-member"/>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/Cover" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#Cover"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/Cover" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntitiesTable_18f3c5af-e554-4d57-81d8-c38bcc4739b5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntitiesTable_18f3c5af-e554-4d57-81d8-c38bcc4739b5" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_7c195971-3951-4d0d-bc21-cc1f11bc1ebf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntitiesTable_18f3c5af-e554-4d57-81d8-c38bcc4739b5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_7c195971-3951-4d0d-bc21-cc1f11bc1ebf" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_7c195971-3951-4d0d-bc21-cc1f11bc1ebf_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_7c195971-3951-4d0d-bc21-cc1f11bc1ebf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_7c195971-3951-4d0d-bc21-cc1f11bc1ebf_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_7c195971-3951-4d0d-bc21-cc1f11bc1ebf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_3bf20ff9-5e24-4279-a6cd-ed500c997368" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_3bf20ff9-5e24-4279-a6cd-ed500c997368" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_e3658529-c62d-424f-8990-3a588abcd25c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_e3658529-c62d-424f-8990-3a588abcd25c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_9cd28a63-526e-45ae-b496-5cc808eedeb3" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_9cd28a63-526e-45ae-b496-5cc808eedeb3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_a90e3220-c782-4b71-9b30-0b0028521ceb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_a90e3220-c782-4b71-9b30-0b0028521ceb" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_1f128dff-01f6-425f-8a7e-8eb323b840c5" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_f0d53f6e-957b-429e-ada6-632765c88a12" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_1f128dff-01f6-425f-8a7e-8eb323b840c5" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentType_2b223028-a27f-4181-850b-dac176cdb92f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentType"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentType_2b223028-a27f-4181-850b-dac176cdb92f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentAnnualReport_d0027cbf-6da1-46bf-a954-a773e1d5767c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentAnnualReport"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentAnnualReport_d0027cbf-6da1-46bf-a954-a773e1d5767c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentPeriodEndDate_a4b7c95d-adae-4459-b5f9-abf6a5e561d2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentPeriodEndDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentPeriodEndDate_a4b7c95d-adae-4459-b5f9-abf6a5e561d2" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentTransitionReport_3ad2a084-43f0-472b-862a-cb85271223ea" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentTransitionReport"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentTransitionReport_3ad2a084-43f0-472b-862a-cb85271223ea" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityFileNumber_f6a46920-5c47-473f-9bac-4bb6cacb6baf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityFileNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityFileNumber_f6a46920-5c47-473f-9bac-4bb6cacb6baf" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityRegistrantName_c549df67-9b3d-44c0-9126-b4a0de33d285" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityRegistrantName"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityRegistrantName_c549df67-9b3d-44c0-9126-b4a0de33d285" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityIncorporationStateCountryCode_8f7db806-3d33-474a-a483-b5888a3481cc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityIncorporationStateCountryCode"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityIncorporationStateCountryCode_8f7db806-3d33-474a-a483-b5888a3481cc" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityTaxIdentificationNumber_096441df-bcb2-4030-9485-b9a9e423ce59" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityTaxIdentificationNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityTaxIdentificationNumber_096441df-bcb2-4030-9485-b9a9e423ce59" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityCentralIndexKey_a7f03377-e3d7-43c6-8795-729ce30bcb09" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityCentralIndexKey"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityCentralIndexKey_a7f03377-e3d7-43c6-8795-729ce30bcb09" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressAddressLine1_e1a93925-41fb-4309-b792-0fd68bc191e8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityAddressAddressLine1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressAddressLine1_e1a93925-41fb-4309-b792-0fd68bc191e8" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressCityOrTown_6c7bd24a-153e-43c1-a652-668399388c86" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityAddressCityOrTown"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressCityOrTown_6c7bd24a-153e-43c1-a652-668399388c86" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressStateOrProvince_fc062c9f-45e9-45d7-96ce-4b4e018e181e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityAddressStateOrProvince"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressStateOrProvince_fc062c9f-45e9-45d7-96ce-4b4e018e181e" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityAddressPostalZipCode_bb6b268f-113a-4e78-af7d-d3cb115683f2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityAddressPostalZipCode"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityAddressPostalZipCode_bb6b268f-113a-4e78-af7d-d3cb115683f2" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_CityAreaCode_4512160c-3264-49d6-b885-98f2cb059059" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_CityAreaCode"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_CityAreaCode_4512160c-3264-49d6-b885-98f2cb059059" xlink:type="arc" order="13"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_LocalPhoneNumber_6f7beab5-c6b3-41ba-8e6b-4d8bc28c4303" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_LocalPhoneNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_LocalPhoneNumber_6f7beab5-c6b3-41ba-8e6b-4d8bc28c4303" xlink:type="arc" order="14"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_Security12bTitle_98f8c613-f274-4093-97a1-cd80a6591372" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_Security12bTitle"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_Security12bTitle_98f8c613-f274-4093-97a1-cd80a6591372" xlink:type="arc" order="15"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_TradingSymbol_d115bcb0-ed44-4550-8d2e-5c2db2520a0d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_TradingSymbol"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_TradingSymbol_d115bcb0-ed44-4550-8d2e-5c2db2520a0d" xlink:type="arc" order="16"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_SecurityExchangeName_a235573e-f95b-4719-874b-3e464e39b1a8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_SecurityExchangeName"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_SecurityExchangeName_a235573e-f95b-4719-874b-3e464e39b1a8" xlink:type="arc" order="17"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityWellKnownSeasonedIssuer_8351a8ef-375e-41ba-a22e-49cba9886ea7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityWellKnownSeasonedIssuer"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityWellKnownSeasonedIssuer_8351a8ef-375e-41ba-a22e-49cba9886ea7" xlink:type="arc" order="18"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityVoluntaryFilers_2aefa201-2d1a-46fa-bb72-5cc31d993745" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityVoluntaryFilers"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityVoluntaryFilers_2aefa201-2d1a-46fa-bb72-5cc31d993745" xlink:type="arc" order="19"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityCurrentReportingStatus_b48a6ff7-d351-4f96-8641-68772c0d4eec" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityCurrentReportingStatus"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityCurrentReportingStatus_b48a6ff7-d351-4f96-8641-68772c0d4eec" xlink:type="arc" order="20"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityInteractiveDataCurrent_14fca4a9-c163-4122-a9ec-63c97b8ce66b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityInteractiveDataCurrent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityInteractiveDataCurrent_14fca4a9-c163-4122-a9ec-63c97b8ce66b" xlink:type="arc" order="21"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_AmendmentFlag_cfc64741-6b1d-442a-a2a8-11ed96d1a123" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_AmendmentFlag"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_AmendmentFlag_cfc64741-6b1d-442a-a2a8-11ed96d1a123" xlink:type="arc" order="22"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalYearFocus_1298b130-33e1-4357-a837-0d280e1c285a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentFiscalYearFocus"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalYearFocus_1298b130-33e1-4357-a837-0d280e1c285a" xlink:type="arc" order="23"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus_2a71ffdb-70be-48ba-90f6-a30e619d6f51" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus_2a71ffdb-70be-48ba-90f6-a30e619d6f51" xlink:type="arc" order="24"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_CurrentFiscalYearEndDate_07851646-0405-4cfd-8c09-5b888869d4c6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_CurrentFiscalYearEndDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_CurrentFiscalYearEndDate_07851646-0405-4cfd-8c09-5b888869d4c6" xlink:type="arc" order="25"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityFilerCategory_1157b576-7da9-4715-bf0e-4cb353cdd0f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityFilerCategory"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityFilerCategory_1157b576-7da9-4715-bf0e-4cb353cdd0f9" xlink:type="arc" order="26"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntitySmallBusiness_3a170996-a3b0-4cf3-bc99-6bfa1f541034" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntitySmallBusiness"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntitySmallBusiness_3a170996-a3b0-4cf3-bc99-6bfa1f541034" xlink:type="arc" order="27"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityEmergingGrowthCompany_8fcaf2e1-e407-486f-8a38-c440c8ee3f73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityEmergingGrowthCompany"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityEmergingGrowthCompany_8fcaf2e1-e407-486f-8a38-c440c8ee3f73" xlink:type="arc" order="28"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_IcfrAuditorAttestationFlag_9568af09-7d95-4aef-97d0-d6d98dcbe70c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_IcfrAuditorAttestationFlag"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_IcfrAuditorAttestationFlag_9568af09-7d95-4aef-97d0-d6d98dcbe70c" xlink:type="arc" order="29"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityShellCompany_e015a50e-43dc-4261-bf6e-ceac9102dc77" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityShellCompany"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityShellCompany_e015a50e-43dc-4261-bf6e-ceac9102dc77" xlink:type="arc" order="30"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityPublicFloat_ec316d10-95ee-49eb-900c-737e9d9254ad" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityPublicFloat"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityPublicFloat_ec316d10-95ee-49eb-900c-737e9d9254ad" xlink:type="arc" order="31"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding_29c7d547-fdfe-4cdf-8777-bf517d7c865e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding_29c7d547-fdfe-4cdf-8777-bf517d7c865e" xlink:type="arc" order="32"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_dei_DocumentFinStmtErrorCorrectionFlag_c0c44db5-67cb-400f-b3f9-ef67fdc96f50" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2023/dei-2023.xsd#dei_DocumentFinStmtErrorCorrectionFlag"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_dei_EntityInformationLineItems_ef601dba-a1a6-43dc-b6c9-4451bee56d51" xlink:to="loc_dei_DocumentFinStmtErrorCorrectionFlag_c0c44db5-67cb-400f-b3f9-ef67fdc96f50" xlink:type="arc" order="33"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedStatementofChangesinEquity" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ConsolidatedStatementofChangesinEquity"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ConsolidatedStatementofChangesinEquity" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_8801a398-0c25-4899-b0af-9108351d7a3b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_3f0548db-6ed5-4ca3-b0c4-8a8619e3d7dc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_8801a398-0c25-4899-b0af-9108351d7a3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_3f0548db-6ed5-4ca3-b0c4-8a8619e3d7dc" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_c2f1d7f5-ebf5-491c-a41e-6548a03d1326" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementTable_3f0548db-6ed5-4ca3-b0c4-8a8619e3d7dc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_c2f1d7f5-ebf5-491c-a41e-6548a03d1326" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c2f1d7f5-ebf5-491c-a41e-6548a03d1326_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_c2f1d7f5-ebf5-491c-a41e-6548a03d1326" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c2f1d7f5-ebf5-491c-a41e-6548a03d1326_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_2fc29153-4a34-45b5-8c79-9310f90e3bb9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_c2f1d7f5-ebf5-491c-a41e-6548a03d1326" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_2fc29153-4a34-45b5-8c79-9310f90e3bb9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_9de2b34c-758f-4690-9382-791c4c29f6f0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ParentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_2fc29153-4a34-45b5-8c79-9310f90e3bb9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_9de2b34c-758f-4690-9382-791c4c29f6f0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_295dea3f-107a-4e4d-9320-dc2dca72fdae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_9de2b34c-758f-4690-9382-791c4c29f6f0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_295dea3f-107a-4e4d-9320-dc2dca72fdae" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockIncludingAdditionalPaidInCapitalMember_80afdd5f-c2dc-4000-9591-4f45e8eac03a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockIncludingAdditionalPaidInCapitalMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_9de2b34c-758f-4690-9382-791c4c29f6f0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockIncludingAdditionalPaidInCapitalMember_80afdd5f-c2dc-4000-9591-4f45e8eac03a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RetainedEarningsMember_51274d8a-1e2e-4466-84c5-e5e1369d2fc9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RetainedEarningsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_9de2b34c-758f-4690-9382-791c4c29f6f0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RetainedEarningsMember_51274d8a-1e2e-4466-84c5-e5e1369d2fc9" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_f8450778-af52-408c-af23-fc1e248a0e18" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ParentMember_9de2b34c-758f-4690-9382-791c4c29f6f0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_f8450778-af52-408c-af23-fc1e248a0e18" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementLineItems_8801a398-0c25-4899-b0af-9108351d7a3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding_d899fcc2-1587-438c-92cf-d87c93f2a04f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding_d899fcc2-1587-438c-92cf-d87c93f2a04f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_14eed23b-89d2-47ed-9c1e-23b485d73e77" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_14eed23b-89d2-47ed-9c1e-23b485d73e77" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_bd70168d-cb1a-4457-8763-e784b1ab9526" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_bd70168d-cb1a-4457-8763-e784b1ab9526" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_cc55145b-84a5-43da-a9f7-636cfc4ea085" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_cc55145b-84a5-43da-a9f7-636cfc4ea085" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Dividends_34698be4-d4e7-4d71-acf0-fc66e5e1af09" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Dividends"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Dividends_34698be4-d4e7-4d71-acf0-fc66e5e1af09" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SharesIssuedAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesStockOptionsExercised_e683718f-245a-4e5a-bf05-b5e519fb3a13" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesStockOptionsExercised"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesStockOptionsExercised_e683718f-245a-4e5a-bf05-b5e519fb3a13" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueStockOptionsExercised_aad48d7c-54e5-40e5-b76a-fe27f93bbf02" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueStockOptionsExercised"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueStockOptionsExercised_aad48d7c-54e5-40e5-b76a-fe27f93bbf02" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross_b032c6b6-7ae4-46af-b0b4-659ab09824bd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardGross_b032c6b6-7ae4-46af-b0b4-659ab09824bd" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueRestrictedStockAwardGross_5707786a-8997-43ba-ab5c-20303d0ecd22" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueRestrictedStockAwardGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueRestrictedStockAwardGross_5707786a-8997-43ba-ab5c-20303d0ecd22" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesShareBasedCompensationGross_26cfd705-c7b5-45a2-8057-0a99a8e2dfa1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesShareBasedCompensationGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesShareBasedCompensationGross_26cfd705-c7b5-45a2-8057-0a99a8e2dfa1" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueShareBasedCompensationGross_e98402e7-1b54-47d4-b3b9-d1dec3647398" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueShareBasedCompensationGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueShareBasedCompensationGross_e98402e7-1b54-47d4-b3b9-d1dec3647398" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesDividendReinvestmentPlan_909598f7-5122-459c-9bec-843cc07e4a67" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesDividendReinvestmentPlan"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesDividendReinvestmentPlan_909598f7-5122-459c-9bec-843cc07e4a67" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueDividendReinvestmentPlan_c5dacd17-7b4d-4da5-8a3f-5416824069b5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueDividendReinvestmentPlan"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SharesIssuedAbstract_0ef37815-845a-47e9-bed2-99be69a1eb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodValueDividendReinvestmentPlan_c5dacd17-7b4d-4da5-8a3f-5416824069b5" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToAdditionalPaidInCapitalSharebasedCompensationRequisiteServicePeriodRecognitionValue_61eb2902-c495-423f-b186-f15e517062bd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AdjustmentsToAdditionalPaidInCapitalSharebasedCompensationRequisiteServicePeriodRecognitionValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToAdditionalPaidInCapitalSharebasedCompensationRequisiteServicePeriodRecognitionValue_61eb2902-c495-423f-b186-f15e517062bd" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodShares_db69a91e-51db-40aa-8753-7252c963bdc7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodShares"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodShares_db69a91e-51db-40aa-8753-7252c963bdc7" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodValue_05c0560c-258b-47eb-82f6-3b90002bfff0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockRepurchasedAndRetiredDuringPeriodValue_05c0560c-258b-47eb-82f6-3b90002bfff0" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansShares_855870f4-d426-4d48-b718-bec5ff07a3a0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansShares"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansShares_855870f4-d426-4d48-b718-bec5ff07a3a0" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansValue_4c29ea1e-e6f8-4b74-aeee-d892b847e01d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_StockRepurchasedSharesExchangedInStockCompensationPlansValue_4c29ea1e-e6f8-4b74-aeee-d892b847e01d" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardForfeited_575b871d-6390-4cd3-9ac0-91c1b0aff275" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardForfeited"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncreaseDecreaseInStockholdersEquityRollForward_e8e32206-c135-429a-a1fd-e4965a9506c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockIssuedDuringPeriodSharesRestrictedStockAwardForfeited_575b871d-6390-4cd3-9ac0-91c1b0aff275" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding_f5ea592a-0dd7-4130-9e2a-4fbabeac5945" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockSharesOutstanding"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_95fa5134-540b-4392-b2ba-e86605797b7a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquity"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AccountingPoliciesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#AccountingPoliciesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AccountingPoliciesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_c26102f0-cc63-438d-8a9f-3c5b410e30be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_c26102f0-cc63-438d-8a9f-3c5b410e30be" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_8ba7a933-0f48-4e94-908d-07f51b32231e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_c26102f0-cc63-438d-8a9f-3c5b410e30be" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_8ba7a933-0f48-4e94-908d-07f51b32231e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_8ba7a933-0f48-4e94-908d-07f51b32231e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_8ba7a933-0f48-4e94-908d-07f51b32231e" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_8ba7a933-0f48-4e94-908d-07f51b32231e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_72488797-3554-49ac-87a2-c252da1f953d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_8ba7a933-0f48-4e94-908d-07f51b32231e" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_72488797-3554-49ac-87a2-c252da1f953d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_0457d1d6-9881-4812-a120-fde7bb791640" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_72488797-3554-49ac-87a2-c252da1f953d" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_0457d1d6-9881-4812-a120-fde7bb791640" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_36e839c0-5ac9-42e4-9193-5e3dd39954fa" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_36e839c0-5ac9-42e4-9193-5e3dd39954fa" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_cb95e8f1-b43d-4cc2-a38b-9379a9794da1" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_cb95e8f1-b43d-4cc2-a38b-9379a9794da1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiabilityCurrentStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_403e1734-16b8-468b-912f-9f3277896844" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiabilityCurrentStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseLiabilityCurrentStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_403e1734-16b8-468b-912f-9f3277896844" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_3c6c07ea-6d82-45c0-9d7b-3231db9df7f0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLeaseRightOfUseAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleList_3c6c07ea-6d82-45c0-9d7b-3231db9df7f0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncrementalCommonSharesAttributableToShareBasedPaymentArrangements_ddbd0090-da5e-46f3-8584-f30bc759eab2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncrementalCommonSharesAttributableToShareBasedPaymentArrangements"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncrementalCommonSharesAttributableToShareBasedPaymentArrangements_ddbd0090-da5e-46f3-8584-f30bc759eab2" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AntidilutiveSecuritiesExcludedFromComputationOfEarningsPerShareAmount_79fc9d96-6a2d-47bb-80e7-1bb9a69284f4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AntidilutiveSecuritiesExcludedFromComputationOfEarningsPerShareAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AntidilutiveSecuritiesExcludedFromComputationOfEarningsPerShareAmount_79fc9d96-6a2d-47bb-80e7-1bb9a69284f4" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MaturityPeriodOfShortTermInvestmentMaximum_72de001d-7aa2-497c-ac46-56836108ffb5" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_MaturityPeriodOfShortTermInvestmentMaximum"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_2aca730b-296d-4591-81e0-1b1455baf103" xlink:to="loc_afg_MaturityPeriodOfShortTermInvestmentMaximum_72de001d-7aa2-497c-ac46-56836108ffb5" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DiscontinuedOperationsNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_233b4c09-36ba-4d91-a989-11b74784e571" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_069f81f1-0b6e-4483-8f88-1526aeaa58a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_233b4c09-36ba-4d91-a989-11b74784e571" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_069f81f1-0b6e-4483-8f88-1526aeaa58a2" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_db611662-65c4-4b31-a947-fe05f6e4e7b4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_069f81f1-0b6e-4483-8f88-1526aeaa58a2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_db611662-65c4-4b31-a947-fe05f6e4e7b4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_db611662-65c4-4b31-a947-fe05f6e4e7b4_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_db611662-65c4-4b31-a947-fe05f6e4e7b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_db611662-65c4-4b31-a947-fe05f6e4e7b4_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_c52d437c-2b79-4f26-a89d-1a5986811d2e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_db611662-65c4-4b31-a947-fe05f6e4e7b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_c52d437c-2b79-4f26-a89d-1a5986811d2e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_646938f9-45bc-45e1-865c-65d39fe3cbfe" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_c52d437c-2b79-4f26-a89d-1a5986811d2e" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_646938f9-45bc-45e1-865c-65d39fe3cbfe" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinessesNetOfExpenses_915a6dc7-49b2-4b49-b2d5-121443fb5c19" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinessesNetOfExpenses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_233b4c09-36ba-4d91-a989-11b74784e571" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinessesNetOfExpenses_915a6dc7-49b2-4b49-b2d5-121443fb5c19" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax_f7087e53-7cdb-43f8-96e7-fc0a2a49bb78" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_233b4c09-36ba-4d91-a989-11b74784e571" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax_f7087e53-7cdb-43f8-96e7-fc0a2a49bb78" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsAssetsandliabilitiesofbusinessesdisposedDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DiscontinuedOperationsAssetsandliabilitiesofbusinessesdisposedDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsAssetsandliabilitiesofbusinessesdisposedDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_16bb6aef-b8f6-49f6-9905-c9d1934a3e09" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_16bb6aef-b8f6-49f6-9905-c9d1934a3e09" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_68052618-8c10-4ada-a83b-6f636eb7ee81" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_16bb6aef-b8f6-49f6-9905-c9d1934a3e09" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_68052618-8c10-4ada-a83b-6f636eb7ee81" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_68052618-8c10-4ada-a83b-6f636eb7ee81_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_68052618-8c10-4ada-a83b-6f636eb7ee81" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_68052618-8c10-4ada-a83b-6f636eb7ee81_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_936c6097-0b5b-42e6-bcc0-e4d4d665e2d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_68052618-8c10-4ada-a83b-6f636eb7ee81" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_936c6097-0b5b-42e6-bcc0-e4d4d665e2d6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_53b8c019-81ee-4d42-9ea9-a98ba2efb08c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_936c6097-0b5b-42e6-bcc0-e4d4d665e2d6" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_53b8c019-81ee-4d42-9ea9-a98ba2efb08c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationCashAndCashEquivalents_fe03cd7f-357e-45c2-bb66-ae4faa023453" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationCashAndCashEquivalents"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationCashAndCashEquivalents_fe03cd7f-357e-45c2-bb66-ae4faa023453" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsInvestments_c6b91530-647f-47b2-b562-6d5bc53733fd" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsInvestments_c6b91530-647f-47b2-b562-6d5bc53733fd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsReinsuranceRecoverablesOnPaidAndUnpaidLosses_a1967446-b64f-4dfd-885d-8633f0bbe2ae" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsReinsuranceRecoverablesOnPaidAndUnpaidLosses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsReinsuranceRecoverablesOnPaidAndUnpaidLosses_a1967446-b64f-4dfd-885d-8633f0bbe2ae" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherAssets_bd0ce9d3-fe35-4a2f-a0c0-4cd3d4ac83ba" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherAssets_bd0ce9d3-fe35-4a2f-a0c0-4cd3d4ac83ba" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsOfDisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperation_9307deb3-7108-4f35-99c7-21d6ef401608" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsOfDisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsOfDisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperation_9307deb3-7108-4f35-99c7-21d6ef401608" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLiabilityForFuturePolicyBenefitsIndividualAndGroupAnnuitiesAndSupplementaryContracts_da917065-d570-4edc-a82f-105ba061b09a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLiabilityForFuturePolicyBenefitsIndividualAndGroupAnnuitiesAndSupplementaryContracts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLiabilityForFuturePolicyBenefitsIndividualAndGroupAnnuitiesAndSupplementaryContracts_da917065-d570-4edc-a82f-105ba061b09a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherLiabilities_97a9027a-f4e7-4eff-bf3f-c8af76053c08" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherLiabilities_97a9027a-f4e7-4eff-bf3f-c8af76053c08" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesOfDisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperation_dba9ee70-245a-4193-bb41-73aebd7570df" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesOfDisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesOfDisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperation_dba9ee70-245a-4193-bb41-73aebd7570df" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_e0a3493b-660b-4443-afbd-ae7cc14e1049" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_e0a3493b-660b-4443-afbd-ae7cc14e1049" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_aeafa48e-811d-4a9b-95af-23d8ceaa5bcf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_afba0513-25f6-4954-a214-0e766c5108ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_aeafa48e-811d-4a9b-95af-23d8ceaa5bcf" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsDetailsoftheresultsoftheAnnuitysubsidiariessoldDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DiscontinuedOperationsDetailsoftheresultsoftheAnnuitysubsidiariessoldDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsDetailsoftheresultsoftheAnnuitysubsidiariessoldDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_4da27db0-b9f9-4f22-a1a9-a184b47e2495" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_4da27db0-b9f9-4f22-a1a9-a184b47e2495" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_ac3e7363-e297-4f87-9e40-a6ecea1bde33" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_4da27db0-b9f9-4f22-a1a9-a184b47e2495" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_ac3e7363-e297-4f87-9e40-a6ecea1bde33" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_ac3e7363-e297-4f87-9e40-a6ecea1bde33_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_ac3e7363-e297-4f87-9e40-a6ecea1bde33" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_ac3e7363-e297-4f87-9e40-a6ecea1bde33_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_f5a64731-4491-4eed-bf1e-6fa68b146f06" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_ac3e7363-e297-4f87-9e40-a6ecea1bde33" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_f5a64731-4491-4eed-bf1e-6fa68b146f06" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_e09173f5-eeb1-4507-b8c6-a7931eaa9a2f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_f5a64731-4491-4eed-bf1e-6fa68b146f06" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_e09173f5-eeb1-4507-b8c6-a7931eaa9a2f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_b980e85f-b322-43a7-a759-dd436927c46a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_4da27db0-b9f9-4f22-a1a9-a184b47e2495" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_b980e85f-b322-43a7-a759-dd436927c46a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_b980e85f-b322-43a7-a759-dd436927c46a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_b980e85f-b322-43a7-a759-dd436927c46a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_b980e85f-b322-43a7-a759-dd436927c46a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_cc4c40a9-9b51-48c3-8b63-8225aa55c5dc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_b980e85f-b322-43a7-a759-dd436927c46a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_cc4c40a9-9b51-48c3-8b63-8225aa55c5dc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDiscontinuedOperationsMember_36087202-e190-40b4-86d5-6bdf0d2e673d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDiscontinuedOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_cc4c40a9-9b51-48c3-8b63-8225aa55c5dc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDiscontinuedOperationsMember_36087202-e190-40b4-86d5-6bdf0d2e673d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationNetInvestmentIncome_dd58beb4-e584-4927-8f73-dbc730eb6a10" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationNetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationNetInvestmentIncome_dd58beb4-e584-4927-8f73-dbc730eb6a10" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsMarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_6dd0b261-7b44-4e66-8e67-9b3986ae940f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsMarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsMarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_6dd0b261-7b44-4e66-8e67-9b3986ae940f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherIncome_b633baa0-89b4-4668-b72d-0c81e39d63c9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherIncome_b633baa0-89b4-4668-b72d-0c81e39d63c9" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationRevenue_e2911381-5144-4f57-8150-d6f6d1892eca" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationRevenue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationRevenue_e2911381-5144-4f57-8150-d6f6d1892eca" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAnnuityBenefits_93a6daeb-575b-40c2-84af-43bab2523407" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAnnuityBenefits"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAnnuityBenefits_93a6daeb-575b-40c2-84af-43bab2523407" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAnnuityAndSupplementalInsuranceAcquisitionExpenses_fa54a1f0-600e-4447-984c-aca62840c23f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAnnuityAndSupplementalInsuranceAcquisitionExpenses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAnnuityAndSupplementalInsuranceAcquisitionExpenses_fa54a1f0-600e-4447-984c-aca62840c23f" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherExpense_d5f1d9b0-cdac-4bef-b50e-fbaf8b7b0945" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOtherExpense_d5f1d9b0-cdac-4bef-b50e-fbaf8b7b0945" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOperatingExpense_6835d646-9490-4ffc-986f-dcb5eac10c24" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOperatingExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationOperatingExpense_6835d646-9490-4ffc-986f-dcb5eac10c24" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationIncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationBeforeIncomeTax_4ae01497-44da-48c6-8e5a-019248256aae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationIncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationBeforeIncomeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationIncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationBeforeIncomeTax_4ae01497-44da-48c6-8e5a-019248256aae" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfDiscontinuedOperation_cb42ab70-10be-4674-8328-5cc9de05f575" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfDiscontinuedOperation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfDiscontinuedOperation_cb42ab70-10be-4674-8328-5cc9de05f575" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DiscontinuedOperationIncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationAfterIncomeTaxAndBeforeGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperation_171b4cf9-6d30-49a6-9921-7fbd0f424f24" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DiscontinuedOperationIncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationAfterIncomeTaxAndBeforeGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_afg_DiscontinuedOperationIncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationAfterIncomeTaxAndBeforeGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperation_171b4cf9-6d30-49a6-9921-7fbd0f424f24" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax_f28eeec4-14ee-49c6-81b1-10de23994f55" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax_f28eeec4-14ee-49c6-81b1-10de23994f55" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalStatementOfIncomeOrComprehensiveIncomeExtensibleEnumeration_0deae70b-1709-425a-903b-ded5680525f4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalStatementOfIncomeOrComprehensiveIncomeExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalStatementOfIncomeOrComprehensiveIncomeExtensibleEnumeration_0deae70b-1709-425a-903b-ded5680525f4" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationsNetOfTax_1507afc1-29f0-4741-b40c-19d7e3d7dddb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationsNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_d7630b27-6c49-4573-a35d-52c3060678b4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationsNetOfTax_1507afc1-29f0-4741-b40c-19d7e3d7dddb" xlink:type="arc" order="13"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsImpactofthesaleoftheannuitybusinessesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DiscontinuedOperationsImpactofthesaleoftheannuitybusinessesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsImpactofthesaleoftheannuitybusinessesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_923d5d1a-af00-4521-a04e-266ed9ae081c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_923d5d1a-af00-4521-a04e-266ed9ae081c" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_77642767-d4d4-4da9-bcf5-03611ac76542" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_923d5d1a-af00-4521-a04e-266ed9ae081c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_77642767-d4d4-4da9-bcf5-03611ac76542" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_77642767-d4d4-4da9-bcf5-03611ac76542_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_77642767-d4d4-4da9-bcf5-03611ac76542" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_77642767-d4d4-4da9-bcf5-03611ac76542_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_70d490d0-8299-4553-b558-96b07d49e937" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_77642767-d4d4-4da9-bcf5-03611ac76542" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_70d490d0-8299-4553-b558-96b07d49e937" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_db4e792e-ceb7-42ff-a592-70e4dd26dba7" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_70d490d0-8299-4553-b558-96b07d49e937" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_db4e792e-ceb7-42ff-a592-70e4dd26dba7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfInterestInConsolidatedSubsidiaries_f31323db-5fc4-4243-88d0-a93c6ab59a3a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfInterestInConsolidatedSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfInterestInConsolidatedSubsidiaries_f31323db-5fc4-4243-88d0-a93c6ab59a3a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsExpensesFromDivestitureOfBusinesses_46efbd57-0d86-4cb2-b1d5-05543550e255" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsExpensesFromDivestitureOfBusinesses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsExpensesFromDivestitureOfBusinesses_46efbd57-0d86-4cb2-b1d5-05543550e255" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinessesNet_a1e3ed3d-fd78-4a9f-a01c-a4290622b412" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinessesNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinessesNet_a1e3ed3d-fd78-4a9f-a01c-a4290622b412" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_88827355-44d5-4ee2-911a-3e56941596eb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_88827355-44d5-4ee2-911a-3e56941596eb" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsReclassificationOfNetDeferredTaxAssets_d851a338-c49a-4307-92a0-6d3441ba1577" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsReclassificationOfNetDeferredTaxAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisposalGroupIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsReclassificationOfNetDeferredTaxAssets_d851a338-c49a-4307-92a0-6d3441ba1577" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationBeforeIncomeTax_52e12e2d-7a93-41e0-a4aa-572ba274001b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationBeforeIncomeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationBeforeIncomeTax_52e12e2d-7a93-41e0-a4aa-572ba274001b" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OperatingTaxLiabilitiesTriggeredByPendingSale_33cedf6f-0628-45bf-9152-edd83e6a8eb2" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OperatingTaxLiabilitiesTriggeredByPendingSale"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_afg_OperatingTaxLiabilitiesTriggeredByPendingSale_33cedf6f-0628-45bf-9152-edd83e6a8eb2" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfIncomeLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationOther_dae9124c-3b50-4aec-82a6-c5ff4f836115" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfIncomeLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationOther"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_afg_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfIncomeLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationOther_dae9124c-3b50-4aec-82a6-c5ff4f836115" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfIncomeLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperation_495e72dc-240a-47fc-bc41-c18f14269e73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfIncomeLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationTaxEffectOfIncomeLossFromDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperation_495e72dc-240a-47fc-bc41-c18f14269e73" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax_ac3fceb5-5ea5-4226-8f56-a0a50d51e3e5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_381c8335-84e1-4f0a-a63b-6609b0edcf59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DiscontinuedOperationGainLossOnDisposalOfDiscontinuedOperationNetOfTax_ac3fceb5-5ea5-4226-8f56-a0a50d51e3e5" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsSummarizedcashflowinformationDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DiscontinuedOperationsSummarizedcashflowinformationDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DiscontinuedOperationsSummarizedcashflowinformationDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_438dd2fb-7b6f-4c49-9575-261a986b1c89" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_fe54c0a5-c6de-4991-861c-14925e4e2baa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_438dd2fb-7b6f-4c49-9575-261a986b1c89" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_fe54c0a5-c6de-4991-861c-14925e4e2baa" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_1fccd99e-5780-4fbb-b8ef-387887196b3e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_fe54c0a5-c6de-4991-861c-14925e4e2baa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_1fccd99e-5780-4fbb-b8ef-387887196b3e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_1fccd99e-5780-4fbb-b8ef-387887196b3e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_1fccd99e-5780-4fbb-b8ef-387887196b3e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_1fccd99e-5780-4fbb-b8ef-387887196b3e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_31d15941-84d6-44b0-891b-6e26f6f278a0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_1fccd99e-5780-4fbb-b8ef-387887196b3e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_31d15941-84d6-44b0-891b-6e26f6f278a0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_f495d33a-582b-4662-9632-a99e3f27c532" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_31d15941-84d6-44b0-891b-6e26f6f278a0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_f495d33a-582b-4662-9632-a99e3f27c532" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations_b871d08f-3daf-426f-8045-6185d80b4635" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_438dd2fb-7b6f-4c49-9575-261a986b1c89" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations_b871d08f-3daf-426f-8045-6185d80b4635" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations_a6d73d6c-6417-4c64-8d6c-89417a782985" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_438dd2fb-7b6f-4c49-9575-261a986b1c89" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations_a6d73d6c-6417-4c64-8d6c-89417a782985" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations_5fa47e56-f4a6-4398-babb-ec0c7ba3651f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_438dd2fb-7b6f-4c49-9575-261a986b1c89" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesDiscontinuedOperations_5fa47e56-f4a6-4398-babb-ec0c7ba3651f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesNarrativeonacquisitionsofsubsidiariesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesNarrativeonacquisitionsofsubsidiariesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesNarrativeonacquisitionsofsubsidiariesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_709db9ec-7105-49d9-87f1-d8a6e52ad6e1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_709db9ec-7105-49d9-87f1-d8a6e52ad6e1" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_61f3248b-fd4c-447c-a675-534e43ad5a8d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_709db9ec-7105-49d9-87f1-d8a6e52ad6e1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_61f3248b-fd4c-447c-a675-534e43ad5a8d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_61f3248b-fd4c-447c-a675-534e43ad5a8d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_61f3248b-fd4c-447c-a675-534e43ad5a8d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_61f3248b-fd4c-447c-a675-534e43ad5a8d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4ed03131-1a9d-4e33-81a4-57049f0e77c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_61f3248b-fd4c-447c-a675-534e43ad5a8d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4ed03131-1a9d-4e33-81a4-57049f0e77c0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_85a1a4b9-cfa9-4e6c-813a-9a966823bf77" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4ed03131-1a9d-4e33-81a4-57049f0e77c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_85a1a4b9-cfa9-4e6c-813a-9a966823bf77" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_21a55474-ec6e-4ad4-ac3e-98f1607a254b" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4ed03131-1a9d-4e33-81a4-57049f0e77c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_21a55474-ec6e-4ad4-ac3e-98f1607a254b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceAgencyMember_c657608c-45e0-4f42-bdaf-d0ab149483ed" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceAgencyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4ed03131-1a9d-4e33-81a4-57049f0e77c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceAgencyMember_c657608c-45e0-4f42-bdaf-d0ab149483ed" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NeonCapitalLimitedMember_d622f1b8-1c42-43ec-8210-4a68c570d67a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NeonCapitalLimitedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4ed03131-1a9d-4e33-81a4-57049f0e77c0" xlink:to="loc_afg_NeonCapitalLimitedMember_d622f1b8-1c42-43ec-8210-4a68c570d67a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_12661006-c293-4974-801f-783bda405615" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_709db9ec-7105-49d9-87f1-d8a6e52ad6e1" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_12661006-c293-4974-801f-783bda405615" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_12661006-c293-4974-801f-783bda405615_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_12661006-c293-4974-801f-783bda405615" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_12661006-c293-4974-801f-783bda405615_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_2ecdbed5-d5d8-449e-a504-2de1a1accd42" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearAxis_12661006-c293-4974-801f-783bda405615" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_2ecdbed5-d5d8-449e-a504-2de1a1accd42" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractCropYear2022Member_78d0f7c3-02af-4f14-b979-1624453fc447" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropInsuranceContractCropYear2022Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractsCropYearDomain_2ecdbed5-d5d8-449e-a504-2de1a1accd42" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropInsuranceContractCropYear2022Member_78d0f7c3-02af-4f14-b979-1624453fc447" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_b5b27040-4844-4f32-bc13-f9dc6712bea4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_709db9ec-7105-49d9-87f1-d8a6e52ad6e1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_b5b27040-4844-4f32-bc13-f9dc6712bea4" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_b5b27040-4844-4f32-bc13-f9dc6712bea4_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_b5b27040-4844-4f32-bc13-f9dc6712bea4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_b5b27040-4844-4f32-bc13-f9dc6712bea4_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_384dc766-c957-428b-bcf4-cac84fd076af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_b5b27040-4844-4f32-bc13-f9dc6712bea4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_384dc766-c957-428b-bcf4-cac84fd076af" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_8a885b3a-df8b-4e09-b5ff-8522367730a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_384dc766-c957-428b-bcf4-cac84fd076af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_8a885b3a-df8b-4e09-b5ff-8522367730a2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_0a1097bf-5c22-4fac-8c32-c9e4378cb9d9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_709db9ec-7105-49d9-87f1-d8a6e52ad6e1" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_0a1097bf-5c22-4fac-8c32-c9e4378cb9d9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_0a1097bf-5c22-4fac-8c32-c9e4378cb9d9_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_0a1097bf-5c22-4fac-8c32-c9e4378cb9d9" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_0a1097bf-5c22-4fac-8c32-c9e4378cb9d9_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_47f84d93-3884-4aa5-8367-5f7f795201fd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_0a1097bf-5c22-4fac-8c32-c9e4378cb9d9" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_47f84d93-3884-4aa5-8367-5f7f795201fd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_f6758918-30ec-461c-b3b0-9ef422bb5dbd" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_47f84d93-3884-4aa5-8367-5f7f795201fd" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_f6758918-30ec-461c-b3b0-9ef422bb5dbd" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenGross_352f335b-256c-41d6-93ab-ed0867e619a0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenGross_352f335b-256c-41d6-93ab-ed0867e619a0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_bc543b78-85c1-48ea-8875-a58cb23f964c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_bc543b78-85c1-48ea-8875-a58cb23f964c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_78f93eef-c775-4dae-8246-23627f55e9e3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_78f93eef-c775-4dae-8246-23627f55e9e3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionCostOfAcquiredEntityTransactionCosts_73525c3b-f4b9-4d4c-9858-03df78ae7ea0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionCostOfAcquiredEntityTransactionCosts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionCostOfAcquiredEntityTransactionCosts_73525c3b-f4b9-4d4c-9858-03df78ae7ea0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_b68d69e2-1979-4a25-b59b-8bcc73aa73f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_b68d69e2-1979-4a25-b59b-8bcc73aa73f9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetUsefulLife_8cb763e7-c2c9-4e9d-9299-f3e327634810" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetUsefulLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetUsefulLife_8cb763e7-c2c9-4e9d-9299-f3e327634810" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_d3f469c4-445d-4758-a86f-cddb4fbe498c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_d3f469c4-445d-4758-a86f-cddb4fbe498c" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionPurchasePriceAllocationGoodwillExpectedTaxDeductibleAmount_c2b20512-c469-4a0d-a667-c4ab1eb6efbf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionPurchasePriceAllocationGoodwillExpectedTaxDeductibleAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionPurchasePriceAllocationGoodwillExpectedTaxDeductibleAmount_c2b20512-c469-4a0d-a667-c4ab1eb6efbf" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationConsiderationTransferred1_4fa12d3d-fe23-4484-a450-b7264dea50ba" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationConsiderationTransferred1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_ef5f9761-0bcd-40b8-8ebe-14b47a45a338" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationConsiderationTransferred1_4fa12d3d-fe23-4484-a450-b7264dea50ba" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesNarrativeonsaleofbusinessesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesNarrativeonsaleofbusinessesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesNarrativeonsaleofbusinessesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_e7541b98-4fb3-4e3c-814d-8d36166b7b38" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_863e4ed4-88f2-4fb1-a8c5-b988f0e9a5d3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_e7541b98-4fb3-4e3c-814d-8d36166b7b38" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_863e4ed4-88f2-4fb1-a8c5-b988f0e9a5d3" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_03181472-58f6-4d27-a9e2-5428e1e6ff3c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsTable_863e4ed4-88f2-4fb1-a8c5-b988f0e9a5d3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_03181472-58f6-4d27-a9e2-5428e1e6ff3c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_03181472-58f6-4d27-a9e2-5428e1e6ff3c_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_03181472-58f6-4d27-a9e2-5428e1e6ff3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_03181472-58f6-4d27-a9e2-5428e1e6ff3c_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_c53e02a1-cebe-4a8e-825e-61a31ae96545" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_03181472-58f6-4d27-a9e2-5428e1e6ff3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_c53e02a1-cebe-4a8e-825e-61a31ae96545" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NeonCapitalLimitedMember_69155396-c574-4aab-8dea-468c66944862" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NeonCapitalLimitedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_c53e02a1-cebe-4a8e-825e-61a31ae96545" xlink:to="loc_afg_NeonCapitalLimitedMember_69155396-c574-4aab-8dea-468c66944862" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfInterestInConsolidatedSubsidiaries_b646f076-c051-4a2f-aca2-88946d37900d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfInterestInConsolidatedSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_e7541b98-4fb3-4e3c-814d-8d36166b7b38" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfInterestInConsolidatedSubsidiaries_b646f076-c051-4a2f-aca2-88946d37900d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary_e275297e-e2be-4129-a5fe-82ae508e468f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsLineItems_e7541b98-4fb3-4e3c-814d-8d36166b7b38" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary_e275297e-e2be-4129-a5fe-82ae508e468f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesAllocationofthepurchasepriceofsubsidiary1Details" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesAllocationofthepurchasepriceofsubsidiary1Details"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesAllocationofthepurchasepriceofsubsidiary1Details" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d5301d72-9665-420a-9b6c-ce5e15fbb8e0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d5301d72-9665-420a-9b6c-ce5e15fbb8e0" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_d162b6f9-adb8-4ef5-9455-2552c9a8b02b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d5301d72-9665-420a-9b6c-ce5e15fbb8e0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_d162b6f9-adb8-4ef5-9455-2552c9a8b02b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_d162b6f9-adb8-4ef5-9455-2552c9a8b02b_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_d162b6f9-adb8-4ef5-9455-2552c9a8b02b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_d162b6f9-adb8-4ef5-9455-2552c9a8b02b_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_a3abc902-24fa-43bf-87e6-11cdde06884c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_d162b6f9-adb8-4ef5-9455-2552c9a8b02b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_a3abc902-24fa-43bf-87e6-11cdde06884c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_b9eb4bfd-5148-45c5-9b90-dd7a6c8cbfd4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_a3abc902-24fa-43bf-87e6-11cdde06884c" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_b9eb4bfd-5148-45c5-9b90-dd7a6c8cbfd4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_c6fd47b2-65b5-40b3-b294-8a5a5b92abac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_d5301d72-9665-420a-9b6c-ce5e15fbb8e0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_c6fd47b2-65b5-40b3-b294-8a5a5b92abac" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_c6fd47b2-65b5-40b3-b294-8a5a5b92abac_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_c6fd47b2-65b5-40b3-b294-8a5a5b92abac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_c6fd47b2-65b5-40b3-b294-8a5a5b92abac_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_0a469656-e10f-4eb3-966a-7716872cd70c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsByMajorClassAxis_c6fd47b2-65b5-40b3-b294-8a5a5b92abac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_0a469656-e10f-4eb3-966a-7716872cd70c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_49d2bf67-491b-41d4-b99f-3993a834c6ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsMajorClassNameDomain_0a469656-e10f-4eb3-966a-7716872cd70c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CustomerRelationshipsMember_49d2bf67-491b-41d4-b99f-3993a834c6ff" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_a0051b9e-d343-4e46-8a47-384523878570" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_a0051b9e-d343-4e46-8a47-384523878570" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_2130eeb5-b759-45c6-b7ed-65da39e1c648" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_2130eeb5-b759-45c6-b7ed-65da39e1c648" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedCashAndEquivalents_b87fe4e3-de34-45d1-af48-88b3d0302520" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedCashAndEquivalents"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_2130eeb5-b759-45c6-b7ed-65da39e1c648" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedCashAndEquivalents_b87fe4e3-de34-45d1-af48-88b3d0302520" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAgentsBalancesAndPremiumsReceivable_14848e5a-1405-43be-bc0d-3a8195213dac" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAgentsBalancesAndPremiumsReceivable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_2130eeb5-b759-45c6-b7ed-65da39e1c648" xlink:to="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAgentsBalancesAndPremiumsReceivable_14848e5a-1405-43be-bc0d-3a8195213dac" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedOtherNoncurrentAssets_44dabdb2-73f6-46e3-acf9-806d1c751b77" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedOtherNoncurrentAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_2130eeb5-b759-45c6-b7ed-65da39e1c648" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedOtherNoncurrentAssets_44dabdb2-73f6-46e3-acf9-806d1c751b77" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets_1b226709-06eb-4778-a921-157597ad397e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssetsAbstract_2130eeb5-b759-45c6-b7ed-65da39e1c648" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets_1b226709-06eb-4778-a921-157597ad397e" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_eba5f80e-61d3-40f5-bf01-4347abcafec4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_eba5f80e-61d3-40f5-bf01-4347abcafec4" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNoncurrentLiabilitiesOther_7e87ea9a-e6af-47bc-9119-cd9d5e83b192" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNoncurrentLiabilitiesOther"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_eba5f80e-61d3-40f5-bf01-4347abcafec4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNoncurrentLiabilitiesOther_7e87ea9a-e6af-47bc-9119-cd9d5e83b192" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities_4ef3b041-c8ea-45a0-aca4-9505a7121a6c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilitiesAbstract_eba5f80e-61d3-40f5-bf01-4347abcafec4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities_4ef3b041-c8ea-45a0-aca4-9505a7121a6c" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_11bdc9df-5c6e-4d7c-9ad3-92cee5cc86c2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_11bdc9df-5c6e-4d7c-9ad3-92cee5cc86c2" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired_27115f6f-f05a-4b22-90c1-b8a7152fadca" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired_27115f6f-f05a-4b22-90c1-b8a7152fadca" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_1d3581ac-9812-4836-a8ed-513e0d1c22f9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedIntangibles_1d3581ac-9812-4836-a8ed-513e0d1c22f9" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedDeferredTaxAssets_0a25c7fd-7af8-4ff4-884e-037d146b7536" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedDeferredTaxAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedDeferredTaxAssets_0a25c7fd-7af8-4ff4-884e-037d146b7536" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_de8ba5d8-c855-45de-85e1-03bffbd8b305" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_e9c5218e-5c85-4ed3-9c7b-6f5d1f526475" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_de8ba5d8-c855-45de-85e1-03bffbd8b305" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesAllocationofthepurchasepriceofsubsidiary2Details" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesAllocationofthepurchasepriceofsubsidiary2Details"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/AcquisitionsandSaleofBusinessesAllocationofthepurchasepriceofsubsidiary2Details" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_28203253-62b9-4626-88b3-732dc3feabbc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_28203253-62b9-4626-88b3-732dc3feabbc" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_47d463f1-1001-4c88-858c-6d37d414fbc6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfBusinessAcquisitionsByAcquisitionTable_28203253-62b9-4626-88b3-732dc3feabbc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_47d463f1-1001-4c88-858c-6d37d414fbc6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_47d463f1-1001-4c88-858c-6d37d414fbc6_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_47d463f1-1001-4c88-858c-6d37d414fbc6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_47d463f1-1001-4c88-858c-6d37d414fbc6_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c2a95c2a-37ea-453e-8620-e37a005b3457" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_47d463f1-1001-4c88-858c-6d37d414fbc6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c2a95c2a-37ea-453e-8620-e37a005b3457" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_8b49361f-76c3-445f-91d7-de22c127e59e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c2a95c2a-37ea-453e-8620-e37a005b3457" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_8b49361f-76c3-445f-91d7-de22c127e59e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_686697e9-5a99-47d6-82f4-761ac488be9e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_686697e9-5a99-47d6-82f4-761ac488be9e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_e10d77fe-8c1b-4659-9a77-cdb43940301f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_e10d77fe-8c1b-4659-9a77-cdb43940301f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationConsiderationTransferred1_5e6b0063-5242-4b35-b7ca-a82e967ceece" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationConsiderationTransferred1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationConsiderationTransferred1_5e6b0063-5242-4b35-b7ca-a82e967ceece" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets_9565980a-154d-4371-b1a7-e936c9bf94d9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedAssets_9565980a-154d-4371-b1a7-e936c9bf94d9" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities_ac00ed4a-1930-4cef-88d5-2126b4427b40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredAndLiabilitiesAssumedLiabilities_ac00ed4a-1930-4cef-88d5-2126b4427b40" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredGoodwillAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_9a4f241f-529f-4d76-93b2-4f6cc855f4dc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredGoodwillAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredGoodwillAndLiabilitiesAssumedNet_9a4f241f-529f-4d76-93b2-4f6cc855f4dc" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired_dd333311-7d7a-40c2-b5df-077849fb8fb2" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_afg_BusinessCombinationRecognizedIdentifiableAssetsAcquiredandLiabilitiesAssumedExcessPurchasePriceOverNetTangibleAssetsAcquired_dd333311-7d7a-40c2-b5df-077849fb8fb2" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DeferredTaxLiabilitiesGoodwillAndIntangibleAssetsIntangibleAssets_de39b16e-dc27-4fe3-a6d4-a83a99ce55cc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DeferredTaxLiabilitiesGoodwillAndIntangibleAssetsIntangibleAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DeferredTaxLiabilitiesGoodwillAndIntangibleAssetsIntangibleAssets_de39b16e-dc27-4fe3-a6d4-a83a99ce55cc" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_e4e5ef2e-42f0-4a9c-baf7-081a1f287b37" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionLineItems_55fc247e-40bc-485c-a925-4c7b2ac3d2d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_e4e5ef2e-42f0-4a9c-baf7-081a1f287b37" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_829190b8-35c4-4c85-9d83-d185f58d5182" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_9da770d7-0a5d-400a-bbe1-69bbadbac428" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_829190b8-35c4-4c85-9d83-d185f58d5182" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_9da770d7-0a5d-400a-bbe1-69bbadbac428" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_7de80055-2fe9-484f-a2b6-c91f00e846d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_9da770d7-0a5d-400a-bbe1-69bbadbac428" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_7de80055-2fe9-484f-a2b6-c91f00e846d6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_7de80055-2fe9-484f-a2b6-c91f00e846d6_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_7de80055-2fe9-484f-a2b6-c91f00e846d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_7de80055-2fe9-484f-a2b6-c91f00e846d6_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_924593ca-b524-4953-b1e5-048603541d82" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_7de80055-2fe9-484f-a2b6-c91f00e846d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_924593ca-b524-4953-b1e5-048603541d82" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_e27c0743-f58c-4cfb-b329-925798187e8f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_924593ca-b524-4953-b1e5-048603541d82" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_e27c0743-f58c-4cfb-b329-925798187e8f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NumberOfReportableSegments_8485bf12-79f0-428d-aa4e-674cbf74d3d4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NumberOfReportableSegments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_829190b8-35c4-4c85-9d83-d185f58d5182" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NumberOfReportableSegments_8485bf12-79f0-428d-aa4e-674cbf74d3d4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DisclosureOnGeographicAreasPropertyAndCasualtyRevenuesAttributedToForeignCountries_6ec0a713-47be-4a73-8870-28fa62d7b960" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DisclosureOnGeographicAreasPropertyAndCasualtyRevenuesAttributedToForeignCountries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_829190b8-35c4-4c85-9d83-d185f58d5182" xlink:to="loc_afg_DisclosureOnGeographicAreasPropertyAndCasualtyRevenuesAttributedToForeignCountries_6ec0a713-47be-4a73-8870-28fa62d7b960" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt_d80d96c9-32af-4041-9d91-268633df7d81" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_829190b8-35c4-4c85-9d83-d185f58d5182" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt_d80d96c9-32af-4041-9d91-268633df7d81" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease_45ce8e1f-deaf-42bc-b4c0-997970e0103d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_829190b8-35c4-4c85-9d83-d185f58d5182" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease_45ce8e1f-deaf-42bc-b4c0-997970e0103d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsAssetsbysegmentDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsAssetsbysegmentDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsAssetsbysegmentDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_09211687-d28c-45be-bb67-6b8db574ed59" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83caceaf-ee51-4ee0-af39-bb809879d098" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_09211687-d28c-45be-bb67-6b8db574ed59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83caceaf-ee51-4ee0-af39-bb809879d098" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_ec069ce5-701e-4eef-bdb8-0dacad8e90d1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_83caceaf-ee51-4ee0-af39-bb809879d098" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_ec069ce5-701e-4eef-bdb8-0dacad8e90d1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_ec069ce5-701e-4eef-bdb8-0dacad8e90d1_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_ec069ce5-701e-4eef-bdb8-0dacad8e90d1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_ec069ce5-701e-4eef-bdb8-0dacad8e90d1_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19e94c1d-e915-4747-9455-a6d10129d456" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_ec069ce5-701e-4eef-bdb8-0dacad8e90d1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19e94c1d-e915-4747-9455-a6d10129d456" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_79432c19-77fa-489f-8d5f-cd627cd23df8" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19e94c1d-e915-4747-9455-a6d10129d456" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_79432c19-77fa-489f-8d5f-cd627cd23df8" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_bb050045-8eae-4e57-9660-27231e8863d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19e94c1d-e915-4747-9455-a6d10129d456" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_bb050045-8eae-4e57-9660-27231e8863d6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Assets_7229a102-80ec-4972-bfdc-adda9a910c9e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Assets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_09211687-d28c-45be-bb67-6b8db574ed59" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Assets_7229a102-80ec-4972-bfdc-adda9a910c9e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsRevenuesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsRevenuesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsRevenuesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_e8a182a7-c728-4e51-b27c-6485f3e3aa26" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_e8a182a7-c728-4e51-b27c-6485f3e3aa26" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_7b6be310-3d66-4329-a989-4a46e1a4a94a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_e8a182a7-c728-4e51-b27c-6485f3e3aa26" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_7b6be310-3d66-4329-a989-4a46e1a4a94a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_7b6be310-3d66-4329-a989-4a46e1a4a94a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_7b6be310-3d66-4329-a989-4a46e1a4a94a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_7b6be310-3d66-4329-a989-4a46e1a4a94a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_03290815-3eb2-40d2-80ab-5086cfb9ad78" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_7b6be310-3d66-4329-a989-4a46e1a4a94a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_03290815-3eb2-40d2-80ab-5086cfb9ad78" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_60e1953a-8042-42cd-8fc3-24722dec09f1" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_03290815-3eb2-40d2-80ab-5086cfb9ad78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_60e1953a-8042-42cd-8fc3-24722dec09f1" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_3c5721f3-1bc6-4f1d-9e75-6b9c9dd9930f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_03290815-3eb2-40d2-80ab-5086cfb9ad78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_3c5721f3-1bc6-4f1d-9e75-6b9c9dd9930f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_7a2a2dbb-84f6-430c-a247-bbf761861c89" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_03290815-3eb2-40d2-80ab-5086cfb9ad78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_7a2a2dbb-84f6-430c-a247-bbf761861c89" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_cceeb7a1-7637-4494-a312-0239383d5cdf" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_03290815-3eb2-40d2-80ab-5086cfb9ad78" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_cceeb7a1-7637-4494-a312-0239383d5cdf" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_fd960ee8-9918-4647-96a8-a75f97ffb5e8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_e8a182a7-c728-4e51-b27c-6485f3e3aa26" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_fd960ee8-9918-4647-96a8-a75f97ffb5e8" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_fd960ee8-9918-4647-96a8-a75f97ffb5e8_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_fd960ee8-9918-4647-96a8-a75f97ffb5e8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_fd960ee8-9918-4647-96a8-a75f97ffb5e8_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_577b0772-70d1-4cc4-9a48-af99e881a281" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_fd960ee8-9918-4647-96a8-a75f97ffb5e8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_577b0772-70d1-4cc4-9a48-af99e881a281" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_afb3c193-714a-4f28-a989-96be44c26b17" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_577b0772-70d1-4cc4-9a48-af99e881a281" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_afb3c193-714a-4f28-a989-96be44c26b17" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_09f8f382-4e41-491a-8d53-959a765b1165" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_577b0772-70d1-4cc4-9a48-af99e881a281" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_09f8f382-4e41-491a-8d53-959a765b1165" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_f7591b56-7506-4daa-b9b3-bcb4da0046d8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_e8a182a7-c728-4e51-b27c-6485f3e3aa26" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_f7591b56-7506-4daa-b9b3-bcb4da0046d8" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_f7591b56-7506-4daa-b9b3-bcb4da0046d8_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_f7591b56-7506-4daa-b9b3-bcb4da0046d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_f7591b56-7506-4daa-b9b3-bcb4da0046d8_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_39b98aac-9cf4-470d-8ca3-3d1c92b4ee10" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_f7591b56-7506-4daa-b9b3-bcb4da0046d8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_39b98aac-9cf4-470d-8ca3-3d1c92b4ee10" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_3b679512-29fd-45b9-874a-87a4c18e4397" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_39b98aac-9cf4-470d-8ca3-3d1c92b4ee10" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_3b679512-29fd-45b9-874a-87a4c18e4397" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty_8b78a573-9ad4-4cb6-91ea-f165f9fe8046" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNetPropertyAndCasualty_8b78a573-9ad4-4cb6-91ea-f165f9fe8046" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_88c085a5-6b27-4b45-acd2-4fb5d628492d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_88c085a5-6b27-4b45-acd2-4fb5d628492d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherIncome_eda75289-6c6d-45aa-8780-6f363284616c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherIncome_eda75289-6c6d-45aa-8780-6f363284616c" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RevenuesBeforeRealizedGainsLosses_77b6d7c5-c109-4901-9886-ea517fc9cd4a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_RevenuesBeforeRealizedGainsLosses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_afg_RevenuesBeforeRealizedGainsLosses_77b6d7c5-c109-4901-9886-ea517fc9cd4a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeExtensibleEnumeration_035a427d-7334-477c-a8f7-0876f746c5ab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeExtensibleEnumeration_035a427d-7334-477c-a8f7-0876f746c5ab" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_ba528487-ff42-44b5-b991-d1ef9ecfb378" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_ba528487-ff42-44b5-b991-d1ef9ecfb378" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary_21b22724-499c-4c25-836a-b8ceacdac11e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary_21b22724-499c-4c25-836a-b8ceacdac11e" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_55068f33-ecc3-46a2-bda5-998d48de8ef1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Revenues"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_c4f598a2-6275-4061-9bff-de6e2cb98e6c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_55068f33-ecc3-46a2-bda5-998d48de8ef1" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsEarningsbeforeincometaxesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#SegmentsofOperationsEarningsbeforeincometaxesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SegmentsofOperationsEarningsbeforeincometaxesbysegmentandsubsegmentDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_77fae4ad-1f5f-4c01-9e5c-014f9b814c5e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_77fae4ad-1f5f-4c01-9e5c-014f9b814c5e" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_b7620b05-1423-4f6c-b1c7-e2fc0db41493" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_77fae4ad-1f5f-4c01-9e5c-014f9b814c5e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_b7620b05-1423-4f6c-b1c7-e2fc0db41493" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b7620b05-1423-4f6c-b1c7-e2fc0db41493_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_b7620b05-1423-4f6c-b1c7-e2fc0db41493" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_b7620b05-1423-4f6c-b1c7-e2fc0db41493_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_b7620b05-1423-4f6c-b1c7-e2fc0db41493" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_6716e8bf-e1e6-458d-9dff-d28269945518" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_6716e8bf-e1e6-458d-9dff-d28269945518" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_0b69e133-7aa1-4d74-8c40-9b29b35e37ef" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_0b69e133-7aa1-4d74-8c40-9b29b35e37ef" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_6d68ec13-7393-49e0-91e0-359823e2c364" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_6d68ec13-7393-49e0-91e0-359823e2c364" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_94efe167-c9bc-4789-961c-a8a7d64935ee" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_94efe167-c9bc-4789-961c-a8a7d64935ee" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherLinesMember_be65c7a9-d196-4967-94e4-958e8f3613bc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherLinesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_f4e53f73-3ef7-461f-b1a1-6fbf11533649" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherLinesMember_be65c7a9-d196-4967-94e4-958e8f3613bc" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_04b71c8c-908b-49e4-b5ad-6fbf721d9655" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_77fae4ad-1f5f-4c01-9e5c-014f9b814c5e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_04b71c8c-908b-49e4-b5ad-6fbf721d9655" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_04b71c8c-908b-49e4-b5ad-6fbf721d9655_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_04b71c8c-908b-49e4-b5ad-6fbf721d9655" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_04b71c8c-908b-49e4-b5ad-6fbf721d9655_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19c721ca-f050-4200-b04a-16d026c228f5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_04b71c8c-908b-49e4-b5ad-6fbf721d9655" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19c721ca-f050-4200-b04a-16d026c228f5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_8a407430-0df1-44f2-9e26-b0926bcdd1e3" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19c721ca-f050-4200-b04a-16d026c228f5" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_8a407430-0df1-44f2-9e26-b0926bcdd1e3" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_125a7a61-9b2c-466e-b9a5-f995d95d538f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_19c721ca-f050-4200-b04a-16d026c228f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_125a7a61-9b2c-466e-b9a5-f995d95d538f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_2ee9c75e-a9c7-421d-ab8b-e12eba3a65ac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfSegmentReportingInformationBySegmentTable_77fae4ad-1f5f-4c01-9e5c-014f9b814c5e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_2ee9c75e-a9c7-421d-ab8b-e12eba3a65ac" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_2ee9c75e-a9c7-421d-ab8b-e12eba3a65ac_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_2ee9c75e-a9c7-421d-ab8b-e12eba3a65ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_2ee9c75e-a9c7-421d-ab8b-e12eba3a65ac_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_9cede961-e090-4557-af66-31c1ede43249" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_2ee9c75e-a9c7-421d-ab8b-e12eba3a65ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_9cede961-e090-4557-af66-31c1ede43249" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_c888c9a0-99c8-4a83-ac66-036f9570c561" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_9cede961-e090-4557-af66-31c1ede43249" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_c888c9a0-99c8-4a83-ac66-036f9570c561" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritingIncomeLoss_32fb4d22-405b-4944-abbe-154cdc64eeb3" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritingIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritingIncomeLoss_32fb4d22-405b-4944-abbe-154cdc64eeb3" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncomeNet_ef146545-f843-43bb-b52e-a0d9f158caca" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncomeNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncomeNet_ef146545-f843-43bb-b52e-a0d9f158caca" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OperatingIncomeLossBeforeRealizedGainsLossesAndIncomeTaxes_eb0d8ddf-fb44-4654-9565-a37e82bbd296" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OperatingIncomeLossBeforeRealizedGainsLossesAndIncomeTaxes"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_afg_OperatingIncomeLossBeforeRealizedGainsLossesAndIncomeTaxes_eb0d8ddf-fb44-4654-9565-a37e82bbd296" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EarningsFromRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsNetOfDAC_76b82179-e288-4247-a15f-854d5ec04c1c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EarningsFromRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsNetOfDAC"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_afg_EarningsFromRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsNetOfDAC_76b82179-e288-4247-a15f-854d5ec04c1c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_a6af17cd-ccdc-4c78-88e6-bb4c14504713" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_a6af17cd-ccdc-4c78-88e6-bb4c14504713" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary_40fe0e4d-014f-4f10-82a5-c48cad9c6559" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainOrLossOnSaleOfStockInSubsidiary_40fe0e4d-014f-4f10-82a5-c48cad9c6559" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss_aa9449d2-168c-4207-92b0-4e5ffb4f2bd0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentReportingInformationLineItems_eff536d9-8105-4b4e-bb2a-178077f18048" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss_aa9449d2-168c-4207-92b0-4e5ffb4f2bd0" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_8ff1d2e4-97d9-4ef5-b26a-1cdacbf5e235" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_d4e293ad-4830-4ac6-a3fa-ddde1a567ce4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_8ff1d2e4-97d9-4ef5-b26a-1cdacbf5e235" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_d4e293ad-4830-4ac6-a3fa-ddde1a567ce4" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_c9e59733-816f-468b-8b16-ed69ecaabff0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_d4e293ad-4830-4ac6-a3fa-ddde1a567ce4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_c9e59733-816f-468b-8b16-ed69ecaabff0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_c9e59733-816f-468b-8b16-ed69ecaabff0_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_c9e59733-816f-468b-8b16-ed69ecaabff0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_c9e59733-816f-468b-8b16-ed69ecaabff0_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fff5fb7c-4d63-4f75-acbb-e1b76c33e286" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_c9e59733-816f-468b-8b16-ed69ecaabff0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fff5fb7c-4d63-4f75-acbb-e1b76c33e286" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_98a36744-07a7-4c72-9170-65c5432ee1b2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_fff5fb7c-4d63-4f75-acbb-e1b76c33e286" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_98a36744-07a7-4c72-9170-65c5432ee1b2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_5b4df54f-4e23-4663-9098-5bdeb96c0b86" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_d4e293ad-4830-4ac6-a3fa-ddde1a567ce4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_5b4df54f-4e23-4663-9098-5bdeb96c0b86" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_5b4df54f-4e23-4663-9098-5bdeb96c0b86_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_5b4df54f-4e23-4663-9098-5bdeb96c0b86" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_5b4df54f-4e23-4663-9098-5bdeb96c0b86_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_abebbd8f-c94e-4630-9799-977f5af738c3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_5b4df54f-4e23-4663-9098-5bdeb96c0b86" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_abebbd8f-c94e-4630-9799-977f5af738c3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_7f231ea0-8821-4789-8813-bc08879794fa" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_abebbd8f-c94e-4630-9799-977f5af738c3" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_7f231ea0-8821-4789-8813-bc08879794fa" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_31d92ff0-1927-4046-8aa0-52b94be4eff6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_d4e293ad-4830-4ac6-a3fa-ddde1a567ce4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_31d92ff0-1927-4046-8aa0-52b94be4eff6" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_31d92ff0-1927-4046-8aa0-52b94be4eff6_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_31d92ff0-1927-4046-8aa0-52b94be4eff6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_31d92ff0-1927-4046-8aa0-52b94be4eff6_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_fb960ea2-93e9-4019-93be-7b96718c3030" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_31d92ff0-1927-4046-8aa0-52b94be4eff6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_fb960ea2-93e9-4019-93be-7b96718c3030" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_70a64d25-d6a8-4df0-ae09-04705427ff86" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_fb960ea2-93e9-4019-93be-7b96718c3030" xlink:to="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_70a64d25-d6a8-4df0-ae09-04705427ff86" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_8ff1d2e4-97d9-4ef5-b26a-1cdacbf5e235" xlink:to="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationArrangementsRangeOfOutcomesValueHigh_f8e1aa9b-47ec-46d8-b383-d6dbc9548212" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationArrangementsRangeOfOutcomesValueHigh"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationArrangementsRangeOfOutcomesValueHigh_f8e1aa9b-47ec-46d8-b383-d6dbc9548212" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_2d3b4043-0d79-43a5-be45-386bfa036735" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_2d3b4043-0d79-43a5-be45-386bfa036735" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationArrangementsChangeInAmountOfContingentConsiderationLiability1_1194fb89-8fc9-422e-b832-ea0342e6cf29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationArrangementsChangeInAmountOfContingentConsiderationLiability1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationArrangementsChangeInAmountOfContingentConsiderationLiability1_1194fb89-8fc9-422e-b832-ea0342e6cf29" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss_6ec58560-9aa7-43e6-8725-ef675b480439" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss_6ec58560-9aa7-43e6-8725-ef675b480439" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfInternalInvestmentProfessionals_63efdb49-2559-436b-949d-d6c8368bae8c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NumberOfInternalInvestmentProfessionals"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfInternalInvestmentProfessionals_63efdb49-2559-436b-949d-d6c8368bae8c" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetAsPercentageOfAssetMeasuredAtFairValue_04ed99cb-7dc5-4e2a-b291-fc672886910e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LevelThreeAssetAsPercentageOfAssetMeasuredAtFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetAsPercentageOfAssetMeasuredAtFairValue_04ed99cb-7dc5-4e2a-b291-fc672886910e" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingNonBindingBrokerQuotes_352e9c89-6c15-4333-9063-1ad8bd1c15cb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingNonBindingBrokerQuotes"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingNonBindingBrokerQuotes_352e9c89-6c15-4333-9063-1ad8bd1c15cb" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingNonBindingBrokerQuotes_dc47f491-0672-46b0-ad16-9a0fdaed428c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingNonBindingBrokerQuotes"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingNonBindingBrokerQuotes_dc47f491-0672-46b0-ad16-9a0fdaed428c" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedByPricingServices_c22279ea-6093-4c01-ab8d-f899714f9219" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedByPricingServices"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedByPricingServices_c22279ea-6093-4c01-ab8d-f899714f9219" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedByPricingServices_569f8c34-5434-486f-a272-91d399135541" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedByPricingServices"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedByPricingServices_569f8c34-5434-486f-a272-91d399135541" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsEquityInvestmentsThatDoNotQualifyForEquityAccounting_8bfd3a6d-aa93-4c1d-aa06-8ec11cdb1d5c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsEquityInvestmentsThatDoNotQualifyForEquityAccounting"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsEquityInvestmentsThatDoNotQualifyForEquityAccounting_8bfd3a6d-aa93-4c1d-aa06-8ec11cdb1d5c" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsEquityInvestmentsThatDoNotQualifyForEquityAccounting_aa9af364-e945-47d8-8e8e-cd330103ada3" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LevelThreeAssetsEquityInvestmentsThatDoNotQualifyForEquityAccounting"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsEquityInvestmentsThatDoNotQualifyForEquityAccounting_aa9af364-e945-47d8-8e8e-cd330103ada3" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InternallyDevelopedLevel3Assets_3d91189a-c603-49b6-9c1c-6a3052bce872" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InternallyDevelopedLevel3Assets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_InternallyDevelopedLevel3Assets_3d91189a-c603-49b6-9c1c-6a3052bce872" xlink:type="arc" order="13"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfInternallyDevelopedLevelThreeAssetsComparedToTotalLevel3Assets_980bea98-a0ce-4ca9-9e76-611aa0cd6f83" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfInternallyDevelopedLevelThreeAssetsComparedToTotalLevel3Assets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfInternallyDevelopedLevelThreeAssetsComparedToTotalLevel3Assets_980bea98-a0ce-4ca9-9e76-611aa0cd6f83" xlink:type="arc" order="14"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingADiscountedCashFlowApproach_adfcf463-af16-4bbf-b7ee-94f16c188f91" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingADiscountedCashFlowApproach"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingADiscountedCashFlowApproach_adfcf463-af16-4bbf-b7ee-94f16c188f91" xlink:type="arc" order="15"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingADiscountedCashFlowApproach_25df41c7-bec2-4df7-9e46-b1f1a0621153" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingADiscountedCashFlowApproach"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsThatWerePricedUsingADiscountedCashFlowApproach_25df41c7-bec2-4df7-9e46-b1f1a0621153" xlink:type="arc" order="16"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsEquitySecuritiesPricedUsingBrokerQuotesAndInternalModels_1a0d994b-9bda-466f-afc7-17a6a0b089fa" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsEquitySecuritiesPricedUsingBrokerQuotesAndInternalModels"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfLevelThreeAssetsEquitySecuritiesPricedUsingBrokerQuotesAndInternalModels_1a0d994b-9bda-466f-afc7-17a6a0b089fa" xlink:type="arc" order="17"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsEquitySecuritiesPricedUsingBrokerQuotesAndInternalModels_9a4f99a3-507c-4f8e-9713-72a371d05195" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LevelThreeAssetsEquitySecuritiesPricedUsingBrokerQuotesAndInternalModels"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementsTextualAbstract_02f3d9ad-1023-43a2-aed9-a1e746625071" xlink:to="loc_afg_LevelThreeAssetsEquitySecuritiesPricedUsingBrokerQuotesAndInternalModels_9a4f99a3-507c-4f8e-9713-72a371d05195" xlink:type="arc" order="18"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsAssetsandliabilitiesmeasuredandcarriedatfairvalueinthefinancialstatementsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsAssetsandliabilitiesmeasuredandcarriedatfairvalueinthefinancialstatementsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsAssetsandliabilitiesmeasuredandcarriedatfairvalueinthefinancialstatementsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_4804589d-7819-44ad-a058-ff42f59dc1fc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_398b0411-c868-46c1-babd-e4bae2b96b80" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_4804589d-7819-44ad-a058-ff42f59dc1fc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_398b0411-c868-46c1-babd-e4bae2b96b80" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_ad4ae60c-d6d4-425e-a5c8-78d01c0c4ed1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_398b0411-c868-46c1-babd-e4bae2b96b80" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_ad4ae60c-d6d4-425e-a5c8-78d01c0c4ed1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ad4ae60c-d6d4-425e-a5c8-78d01c0c4ed1_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_ad4ae60c-d6d4-425e-a5c8-78d01c0c4ed1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ad4ae60c-d6d4-425e-a5c8-78d01c0c4ed1_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_57294dda-5279-4146-bf9d-a77fa7133f4a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_ad4ae60c-d6d4-425e-a5c8-78d01c0c4ed1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_57294dda-5279-4146-bf9d-a77fa7133f4a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_dc3047ef-ba93-4c44-a516-b79ca924871b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_57294dda-5279-4146-bf9d-a77fa7133f4a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_dc3047ef-ba93-4c44-a516-b79ca924871b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_7b5df7e1-150f-4bcc-b921-220ce1bb4266" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_57294dda-5279-4146-bf9d-a77fa7133f4a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_7b5df7e1-150f-4bcc-b921-220ce1bb4266" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_acb3efea-0deb-4ad8-8ecd-502aec61ec21" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_57294dda-5279-4146-bf9d-a77fa7133f4a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_acb3efea-0deb-4ad8-8ecd-502aec61ec21" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_e9cd3ecc-1996-4fd0-a790-83f4e3176a8b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_398b0411-c868-46c1-babd-e4bae2b96b80" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_e9cd3ecc-1996-4fd0-a790-83f4e3176a8b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e9cd3ecc-1996-4fd0-a790-83f4e3176a8b_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_e9cd3ecc-1996-4fd0-a790-83f4e3176a8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e9cd3ecc-1996-4fd0-a790-83f4e3176a8b_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e2ee669a-5186-4a97-847b-4bc5a3ace37d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_e9cd3ecc-1996-4fd0-a790-83f4e3176a8b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e2ee669a-5186-4a97-847b-4bc5a3ace37d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e2ee669a-5186-4a97-847b-4bc5a3ace37d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_617cffe9-7131-47f3-a2b4-840215645759" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_617cffe9-7131-47f3-a2b4-840215645759" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_8b42a053-40bf-4d70-9bbb-8984982dbe1a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_8b42a053-40bf-4d70-9bbb-8984982dbe1a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_1d678b5a-955f-4147-b142-33d0885ca1af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_1d678b5a-955f-4147-b142-33d0885ca1af" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_84065b98-f46b-4924-b7a4-0a66f137bf88" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_84065b98-f46b-4924-b7a4-0a66f137bf88" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_cb44f0da-81df-4737-96ec-c439dbbaf779" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_cb44f0da-81df-4737-96ec-c439dbbaf779" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_132e5652-dcd2-453e-bc1e-bc118e49d723" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_132e5652-dcd2-453e-bc1e-bc118e49d723" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_caa68ba2-fb06-4ced-976d-3860615ee423" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_caa68ba2-fb06-4ced-976d-3860615ee423" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_82a58296-e129-4497-859c-8f29088d61a1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_f9bfa984-4623-462d-82ec-f7e73c343e1a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_82a58296-e129-4497-859c-8f29088d61a1" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_ae45ab03-2f58-45cc-800a-cf0edffb1c8c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e2ee669a-5186-4a97-847b-4bc5a3ace37d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_ae45ab03-2f58-45cc-800a-cf0edffb1c8c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssetsMember_e1151511-39b8-4d8b-a6b7-6cac54133592" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherAssetsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_e2ee669a-5186-4a97-847b-4bc5a3ace37d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssetsMember_e1151511-39b8-4d8b-a6b7-6cac54133592" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_1a15ff7f-1b35-4e47-8160-d4a12e6b5ea1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisTable_398b0411-c868-46c1-babd-e4bae2b96b80" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_1a15ff7f-1b35-4e47-8160-d4a12e6b5ea1" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_1a15ff7f-1b35-4e47-8160-d4a12e6b5ea1_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_1a15ff7f-1b35-4e47-8160-d4a12e6b5ea1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_1a15ff7f-1b35-4e47-8160-d4a12e6b5ea1_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_cb45760f-fea7-461a-bf7d-9f2eaf65e699" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_1a15ff7f-1b35-4e47-8160-d4a12e6b5ea1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_cb45760f-fea7-461a-bf7d-9f2eaf65e699" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_6a027259-e4a5-4643-8cc7-2d571a8e98a9" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_cb45760f-fea7-461a-bf7d-9f2eaf65e699" xlink:to="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_6a027259-e4a5-4643-8cc7-2d571a8e98a9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilitiesMember_e3156c1e-8a13-4846-bf3e-6d5768e5996a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLiabilitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_cb45760f-fea7-461a-bf7d-9f2eaf65e699" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilitiesMember_e3156c1e-8a13-4846-bf3e-6d5768e5996a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_7c23ba3d-895b-4e6d-9471-2a8725c9fdf9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisLineItems_4804589d-7819-44ad-a058-ff42f59dc1fc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_7c23ba3d-895b-4e6d-9471-2a8725c9fdf9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_7c23ba3d-895b-4e6d-9471-2a8725c9fdf9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_00515340-6585-4296-ad2c-9a65aeb642d7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_00515340-6585-4296-ad2c-9a65aeb642d7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt_aedb51b2-dc05-48d2-a8ef-1422b31b9145" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TradingSecuritiesDebt_aedb51b2-dc05-48d2-a8ef-1422b31b9145" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_786eaccf-acb4-432d-a5d5-e9dd9c0cbbd0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_786eaccf-acb4-432d-a5d5-e9dd9c0cbbd0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_e23cb165-8714-4c04-81ac-e7df60b0f45c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityAssets_e23cb165-8714-4c04-81ac-e7df60b0f45c" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_f7c6b174-86a4-4214-959a-ecb0c91af699" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_f7c6b174-86a4-4214-959a-ecb0c91af699" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosure_22072042-d381-4337-81f5-fa967c17cfc6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosureAbstract_1a62d08c-85fb-46b6-91f7-abd2ca1cad9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsFairValueDisclosure_22072042-d381-4337-81f5-fa967c17cfc6" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_c790416b-6bc4-4461-8a50-47ab96a7567f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsAndLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringAndNonrecurringBasisAbstract_7c23ba3d-895b-4e6d-9471-2a8725c9fdf9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_c790416b-6bc4-4461-8a50-47ab96a7567f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_44c4fa73-13cc-4a45-85e5-3ed21c7c8512" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_c790416b-6bc4-4461-8a50-47ab96a7567f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessCombinationContingentConsiderationLiability_44c4fa73-13cc-4a45-85e5-3ed21c7c8512" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_df7a8007-ac5a-4acc-904e-0e55a823c4ed" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_c790416b-6bc4-4461-8a50-47ab96a7567f" xlink:to="loc_afg_VariableInterestEntityLiabilities_df7a8007-ac5a-4acc-904e-0e55a823c4ed" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_6cc60ab6-c20e-49aa-8d35-82667ad0119a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_c790416b-6bc4-4461-8a50-47ab96a7567f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_6cc60ab6-c20e-49aa-8d35-82667ad0119a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosure_a487a2fc-d320-4636-8c37-f87085194a60" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosureAbstract_c790416b-6bc4-4461-8a50-47ab96a7567f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesFairValueDisclosure_a487a2fc-d320-4636-8c37-f87085194a60" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialassetscarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialassetscarriedatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialassetscarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a8b0ba6f-22ec-4162-86e0-bc0d864891f2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_080f79e4-d1e6-4462-90a0-5dbcebc5d821" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a8b0ba6f-22ec-4162-86e0-bc0d864891f2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_080f79e4-d1e6-4462-90a0-5dbcebc5d821" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_c2f911e9-be99-4842-9d88-27037c363a21" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_080f79e4-d1e6-4462-90a0-5dbcebc5d821" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_c2f911e9-be99-4842-9d88-27037c363a21" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_c2f911e9-be99-4842-9d88-27037c363a21_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_c2f911e9-be99-4842-9d88-27037c363a21" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_c2f911e9-be99-4842-9d88-27037c363a21_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_047f70fc-7988-4462-8d36-20a0d23153d5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByAssetClassAxis_c2f911e9-be99-4842-9d88-27037c363a21" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_047f70fc-7988-4462-8d36-20a0d23153d5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_047f70fc-7988-4462-8d36-20a0d23153d5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_267dc19c-da45-4265-a649-b787233d9d46" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_267dc19c-da45-4265-a649-b787233d9d46" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_ad226f02-3e46-4c0c-8224-810710a2f405" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_ad226f02-3e46-4c0c-8224-810710a2f405" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_0571cb3c-2d38-4e80-a957-4257049af14f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_0571cb3c-2d38-4e80-a957-4257049af14f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_1dfd4a86-4e58-497a-8942-68d5afac71f4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_1dfd4a86-4e58-497a-8942-68d5afac71f4" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_cc49ba81-b398-48eb-8e33-ba29388b41ce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_cc49ba81-b398-48eb-8e33-ba29388b41ce" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_51e82e54-e0f6-4e24-bd56-888da58e2b57" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_51e82e54-e0f6-4e24-bd56-888da58e2b57" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_b5dad977-e810-4133-a7b7-48a71b55fd4b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_57fcfa7d-84a6-41cd-b563-225eaebe26c7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_b5dad977-e810-4133-a7b7-48a71b55fd4b" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_62aa066a-03b5-4478-85e8-81099014c516" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_047f70fc-7988-4462-8d36-20a0d23153d5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_62aa066a-03b5-4478-85e8-81099014c516" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AssetsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesMember_ed106e92-534e-4611-b063-d83d82cb1a22" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AssetsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_047f70fc-7988-4462-8d36-20a0d23153d5" xlink:to="loc_afg_AssetsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesMember_ed106e92-534e-4611-b063-d83d82cb1a22" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AssetsOfDiscontinuedAnnuityOperationsMember_adbbccf7-0503-4db7-b807-d83a06472e7d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AssetsOfDiscontinuedAnnuityOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByAssetClassDomain_047f70fc-7988-4462-8d36-20a0d23153d5" xlink:to="loc_afg_AssetsOfDiscontinuedAnnuityOperationsMember_adbbccf7-0503-4db7-b807-d83a06472e7d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_341c6fdc-c52a-47a1-b9b2-bffe2e696536" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_080f79e4-d1e6-4462-90a0-5dbcebc5d821" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_341c6fdc-c52a-47a1-b9b2-bffe2e696536" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_341c6fdc-c52a-47a1-b9b2-bffe2e696536_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_341c6fdc-c52a-47a1-b9b2-bffe2e696536" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_341c6fdc-c52a-47a1-b9b2-bffe2e696536_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_61a68dbb-f1f1-490e-8d6b-69acaaa669f0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_341c6fdc-c52a-47a1-b9b2-bffe2e696536" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_61a68dbb-f1f1-490e-8d6b-69acaaa669f0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_ec76114c-c1bf-482a-8e55-b2a68f8d9e56" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_61a68dbb-f1f1-490e-8d6b-69acaaa669f0" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_ec76114c-c1bf-482a-8e55-b2a68f8d9e56" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a8b0ba6f-22ec-4162-86e0-bc0d864891f2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue_62979570-9844-431d-8a7d-2b9682dcc014" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue_62979570-9844-431d-8a7d-2b9682dcc014" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInEarnings1_e0216213-78d6-49f5-ae74-e6b775103f4e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInEarnings1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInEarnings1_e0216213-78d6-49f5-ae74-e6b775103f4e" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncomeLoss_4841f0da-3e45-4c21-a957-4568ec4af008" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncomeLoss_4841f0da-3e45-4c21-a957-4568ec4af008" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetPurchases_1bbc3a0d-5fd7-4198-8100-62f4e433bc64" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetPurchases"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetPurchases_1bbc3a0d-5fd7-4198-8100-62f4e433bc64" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetSales_fa4f489d-49be-4575-b70b-670e880ec7ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetSales"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetSales_fa4f489d-49be-4575-b70b-670e880ec7ef" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersIntoLevel3_d384833c-4e6d-4ac9-88bf-3d1a027df25a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersIntoLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersIntoLevel3_d384833c-4e6d-4ac9-88bf-3d1a027df25a" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersOutOfLevel3_5f60cd79-756b-4c51-bcc6-3136d2f583be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersOutOfLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetTransfersOutOfLevel3_5f60cd79-756b-4c51-bcc6-3136d2f583be" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetDispositionOfSubsidiaries_98be847e-2bbe-4014-9b81-73e045499f74" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetDispositionOfSubsidiaries_98be847e-2bbe-4014-9b81-73e045499f74" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue_6c0501d4-b673-48d3-93ef-c0c18cf4afe0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisAssetValue"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationAssetGainLossStatementOfOtherComprehensiveIncomeExtensibleList_b7810b54-16b1-4f05-b840-7fd3ab391292" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationAssetGainLossStatementOfOtherComprehensiveIncomeExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationAssetGainLossStatementOfOtherComprehensiveIncomeExtensibleList_b7810b54-16b1-4f05-b840-7fd3ab391292" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationAssetGainLossStatementOfIncomeExtensibleList_99d0c423-b8e6-4674-bbab-9d2406dd84c2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationAssetGainLossStatementOfIncomeExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueAssetsMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationCalculationRollForward_13844d7f-250b-4d2d-9918-63306735c60b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationAssetGainLossStatementOfIncomeExtensibleList_99d0c423-b8e6-4674-bbab-9d2406dd84c2" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialliabilitiescarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialliabilitiescarriedatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsChangesinbalancesofLevel3financialliabilitiescarriedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_dcf78bcb-06fe-4fd3-8246-c30d6f082b94" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_dcf78bcb-06fe-4fd3-8246-c30d6f082b94" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_3ea07162-f0eb-4ab4-89cc-3210e1f87a98" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_dcf78bcb-06fe-4fd3-8246-c30d6f082b94" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_3ea07162-f0eb-4ab4-89cc-3210e1f87a98" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_3ea07162-f0eb-4ab4-89cc-3210e1f87a98_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_3ea07162-f0eb-4ab4-89cc-3210e1f87a98" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_3ea07162-f0eb-4ab4-89cc-3210e1f87a98_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_a167ec04-a7af-4a65-87c5-aac9473041ae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByLiabilityClassAxis_3ea07162-f0eb-4ab4-89cc-3210e1f87a98" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_a167ec04-a7af-4a65-87c5-aac9473041ae" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_88e20467-4588-4b1b-8c87-5b5430de3685" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_a167ec04-a7af-4a65-87c5-aac9473041ae" xlink:to="loc_afg_ContingentConsiderationAcquisitionsMember_88e20467-4588-4b1b-8c87-5b5430de3685" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_LiabilitiesOfDiscontinuedAnnuityOperationsMember_c65cd381-cd3c-42f5-8f06-8a08996b359a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_LiabilitiesOfDiscontinuedAnnuityOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationByLiabilityClassDomain_a167ec04-a7af-4a65-87c5-aac9473041ae" xlink:to="loc_afg_LiabilitiesOfDiscontinuedAnnuityOperationsMember_c65cd381-cd3c-42f5-8f06-8a08996b359a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_85f3f969-b6eb-492d-aa59-c181c7d855ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationTable_dcf78bcb-06fe-4fd3-8246-c30d6f082b94" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_85f3f969-b6eb-492d-aa59-c181c7d855ef" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_85f3f969-b6eb-492d-aa59-c181c7d855ef_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_85f3f969-b6eb-492d-aa59-c181c7d855ef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_85f3f969-b6eb-492d-aa59-c181c7d855ef_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_b75d6198-a22a-40e9-83aa-89c4fcf264e9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_85f3f969-b6eb-492d-aa59-c181c7d855ef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_b75d6198-a22a-40e9-83aa-89c4fcf264e9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_beee90fe-e2a4-4d12-a832-43d19a3ba9e6" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_b75d6198-a22a-40e9-83aa-89c4fcf264e9" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_beee90fe-e2a4-4d12-a832-43d19a3ba9e6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue_10451120-950a-46bb-9469-9cd03173c13a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue_10451120-950a-46bb-9469-9cd03173c13a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInEarnings_5dda0540-38f0-41e5-b5a6-3b4b13c14e7d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInEarnings"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInEarnings_5dda0540-38f0-41e5-b5a6-3b4b13c14e7d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncome_bd940924-3c88-4f85-bfe0-e1921a17c85b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityGainLossIncludedInOtherComprehensiveIncome_bd940924-3c88-4f85-bfe0-e1921a17c85b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityIssues_7767f1c6-2be1-4102-8043-364d5e72379f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityIssues"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityIssues_7767f1c6-2be1-4102-8043-364d5e72379f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilitySettlements_5d24fb2d-0a73-4518-9eeb-f51d9859240f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilitySettlements"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilitySettlements_5d24fb2d-0a73-4518-9eeb-f51d9859240f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersIntoLevel3_0e5f8207-980f-4103-a2c3-1980f5737faf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersIntoLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersIntoLevel3_0e5f8207-980f-4103-a2c3-1980f5737faf" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersOutOfLevel3_a6a96c1d-2163-400b-b0b6-e0d15afcc275" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersOutOfLevel3"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationLiabilityTransfersOutOfLevel3_a6a96c1d-2163-400b-b0b6-e0d15afcc275" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityDispositionOfSubsidiaries_aa3c7fb1-50bc-49d5-a3f9-adf7f20adda5" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_afg_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationRecurringBasisLiabilityDispositionOfSubsidiaries_aa3c7fb1-50bc-49d5-a3f9-adf7f20adda5" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue_06716ba8-0c99-42e2-b128-f91cbfcc74b6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementWithUnobservableInputsReconciliationsRecurringBasisLiabilityValue"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLiabilityGainLossStatementOfIncomeExtensibleList_5ae09050-f619-40ee-8084-086774753042" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLiabilityGainLossStatementOfIncomeExtensibleList"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueLiabilitiesMeasuredOnRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLineItems_a45041f0-15dc-44b0-a8d3-600457240096" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueRecurringBasisUnobservableInputReconciliationLiabilityGainLossStatementOfIncomeExtensibleList_5ae09050-f619-40ee-8084-086774753042" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsThecarryingvalueandfairvalueoffinancialinstrumentsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#FairValueMeasurementsThecarryingvalueandfairvalueoffinancialinstrumentsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/FairValueMeasurementsThecarryingvalueandfairvalueoffinancialinstrumentsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems_0050e014-969e-4516-9826-51f0d62b53d0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_2f095b76-22ba-4ddf-a73c-018a52e3c684" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems_0050e014-969e-4516-9826-51f0d62b53d0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_2f095b76-22ba-4ddf-a73c-018a52e3c684" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_1eb54151-4a82-4a4b-a673-f32cc0117b42" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_2f095b76-22ba-4ddf-a73c-018a52e3c684" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_1eb54151-4a82-4a4b-a673-f32cc0117b42" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_1eb54151-4a82-4a4b-a673-f32cc0117b42_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_1eb54151-4a82-4a4b-a673-f32cc0117b42" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_1eb54151-4a82-4a4b-a673-f32cc0117b42_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain_75716530-81f9-42ab-914e-394a96c214e5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByMeasurementBasisAxis_1eb54151-4a82-4a4b-a673-f32cc0117b42" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain_75716530-81f9-42ab-914e-394a96c214e5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_0c7ddade-5e4c-41fe-a4a3-f6d75c9c103f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueDisclosureItemAmountsDomain_75716530-81f9-42ab-914e-394a96c214e5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_0c7ddade-5e4c-41fe-a4a3-f6d75c9c103f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CarryingReportedAmountFairValueDisclosureMember_25cc3b2c-7145-4c63-9a41-fca443e3c014" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CarryingReportedAmountFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_0c7ddade-5e4c-41fe-a4a3-f6d75c9c103f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CarryingReportedAmountFairValueDisclosureMember_25cc3b2c-7145-4c63-9a41-fca443e3c014" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EstimateOfFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_da812259-378b-43b5-8307-8ce71d05cb55" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EstimateOfFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PortionAtFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_0c7ddade-5e4c-41fe-a4a3-f6d75c9c103f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EstimateOfFairValueFairValueDisclosureMember_da812259-378b-43b5-8307-8ce71d05cb55" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_846746a1-cdf6-4301-af62-c012b1c0d3a7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByBalanceSheetGroupingTable_2f095b76-22ba-4ddf-a73c-018a52e3c684" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_846746a1-cdf6-4301-af62-c012b1c0d3a7" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_846746a1-cdf6-4301-af62-c012b1c0d3a7_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_846746a1-cdf6-4301-af62-c012b1c0d3a7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_846746a1-cdf6-4301-af62-c012b1c0d3a7_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ed401c19-4d9a-471a-86cb-2e580c380ceb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueByFairValueHierarchyLevelAxis_846746a1-cdf6-4301-af62-c012b1c0d3a7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ed401c19-4d9a-471a-86cb-2e580c380ceb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_1a091f02-c86f-4c3f-ad28-c9f0d5692bc9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ed401c19-4d9a-471a-86cb-2e580c380ceb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel1Member_1a091f02-c86f-4c3f-ad28-c9f0d5692bc9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_06d6dfa4-a6ab-4606-851d-2657b11fab1e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ed401c19-4d9a-471a-86cb-2e580c380ceb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel2Member_06d6dfa4-a6ab-4606-851d-2657b11fab1e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_69725fe9-1970-49e5-b02a-64fb6ae903be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueMeasurementsFairValueHierarchyDomain_ed401c19-4d9a-471a-86cb-2e580c380ceb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValueInputsLevel3Member_69725fe9-1970-49e5-b02a-64fb6ae903be" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_71be919e-7e1f-45b0-8435-741f17e7270b" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValueBalanceSheetGroupingFinancialStatementCaptionsLineItems_0050e014-969e-4516-9826-51f0d62b53d0" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_71be919e-7e1f-45b0-8435-741f17e7270b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_280930fd-9a90-4ebf-acc9-50d4481e402d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_71be919e-7e1f-45b0-8435-741f17e7270b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_280930fd-9a90-4ebf-acc9-50d4481e402d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsFairValueDisclosure_0e725f3b-a83d-4380-9fea-fbdc6ed2a413" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsFairValueDisclosure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_280930fd-9a90-4ebf-acc9-50d4481e402d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsFairValueDisclosure_0e725f3b-a83d-4380-9fea-fbdc6ed2a413" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet_670cffc2-dd27-42c6-ae60-4d5bad41e98b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_280930fd-9a90-4ebf-acc9-50d4481e402d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateCommercialAndConsumerNet_670cffc2-dd27-42c6-ae60-4d5bad41e98b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialAssetsNotAccountedForAtFairValue_fbf74aa1-cc57-494b-a81e-c0a9641caa79" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FinancialAssetsNotAccountedForAtFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_280930fd-9a90-4ebf-acc9-50d4481e402d" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialAssetsNotAccountedForAtFairValue_fbf74aa1-cc57-494b-a81e-c0a9641caa79" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_bf51ed7c-4fea-42cd-a12d-fd40e28ae2eb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_71be919e-7e1f-45b0-8435-741f17e7270b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_bf51ed7c-4fea-42cd-a12d-fd40e28ae2eb" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialLiabilitiesNotAccountedForAtFairValue_b620340f-5774-4ab0-b21d-8a2334911c2e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FinancialLiabilitiesNotAccountedForAtFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInstrumentsFinancialAssetsAndLiabilitiesBalanceSheetGroupingsAbstract_71be919e-7e1f-45b0-8435-741f17e7270b" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialLiabilitiesNotAccountedForAtFairValue_b620340f-5774-4ab0-b21d-8a2334911c2e" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_25dd322c-e2b1-4d9b-8c53-36382d80ac23" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_25dd322c-e2b1-4d9b-8c53-36382d80ac23" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_16fb2b46-cbce-4a01-9718-597c5a31f533" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_25dd322c-e2b1-4d9b-8c53-36382d80ac23" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_16fb2b46-cbce-4a01-9718-597c5a31f533" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_16fb2b46-cbce-4a01-9718-597c5a31f533_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_16fb2b46-cbce-4a01-9718-597c5a31f533" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_16fb2b46-cbce-4a01-9718-597c5a31f533_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_a230aa2d-32e0-4629-9005-c257cfeeec69" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_16fb2b46-cbce-4a01-9718-597c5a31f533" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_a230aa2d-32e0-4629-9005-c257cfeeec69" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_02e28874-b118-4afa-84c6-4f92cd52b815" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_a230aa2d-32e0-4629-9005-c257cfeeec69" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_02e28874-b118-4afa-84c6-4f92cd52b815" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_d21f7035-51ce-4ec5-b708-2c1009d37041" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_25dd322c-e2b1-4d9b-8c53-36382d80ac23" xlink:to="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_d21f7035-51ce-4ec5-b708-2c1009d37041" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_d21f7035-51ce-4ec5-b708-2c1009d37041_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_d21f7035-51ce-4ec5-b708-2c1009d37041" xlink:to="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_d21f7035-51ce-4ec5-b708-2c1009d37041_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_9496a782-1c0f-4a3a-b97b-c76ea890834b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateDescriptionTypeOfPropertyAxis_d21f7035-51ce-4ec5-b708-2c1009d37041" xlink:to="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_9496a782-1c0f-4a3a-b97b-c76ea890834b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MultifamilyMember_75e0a073-a4f9-4072-8633-1404c0f4a94a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MultifamilyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_MortgageLoansOnRealEstateNamePropertyTypeDomain_9496a782-1c0f-4a3a-b97b-c76ea890834b" xlink:to="loc_srt_MultifamilyMember_75e0a073-a4f9-4072-8633-1404c0f4a94a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealEstateRelatedInvestmentsPercentByPropertyType_5f248640-1345-4ddb-b63f-32f1a29d008f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_RealEstateRelatedInvestmentsPercentByPropertyType"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealEstateRelatedInvestmentsPercentByPropertyType_5f248640-1345-4ddb-b63f-32f1a29d008f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_UnfundedCommitmentsToLimitedPartnerships_35dd7983-07f2-4b14-85ab-f8372197f2f0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_UnfundedCommitmentsToLimitedPartnerships"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_afg_UnfundedCommitmentsToLimitedPartnerships_35dd7983-07f2-4b14-85ab-f8372197f2f0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_998b15f5-b1d8-4227-b028-2d10f070ab08" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_998b15f5-b1d8-4227-b028-2d10f070ab08" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleUnrealizedLossPositionNumberOfPositions_03e03ff5-7f51-4c30-9b3c-58d0e61d9d25" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleUnrealizedLossPositionNumberOfPositions"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleUnrealizedLossPositionNumberOfPositions_03e03ff5-7f51-4c30-9b3c-58d0e61d9d25" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnUnrealizedLossOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_29116a6c-4ffb-4f37-b5bb-5e11274f0f41" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageBasedOnUnrealizedLossOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnUnrealizedLossOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_29116a6c-4ffb-4f37-b5bb-5e11274f0f41" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnFairValueOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_00c31729-b768-44dc-8174-ff0d24cb783e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageBasedOnFairValueOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_de7ad50f-d1c8-4415-a1af-a9384e10be88" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageBasedOnFairValueOfAvailableForSaleFixedMaturitiesThatAreInUnrealizedLossPositionAndRatedInvestmentGrade_00c31729-b768-44dc-8174-ff0d24cb783e" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAvailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsAvailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAvailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ae00bcd7-e05a-4b12-b8bc-7a256a934992" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ae00bcd7-e05a-4b12-b8bc-7a256a934992" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_d36e363f-6c5a-433c-8a46-edb11408313a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_ae00bcd7-e05a-4b12-b8bc-7a256a934992" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_d36e363f-6c5a-433c-8a46-edb11408313a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_d36e363f-6c5a-433c-8a46-edb11408313a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_d36e363f-6c5a-433c-8a46-edb11408313a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_d36e363f-6c5a-433c-8a46-edb11408313a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_980030cd-e54d-4181-8f5d-6e81733e5105" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_d36e363f-6c5a-433c-8a46-edb11408313a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_980030cd-e54d-4181-8f5d-6e81733e5105" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_980030cd-e54d-4181-8f5d-6e81733e5105" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_926b7e1c-604b-4f66-b917-123f6bd8d5ac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_926b7e1c-604b-4f66-b917-123f6bd8d5ac" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_3613c8f0-d814-4bbb-b15b-7b7d319e87a5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_3613c8f0-d814-4bbb-b15b-7b7d319e87a5" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_daf9f5e9-d876-4c3c-8dc8-8099517b22ab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_daf9f5e9-d876-4c3c-8dc8-8099517b22ab" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_671d3382-813a-4536-a29b-96ffe866883c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_671d3382-813a-4536-a29b-96ffe866883c" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_eb1a5fd0-2bd5-4934-bd93-a0b996129c4e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_eb1a5fd0-2bd5-4934-bd93-a0b996129c4e" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_2c04557a-e757-495c-8eba-cafb5dd79c71" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_2c04557a-e757-495c-8eba-cafb5dd79c71" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_1a225beb-0e68-4ed5-82b4-70fab38e2abd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_1a225beb-0e68-4ed5-82b4-70fab38e2abd" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_56c40270-dcfc-477a-9dcd-a2133ea55bca" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_028e33fd-1f82-498d-b887-4ff6f11b8b65" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_56c40270-dcfc-477a-9dcd-a2133ea55bca" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAmortizedCostBasis_57997b94-238b-433f-b88d-bb5e61b18ad9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAmortizedCostBasis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAmortizedCostBasis_57997b94-238b-433f-b88d-bb5e61b18ad9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_02973a87-d14d-4c00-adcd-df7daa26ec7d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_02973a87-d14d-4c00-adcd-df7daa26ec7d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainBeforeTax_b2977c4a-2fa6-4745-90ae-e43d640fc18b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainBeforeTax_b2977c4a-2fa6-4745-90ae-e43d640fc18b" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_4fcd94be-7de2-453d-898f-b246ff250ea4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleDebtSecuritiesAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedLossBeforeTax_4fcd94be-7de2-453d-898f-b246ff250ea4" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainLossBeforeTax_da1e93ee-92e3-4db8-8894-125009bd72db" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAccumulatedGrossUnrealizedGainLossBeforeTax_da1e93ee-92e3-4db8-8894-125009bd72db" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_e7f734c3-a33b-4b29-a6c4-2a00098a4cee" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_1d57ce14-9b41-4d03-af6c-d39be7748693" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_e7f734c3-a33b-4b29-a6c4-2a00098a4cee" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsEquitysecuritiesreportedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsEquitysecuritiesreportedatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsEquitysecuritiesreportedatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_bcf46372-41ad-4320-b283-42c73fb79a70" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable_60823972-4827-4441-a113-f3045f163de7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_bcf46372-41ad-4320-b283-42c73fb79a70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable_60823972-4827-4441-a113-f3045f163de7" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5c3ab246-ce93-423e-9d85-a6b3b5bed093" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsTable_60823972-4827-4441-a113-f3045f163de7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5c3ab246-ce93-423e-9d85-a6b3b5bed093" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5c3ab246-ce93-423e-9d85-a6b3b5bed093_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5c3ab246-ce93-423e-9d85-a6b3b5bed093" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5c3ab246-ce93-423e-9d85-a6b3b5bed093_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8b0443e2-5f7a-41ea-b4dd-009de17f443d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5c3ab246-ce93-423e-9d85-a6b3b5bed093" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8b0443e2-5f7a-41ea-b4dd-009de17f443d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_56e77e12-110f-41f2-8adb-0f15e8a5e9eb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommonStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8b0443e2-5f7a-41ea-b4dd-009de17f443d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommonStockMember_56e77e12-110f-41f2-8adb-0f15e8a5e9eb" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockMember_44426766-8271-40c6-ad33-a618086c6959" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PreferredStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8b0443e2-5f7a-41ea-b4dd-009de17f443d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockMember_44426766-8271-40c6-ad33-a618086c6959" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_b41ce768-a4b5-41da-b38c-3cd8efb20057" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8b0443e2-5f7a-41ea-b4dd-009de17f443d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_b41ce768-a4b5-41da-b38c-3cd8efb20057" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiCost_e6e8853a-c244-4843-b9c3-5313cdddaca7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_bcf46372-41ad-4320-b283-42c73fb79a70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiCost_e6e8853a-c244-4843-b9c3-5313cdddaca7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_a5108a7d-4c23-4b3c-8287-12345d427cfe" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_bcf46372-41ad-4320-b283-42c73fb79a70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNi_a5108a7d-4c23-4b3c-8287-12345d427cfe" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquitySecuritiesFVNIFairValueinExcessofCost_910fc60a-d604-4acc-9dca-9deaf181f547" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EquitySecuritiesFVNIFairValueinExcessofCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfTradingSecuritiesAndOtherTradingAssetsLineItems_bcf46372-41ad-4320-b283-42c73fb79a70" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquitySecuritiesFVNIFairValueinExcessofCost_910fc60a-d604-4acc-9dca-9deaf181f547" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsDetailofequitymethodinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsDetailofequitymethodinvestmentsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsDetailofequitymethodinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_f6d5cf9a-74db-41f8-a76b-3acfd96d0d73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_1198876a-f2f9-43f4-bb9f-0023c6eaaac0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_f6d5cf9a-74db-41f8-a76b-3acfd96d0d73" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_1198876a-f2f9-43f4-bb9f-0023c6eaaac0" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_aee5e501-5e12-44de-9fc0-adc9cd83b578" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsTable_1198876a-f2f9-43f4-bb9f-0023c6eaaac0" xlink:to="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_aee5e501-5e12-44de-9fc0-adc9cd83b578" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_aee5e501-5e12-44de-9fc0-adc9cd83b578_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_aee5e501-5e12-44de-9fc0-adc9cd83b578" xlink:to="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_aee5e501-5e12-44de-9fc0-adc9cd83b578_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_c189cc1d-ed7a-43fd-a76d-2b2cb2e88ea1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfEquityMethodInvestmentEquityMethodInvesteeNameAxis_aee5e501-5e12-44de-9fc0-adc9cd83b578" xlink:to="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_c189cc1d-ed7a-43fd-a76d-2b2cb2e88ea1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsMember_5005feb7-a7d5-4738-8d09-fde4afe0048c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_c189cc1d-ed7a-43fd-a76d-2b2cb2e88ea1" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsRealEstateRelatedInvestmentsMember_5005feb7-a7d5-4738-8d09-fde4afe0048c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateEquityFundsMember_2074051a-d7c2-4a88-a7f4-b0ec6c33af7d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateEquityFundsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_c189cc1d-ed7a-43fd-a76d-2b2cb2e88ea1" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateEquityFundsMember_2074051a-d7c2-4a88-a7f4-b0ec6c33af7d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateDebtFundsMember_a5bad102-f375-466a-8132-c57a3d218fd7" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateDebtFundsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_EquityMethodInvesteeNameDomain_c189cc1d-ed7a-43fd-a76d-2b2cb2e88ea1" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityMethodInvestmentsPrivateDebtFundsMember_a5bad102-f375-466a-8132-c57a3d218fd7" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments_aa334f3c-b441-424c-9909-0b31b2a53cc2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_f6d5cf9a-74db-41f8-a76b-3acfd96d0d73" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityMethodInvestments_aa334f3c-b441-424c-9909-0b31b2a53cc2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_51260647-dbf4-4c73-8522-773606b8ba5d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentsLineItems_f6d5cf9a-74db-41f8-a76b-3acfd96d0d73" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_51260647-dbf4-4c73-8522-773606b8ba5d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossunrealizedlossesonsecuritiesbyinvestmentcategoryandlengthoftimethathavebeeninacontinuousunrealizedlosspositionDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsGrossunrealizedlossesonsecuritiesbyinvestmentcategoryandlengthoftimethathavebeeninacontinuousunrealizedlosspositionDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossunrealizedlossesonsecuritiesbyinvestmentcategoryandlengthoftimethathavebeeninacontinuousunrealizedlosspositionDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_bfe5df5e-b696-4e61-aa74-a573699ae4fc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_c3418c2a-9dd9-42d5-a9d2-97ed17ba9dd2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_bfe5df5e-b696-4e61-aa74-a573699ae4fc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_c3418c2a-9dd9-42d5-a9d2-97ed17ba9dd2" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_ecb7e195-0d51-49ad-9b18-bd4fbe3847c1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_c3418c2a-9dd9-42d5-a9d2-97ed17ba9dd2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_ecb7e195-0d51-49ad-9b18-bd4fbe3847c1" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_ecb7e195-0d51-49ad-9b18-bd4fbe3847c1_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_ecb7e195-0d51-49ad-9b18-bd4fbe3847c1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_ecb7e195-0d51-49ad-9b18-bd4fbe3847c1_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_9498890e-41d4-41c1-ae98-cfc6ced6edd4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_ecb7e195-0d51-49ad-9b18-bd4fbe3847c1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_9498890e-41d4-41c1-ae98-cfc6ced6edd4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_9498890e-41d4-41c1-ae98-cfc6ced6edd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_86e28880-f10f-4341-b8cd-0e83d1660717" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USTreasuryAndGovernmentMember_86e28880-f10f-4341-b8cd-0e83d1660717" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_65897f85-7719-43b0-8017-99acb57506ee" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_USStatesAndPoliticalSubdivisionsMember_65897f85-7719-43b0-8017-99acb57506ee" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_fab54c68-2a2f-4b2a-9b58-c3c4ac8fd850" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ForeignGovernmentDebtSecuritiesMember_fab54c68-2a2f-4b2a-9b58-c3c4ac8fd850" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_d6d3a46d-4def-463c-b8ad-cde315e67c81" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ResidentialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_d6d3a46d-4def-463c-b8ad-cde315e67c81" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_b2ae605b-ded6-4064-a582-881dfc5e7f3e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CommercialMortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_b2ae605b-ded6-4064-a582-881dfc5e7f3e" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_4432a97c-2394-4b5c-9001-3dd6b5b62e32" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_4432a97c-2394-4b5c-9001-3dd6b5b62e32" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_a7813170-ca59-4b6f-9114-7e2dae834dcc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetBackedSecuritiesMember_a7813170-ca59-4b6f-9114-7e2dae834dcc" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_032dadba-bed3-4282-9556-de5928055199" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_03f63fed-3abb-4824-8a8b-fad003c50be5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_032dadba-bed3-4282-9556-de5928055199" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_bfe5df5e-b696-4e61-aa74-a573699ae4fc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12MonthsAccumulatedLoss_09bdda73-130f-421a-a735-3cc69894b740" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12MonthsAccumulatedLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12MonthsAccumulatedLoss_09bdda73-130f-421a-a735-3cc69894b740" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12Months_26c1ddc1-cd06-4389-8b84-02934676bf4f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12Months"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThan12Months_26c1ddc1-cd06-4389-8b84-02934676bf4f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThanTwelveMonthsFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_297697f3-f483-4225-a41e-b6580db72671" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThanTwelveMonthsFairValueAsPercentageOfCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:to="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionLessThanTwelveMonthsFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_297697f3-f483-4225-a41e-b6580db72671" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLongerAccumulatedLoss_28d0d30d-3df5-47e2-a1dc-c6ab1173256e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLongerAccumulatedLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLongerAccumulatedLoss_28d0d30d-3df5-47e2-a1dc-c6ab1173256e" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLonger_af0d1f8f-a3f4-4399-8907-cb3180bf1f3d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLonger"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPosition12MonthsOrLonger_af0d1f8f-a3f4-4399-8907-cb3180bf1f3d" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionTwelveMonthsOrLongerFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_20d15d56-938b-4f3a-a921-d2e4986ce85f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionTwelveMonthsOrLongerFairValueAsPercentageOfCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionAccumulatedLossAbstract_39244568-de3a-4cef-bcec-b2abb8daaea6" xlink:to="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleContinuousUnrealizedLossPositionTwelveMonthsOrLongerFairValueAsPercentageOfCost_20d15d56-938b-4f3a-a921-d2e4986ce85f" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAllowanceforcreditlossesonfixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsAllowanceforcreditlossesonfixedmaturitiesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsAllowanceforcreditlossesonfixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems_1ac86a4a-eed9-4115-9128-4d205ce25f39" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable_dc53ed88-2294-43b9-be8f-a50ca334680d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems_1ac86a4a-eed9-4115-9128-4d205ce25f39" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable_dc53ed88-2294-43b9-be8f-a50ca334680d" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5a1130a1-6093-4392-997c-72bc38187380" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossTable_dc53ed88-2294-43b9-be8f-a50ca334680d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5a1130a1-6093-4392-997c-72bc38187380" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5a1130a1-6093-4392-997c-72bc38187380_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5a1130a1-6093-4392-997c-72bc38187380" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5a1130a1-6093-4392-997c-72bc38187380_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_6a0ad103-6469-48a9-b1a7-3112388e6a0d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_5a1130a1-6093-4392-997c-72bc38187380" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_6a0ad103-6469-48a9-b1a7-3112388e6a0d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StructuredSecuritiesMember_19b83b9d-6b0c-4fa0-a063-95b20a8b9b9d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_StructuredSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_6a0ad103-6469-48a9-b1a7-3112388e6a0d" xlink:to="loc_afg_StructuredSecuritiesMember_19b83b9d-6b0c-4fa0-a063-95b20a8b9b9d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_0bf954ad-be18-4580-8619-aef996f3fffa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_6a0ad103-6469-48a9-b1a7-3112388e6a0d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateDebtSecuritiesMember_0bf954ad-be18-4580-8619-aef996f3fffa" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_00ece811-84e2-4e7e-bd4a-de18d6fae2ec" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableforsaleAllowanceForCreditLossLineItems_1ac86a4a-eed9-4115-9128-4d205ce25f39" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_00ece811-84e2-4e7e-bd4a-de18d6fae2ec" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_3b30907c-9cae-46db-b0f6-63ac9009d2b7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_00ece811-84e2-4e7e-bd4a-de18d6fae2ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_3b30907c-9cae-46db-b0f6-63ac9009d2b7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotPreviouslyRecorded_e4e4b8cf-bf7d-4e8d-a1f8-75ae47be6363" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotPreviouslyRecorded"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_00ece811-84e2-4e7e-bd4a-de18d6fae2ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotPreviouslyRecorded_e4e4b8cf-bf7d-4e8d-a1f8-75ae47be6363" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotToSellBeforeRecoveryCreditLossPreviouslyRecordedExpenseReversal_06250990-18cc-4fb4-81b2-4f490a481d96" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotToSellBeforeRecoveryCreditLossPreviouslyRecordedExpenseReversal"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_00ece811-84e2-4e7e-bd4a-de18d6fae2ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossNotToSellBeforeRecoveryCreditLossPreviouslyRecordedExpenseReversal_06250990-18cc-4fb4-81b2-4f490a481d96" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossSecuritiesSold_ce94ecde-7d37-4701-b182-ded81f034136" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossSecuritiesSold"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_00ece811-84e2-4e7e-bd4a-de18d6fae2ec" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLossSecuritiesSold_ce94ecde-7d37-4701-b182-ded81f034136" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss_f586183e-94b0-40af-9a1a-5a9a7518e4fb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduledmaturitiesofavailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsScheduledmaturitiesofavailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduledmaturitiesofavailableforsalefixedmaturitiesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_56171f92-d366-4bc6-941b-e9e1caa2a70f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_6aee87bb-e32d-48f6-a27c-ceae8320caad" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_56171f92-d366-4bc6-941b-e9e1caa2a70f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_6aee87bb-e32d-48f6-a27c-ceae8320caad" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_05d35671-3c76-40f3-bfb8-55c8d4c8aa46" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_6aee87bb-e32d-48f6-a27c-ceae8320caad" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_05d35671-3c76-40f3-bfb8-55c8d4c8aa46" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_05d35671-3c76-40f3-bfb8-55c8d4c8aa46_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_05d35671-3c76-40f3-bfb8-55c8d4c8aa46" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_05d35671-3c76-40f3-bfb8-55c8d4c8aa46_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8459876e-73af-4c4f-a266-a390abfd846f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_05d35671-3c76-40f3-bfb8-55c8d4c8aa46" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8459876e-73af-4c4f-a266-a390abfd846f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_90167bc4-4af8-4ef8-aa9d-5133730c942b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8459876e-73af-4c4f-a266-a390abfd846f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_90167bc4-4af8-4ef8-aa9d-5133730c942b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesMember_1444a023-42be-439d-ab83-860cfb56c73a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8459876e-73af-4c4f-a266-a390abfd846f" xlink:to="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesMember_1444a023-42be-439d-ab83-860cfb56c73a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_cdbda39e-fbb4-465e-b285-37f134db35f7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MortgageBackedSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_8459876e-73af-4c4f-a266-a390abfd846f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MortgageBackedSecuritiesMember_cdbda39e-fbb4-465e-b285-37f134db35f7" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_56171f92-d366-4bc6-941b-e9e1caa2a70f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearAmortizedCost_9c988406-7420-4471-9e4d-6c99207681b9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearAmortizedCost_9c988406-7420-4471-9e4d-6c99207681b9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsAmortizedCost_724511b2-9e71-46a6-877d-5237a17072bd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsAmortizedCost_724511b2-9e71-46a6-877d-5237a17072bd" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsAmortizedCost_5bf1727c-3956-4c60-87b1-97ec754b42c9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsAmortizedCost_5bf1727c-3956-4c60-87b1-97ec754b42c9" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsAmortizedCost_0d3f52cb-167e-448b-920d-188e39388d65" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsAmortizedCost_0d3f52cb-167e-448b-920d-188e39388d65" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsAmortizedCost_7785ae69-5f01-4273-9ada-11d8b8e2151f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsAmortizedCost_7785ae69-5f01-4273-9ada-11d8b8e2151f" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateAmortizedCost_860d0dec-6d46-46b0-8c0c-382abf267409" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateAmortizedCost"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateAmortizedCost_860d0dec-6d46-46b0-8c0c-382abf267409" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAmortizedCostAfterAllowanceForCreditLoss_f03f15fe-31e6-4a61-b77f-40c37e2fd09d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAmortizedCostAfterAllowanceForCreditLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAmortizedCostAbstract_18b11917-fc29-4b71-a188-1cad1d25190d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleAmortizedCostAfterAllowanceForCreditLoss_f03f15fe-31e6-4a61-b77f-40c37e2fd09d" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValue_0d077daa-e48b-48bd-ad65-44a1af58ab22" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValue_0d077daa-e48b-48bd-ad65-44a1af58ab22" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValue_efdd9890-b145-48f0-8173-83556831b251" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValue_efdd9890-b145-48f0-8173-83556831b251" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValue_ca0ed441-77cf-4429-8b19-35ec40514026" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValue_ca0ed441-77cf-4429-8b19-35ec40514026" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValue_b05f2765-efc8-4899-b286-844e064b9e8b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValue_b05f2765-efc8-4899-b286-844e064b9e8b" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValue_a9f07f0c-ca20-425e-829f-46b0f7134c8c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValue_a9f07f0c-ca20-425e-829f-46b0f7134c8c" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValue_31a4b053-6201-42b5-bb35-31b04a34e5f7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValue_31a4b053-6201-42b5-bb35-31b04a34e5f7" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_410c0d1a-b343-46e7-9087-2e55fa5792c8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValueAbstract_889eb940-25ea-4df4-8239-00342fda0cef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_410c0d1a-b343-46e7-9087-2e55fa5792c8" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValuePercent_94a04e16-a620-481b-8761-6046f1df54c4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithinOneYearFairValuePercent_94a04e16-a620-481b-8761-6046f1df54c4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValuePercent_2502d118-3670-476c-8af8-008690097792" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterOneThroughFiveYearsFairValuePercent_2502d118-3670-476c-8af8-008690097792" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValuePercent_34e40807-d1c9-4e6e-acd6-fe6522e1ff16" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterFiveThroughTenYearsFairValuePercent_34e40807-d1c9-4e6e-acd6-fe6522e1ff16" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValuePercent_1f22a032-262e-4dde-967a-08b7e3ffc7e2" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAfterTenYearsFairValuePercent_1f22a032-262e-4dde-967a-08b7e3ffc7e2" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValuePercent_3a7f6869-c49b-4ffe-97ad-1c4ffc0d9889" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesExcludingAbsAndMbsFairValuePercent_3a7f6869-c49b-4ffe-97ad-1c4ffc0d9889" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValuePercent_8c71a468-289e-4b1e-8705-e3cfe8ec0a41" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesWithoutSingleMaturityDateFairValuePercent_8c71a468-289e-4b1e-8705-e3cfe8ec0a41" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercent_9edd1720-e8b3-4196-8777-ba0f9c93c3c9" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercentFiscalYearMaturityAbstract_bf0edf93-15df-46d7-b487-1c2356e5a8ad" xlink:to="loc_afg_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesFairValuePercent_9edd1720-e8b3-4196-8777-ba0f9c93c3c9" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesAverageLife_a3ac5b15-d3fe-4f7f-a229-1be8cf7610a9" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesAverageLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:to="loc_afg_CollateralizedLoanObligationsAndOtherAssetBackedSecuritiesAverageLife_a3ac5b15-d3fe-4f7f-a229-1be8cf7610a9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesAverageLife_086fe9b8-05e8-4afe-9040-ea76b539247a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesAverageLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtMaturitiesAbstract_1e6dc19c-d2a3-48bf-b5e9-a0d751cc7203" xlink:to="loc_afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesAverageLife_086fe9b8-05e8-4afe-9040-ea76b539247a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduleofsourcesofnetinvestmentincomeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsScheduleofsourcesofnetinvestmentincomeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsScheduleofsourcesofnetinvestmentincomeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_6a0c63dc-5a38-4484-840b-0a8779d691ed" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_6a0c63dc-5a38-4484-840b-0a8779d691ed" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_6a0c63dc-5a38-4484-840b-0a8779d691ed_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_6a0c63dc-5a38-4484-840b-0a8779d691ed" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_6a0c63dc-5a38-4484-840b-0a8779d691ed_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_948204a5-1e1b-4784-a23d-ab08b6e7a457" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DividendsAxis_6a0c63dc-5a38-4484-840b-0a8779d691ed" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_948204a5-1e1b-4784-a23d-ab08b6e7a457" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_68fe41cc-eb44-4cd2-a779-f4afeda61275" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DividendsDomain_948204a5-1e1b-4784-a23d-ab08b6e7a457" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_68fe41cc-eb44-4cd2-a779-f4afeda61275" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_19c7d212-f778-4619-9877-39632f6cbcd3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_19c7d212-f778-4619-9877-39632f6cbcd3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_19c7d212-f778-4619-9877-39632f6cbcd3_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_19c7d212-f778-4619-9877-39632f6cbcd3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_19c7d212-f778-4619-9877-39632f6cbcd3_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_f9dc2263-3222-4a87-b525-a0795b34195f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeAxis_19c7d212-f778-4619-9877-39632f6cbcd3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_f9dc2263-3222-4a87-b525-a0795b34195f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_b9553d09-e99c-41cc-844f-d7369d8fe494" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_f9dc2263-3222-4a87-b525-a0795b34195f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_b9553d09-e99c-41cc-844f-d7369d8fe494" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_2e04c09a-c2c3-42da-8681-97bf59e24b27" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_f9dc2263-3222-4a87-b525-a0795b34195f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_2e04c09a-c2c3-42da-8681-97bf59e24b27" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLongTermInvestmentsMember_ea89c7f6-42da-4e58-81d9-0474598d121f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLongTermInvestmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember_f9dc2263-3222-4a87-b525-a0795b34195f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLongTermInvestmentsMember_ea89c7f6-42da-4e58-81d9-0474598d121f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_f50ac184-f37d-4841-892f-c9e528b2e35c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_f50ac184-f37d-4841-892f-c9e528b2e35c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_f50ac184-f37d-4841-892f-c9e528b2e35c_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_f50ac184-f37d-4841-892f-c9e528b2e35c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_f50ac184-f37d-4841-892f-c9e528b2e35c_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_3f66588f-f8f6-4df2-a069-0dbc4db0d04d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_f50ac184-f37d-4841-892f-c9e528b2e35c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_3f66588f-f8f6-4df2-a069-0dbc4db0d04d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_256e1a2e-1818-4b2c-9dc4-8371456a9afc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_3f66588f-f8f6-4df2-a069-0dbc4db0d04d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_256e1a2e-1818-4b2c-9dc4-8371456a9afc" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_7fb6f798-96b3-44a4-919e-4e27438c441b" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_7fb6f798-96b3-44a4-919e-4e27438c441b" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_7fb6f798-96b3-44a4-919e-4e27438c441b_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_7fb6f798-96b3-44a4-919e-4e27438c441b" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_7fb6f798-96b3-44a4-919e-4e27438c441b_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_f512d4da-6901-487e-ad97-3eabee86d6f5" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationAxis_7fb6f798-96b3-44a4-919e-4e27438c441b" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_f512d4da-6901-487e-ad97-3eabee86d6f5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_8f266e0e-b1fb-4509-bb92-9e530c2e4e50" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InterestAndAmortizationDomain_f512d4da-6901-487e-ad97-3eabee86d6f5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_8f266e0e-b1fb-4509-bb92-9e530c2e4e50" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_6b19ad1c-5fe4-4ec2-be85-69a8482826ee" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryTable_302cf0eb-784f-4224-959c-824c825a4d86" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_6b19ad1c-5fe4-4ec2-be85-69a8482826ee" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_6b19ad1c-5fe4-4ec2-be85-69a8482826ee_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_6b19ad1c-5fe4-4ec2-be85-69a8482826ee" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_6b19ad1c-5fe4-4ec2-be85-69a8482826ee_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_e3390525-fee9-41e5-8aa4-1265c37860cb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueAxis_6b19ad1c-5fe4-4ec2-be85-69a8482826ee" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_e3390525-fee9-41e5-8aa4-1265c37860cb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_9740a416-c3e5-40cb-b60a-27cbade9d851" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueDomain_e3390525-fee9-41e5-8aa4-1265c37860cb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_9740a416-c3e5-40cb-b60a-27cbade9d851" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GrossInvestmentIncomeOperating_18c5782a-13ab-4bad-93e9-db59b2d1a3a1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GrossInvestmentIncomeOperating"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GrossInvestmentIncomeOperating_18c5782a-13ab-4bad-93e9-db59b2d1a3a1" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesTradingAndConvertibleGainLoss_886ce5db-241e-4742-ad6a-be1017ac73c7" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DebtSecuritiesTradingAndConvertibleGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_afg_DebtSecuritiesTradingAndConvertibleGainLoss_886ce5db-241e-4742-ad6a-be1017ac73c7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiGainLoss_660247fd-7b72-4d4e-bd71-7fe436fbacb6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiGainLoss_660247fd-7b72-4d4e-bd71-7fe436fbacb6" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_5e0b6882-28ae-478e-822a-b285825c0584" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromEquityMethodInvestments_5e0b6882-28ae-478e-822a-b285825c0584" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeInvestmentExpense_01a1ec8d-dc1c-40ce-8938-3a820ab45bb6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeInvestmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeInvestmentExpense_01a1ec8d-dc1c-40ce-8938-3a820ab45bb6" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_a8c8fd69-69a9-4485-84e3-66fc10078d29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfInvestmentIncomeReportedAmountsByCategoryLineItems_be85ba46-7a62-4e8c-a991-c12acf95264e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetInvestmentIncome_a8c8fd69-69a9-4485-84e3-66fc10078d29" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsRealizedgainslossesandchangesinunrealizedappreciationdepreciationrelatedtofixedmaturityandequitysecurityinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsRealizedgainslossesandchangesinunrealizedappreciationdepreciationrelatedtofixedmaturityandequitysecurityinvestmentsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsRealizedgainslossesandchangesinunrealizedappreciationdepreciationrelatedtofixedmaturityandequitysecurityinvestmentsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_9973944f-3487-49e6-8261-b23a83051714" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_1d29276d-22e4-40ed-811a-53bfdbbfe9e0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_9973944f-3487-49e6-8261-b23a83051714" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_1d29276d-22e4-40ed-811a-53bfdbbfe9e0" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_a66dcf77-4661-4edc-a9c5-17c59c261826" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_1d29276d-22e4-40ed-811a-53bfdbbfe9e0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_a66dcf77-4661-4edc-a9c5-17c59c261826" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_a66dcf77-4661-4edc-a9c5-17c59c261826_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_a66dcf77-4661-4edc-a9c5-17c59c261826" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_a66dcf77-4661-4edc-a9c5-17c59c261826_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_569d1505-0443-449d-bf09-91b8b8560d1c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_a66dcf77-4661-4edc-a9c5-17c59c261826" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_569d1505-0443-449d-bf09-91b8b8560d1c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MarketableSecuritiesMember_53644501-fb43-48db-bd40-9153cd461a2f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_MarketableSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_569d1505-0443-449d-bf09-91b8b8560d1c" xlink:to="loc_afg_MarketableSecuritiesMember_53644501-fb43-48db-bd40-9153cd461a2f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PretaxMember_3fcc832d-38a5-45e9-a6c2-c076fc1f6f46" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PretaxMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_MarketableSecuritiesMember_53644501-fb43-48db-bd40-9153cd461a2f" xlink:to="loc_afg_PretaxMember_3fcc832d-38a5-45e9-a6c2-c076fc1f6f46" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_3cc57072-a0cb-4c11-8666-90516d92d91d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PretaxMember_3fcc832d-38a5-45e9-a6c2-c076fc1f6f46" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_3cc57072-a0cb-4c11-8666-90516d92d91d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_66674e3b-e4cc-484c-a2db-15fbc98e5a22" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PretaxMember_3fcc832d-38a5-45e9-a6c2-c076fc1f6f46" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesMember_66674e3b-e4cc-484c-a2db-15fbc98e5a22" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MortgageLoansAndOtherInvestmentsMember_600b8c33-caf6-48c8-b09f-ebcf266736f2" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_MortgageLoansAndOtherInvestmentsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_PretaxMember_3fcc832d-38a5-45e9-a6c2-c076fc1f6f46" xlink:to="loc_afg_MortgageLoansAndOtherInvestmentsMember_600b8c33-caf6-48c8-b09f-ebcf266736f2" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_TaxEffectsMember_bff8dce9-8998-4c56-9cbf-383138fd08c8" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_TaxEffectsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_MarketableSecuritiesMember_53644501-fb43-48db-bd40-9153cd461a2f" xlink:to="loc_afg_TaxEffectsMember_bff8dce9-8998-4c56-9cbf-383138fd08c8" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_12ca9ff2-657b-41eb-bf50-c3e9169892f8" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_9973944f-3487-49e6-8261-b23a83051714" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_12ca9ff2-657b-41eb-bf50-c3e9169892f8" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLossExcludingOtherThanTemporaryImpairments_88229521-20ea-4171-a440-2cf8e31467c8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLossExcludingOtherThanTemporaryImpairments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_12ca9ff2-657b-41eb-bf50-c3e9169892f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLossExcludingOtherThanTemporaryImpairments_88229521-20ea-4171-a440-2cf8e31467c8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherThanTemporaryImpairmentLossDebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRecognizedInEarnings_ea107ff3-eccd-41b9-a9b4-f13db6b136ce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherThanTemporaryImpairmentLossDebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRecognizedInEarnings"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_12ca9ff2-657b-41eb-bf50-c3e9169892f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherThanTemporaryImpairmentLossDebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRecognizedInEarnings_ea107ff3-eccd-41b9-a9b4-f13db6b136ce" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_4ffc3ae8-272e-461e-bcb2-a9d8b0742784" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_12ca9ff2-657b-41eb-bf50-c3e9169892f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss_4ffc3ae8-272e-461e-bcb2-a9d8b0742784" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciation_46ed10fb-90f0-45f8-8507-73c24bc97be1" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ChangeInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciation"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesAndChangesInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciationRelatedToFixedMaturityAndEquitySecurityInvestmentsAbstract_12ca9ff2-657b-41eb-bf50-c3e9169892f8" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInUnrealizedAppreciationDepreciation_46ed10fb-90f0-45f8-8507-73c24bc97be1" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsHoldinggainslossesonequitysecuritiesstillheldDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsHoldinggainslossesonequitysecuritiesstillheldDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsHoldinggainslossesonequitysecuritiesstillheldDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems_a11d302c-96d9-494f-9e04-78e984f00245" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable_fd486987-3ec2-4764-b596-f5507422e617" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems_a11d302c-96d9-494f-9e04-78e984f00245" xlink:to="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable_fd486987-3ec2-4764-b596-f5507422e617" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_05968eba-50f9-451c-9258-8f015727e7b2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldTable_fd486987-3ec2-4764-b596-f5507422e617" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_05968eba-50f9-451c-9258-8f015727e7b2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_05968eba-50f9-451c-9258-8f015727e7b2_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_05968eba-50f9-451c-9258-8f015727e7b2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_05968eba-50f9-451c-9258-8f015727e7b2_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_24f4db2d-7a11-4ad6-80f6-614570e441ea" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_05968eba-50f9-451c-9258-8f015727e7b2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_24f4db2d-7a11-4ad6-80f6-614570e441ea" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_3868487c-d2d6-4f60-8ee5-e0c44335ee7c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_24f4db2d-7a11-4ad6-80f6-614570e441ea" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_3868487c-d2d6-4f60-8ee5-e0c44335ee7c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_8d5c3724-0ad5-4ff0-bac5-68a1764c5cc8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_24f4db2d-7a11-4ad6-80f6-614570e441ea" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_8d5c3724-0ad5-4ff0-bac5-68a1764c5cc8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiUnrealizedGainLoss_ed4b1a4a-4c34-46e7-9687-c46b7a7578de" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiUnrealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_HoldingGainsLossesonEquitySecuritiesStillHeldLineItems_a11d302c-96d9-494f-9e04-78e984f00245" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquitySecuritiesFvNiUnrealizedGainLoss_ed4b1a4a-4c34-46e7-9687-c46b7a7578de" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossrealizedgainsandlossesonavailableforsalefixedmaturitysecurityinvestmenttransactionsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InvestmentsGrossrealizedgainsandlossesonavailableforsalefixedmaturitysecurityinvestmenttransactionsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InvestmentsGrossrealizedgainsandlossesonavailableforsalefixedmaturitysecurityinvestmenttransactionsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_9f0d343f-6b5d-475e-bc9f-f385c3674b01" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_e9262851-f9ac-417a-ab13-2a181788d4b0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_9f0d343f-6b5d-475e-bc9f-f385c3674b01" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_e9262851-f9ac-417a-ab13-2a181788d4b0" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_69247e57-2a2a-43ca-9a34-75eff00dabae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleTable_e9262851-f9ac-417a-ab13-2a181788d4b0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_69247e57-2a2a-43ca-9a34-75eff00dabae" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_69247e57-2a2a-43ca-9a34-75eff00dabae_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_69247e57-2a2a-43ca-9a34-75eff00dabae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_69247e57-2a2a-43ca-9a34-75eff00dabae_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5e5d1ce8-fbc5-4c6a-9043-59e5d53f14f3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_69247e57-2a2a-43ca-9a34-75eff00dabae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5e5d1ce8-fbc5-4c6a-9043-59e5d53f14f3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_48435a2b-2759-48b5-b816-b060c6087106" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_5e5d1ce8-fbc5-4c6a-9043-59e5d53f14f3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FixedMaturitiesMember_48435a2b-2759-48b5-b816-b060c6087106" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_e1e3a1c2-6bd5-4877-b897-00e7e23560c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfAvailableForSaleSecuritiesLineItems_9f0d343f-6b5d-475e-bc9f-f385c3674b01" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_e1e3a1c2-6bd5-4877-b897-00e7e23560c0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedGain_a963ec4c-0b3e-4197-b775-6a27bfc96f40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedGain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_e1e3a1c2-6bd5-4877-b897-00e7e23560c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedGain_a963ec4c-0b3e-4197-b775-6a27bfc96f40" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedLoss_6ef68c9d-d049-4f73-9fd5-657bde0ecf86" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesGrossRealizedGainLossAbstract_e1e3a1c2-6bd5-4877-b897-00e7e23560c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesAvailableForSaleRealizedLoss_6ef68c9d-d049-4f73-9fd5-657bde0ecf86" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DerivativesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_f6009caa-7e22-4e84-a4ce-1ec993fdbd4e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_f6009caa-7e22-4e84-a4ce-1ec993fdbd4e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_f6009caa-7e22-4e84-a4ce-1ec993fdbd4e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_f6009caa-7e22-4e84-a4ce-1ec993fdbd4e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_f6009caa-7e22-4e84-a4ce-1ec993fdbd4e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e0b14a78-850c-4d58-9a0e-85d965e8aecc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_f6009caa-7e22-4e84-a4ce-1ec993fdbd4e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e0b14a78-850c-4d58-9a0e-85d965e8aecc" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_2d049002-a292-4206-97e5-afc7cb3d7f59" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e0b14a78-850c-4d58-9a0e-85d965e8aecc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_2d049002-a292-4206-97e5-afc7cb3d7f59" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_6ca614de-3c29-4d9d-afde-062cf9c6c9dd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e0b14a78-850c-4d58-9a0e-85d965e8aecc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_6ca614de-3c29-4d9d-afde-062cf9c6c9dd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewInterestRateSwapsEnteredDuringPeriodMember_ac2082a5-3027-49a0-be9e-d8563d98711c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NewInterestRateSwapsEnteredDuringPeriodMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e0b14a78-850c-4d58-9a0e-85d965e8aecc" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewInterestRateSwapsEnteredDuringPeriodMember_ac2082a5-3027-49a0-be9e-d8563d98711c" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_ddd39691-5a61-4d2f-84e3-7e1768b63b2f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_ddd39691-5a61-4d2f-84e3-7e1768b63b2f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_ddd39691-5a61-4d2f-84e3-7e1768b63b2f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_ddd39691-5a61-4d2f-84e3-7e1768b63b2f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_ddd39691-5a61-4d2f-84e3-7e1768b63b2f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_a63808b1-20c2-4dc7-b097-4c0f088f8008" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsGainLossByHedgingRelationshipAxis_ddd39691-5a61-4d2f-84e3-7e1768b63b2f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_a63808b1-20c2-4dc7-b097-4c0f088f8008" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgingMember_43501e4b-cb12-4b67-b584-a281e0296d8b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashFlowHedgingMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingRelationshipDomain_a63808b1-20c2-4dc7-b097-4c0f088f8008" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgingMember_43501e4b-cb12-4b67-b584-a281e0296d8b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_17d595da-1318-43fc-be71-d3989c086915" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_17d595da-1318-43fc-be71-d3989c086915" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_17d595da-1318-43fc-be71-d3989c086915_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_17d595da-1318-43fc-be71-d3989c086915" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_17d595da-1318-43fc-be71-d3989c086915_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_9de609d6-126b-455e-8b4d-82911a6c2492" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_17d595da-1318-43fc-be71-d3989c086915" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_9de609d6-126b-455e-8b4d-82911a6c2492" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_eeb94a77-9c4e-4452-806f-00fe0f8f9cea" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_9de609d6-126b-455e-8b4d-82911a6c2492" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_eeb94a77-9c4e-4452-806f-00fe0f8f9cea" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_f87b11fe-1aa3-48dd-9a44-10f9cfd1ea66" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NondesignatedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_9de609d6-126b-455e-8b4d-82911a6c2492" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_f87b11fe-1aa3-48dd-9a44-10f9cfd1ea66" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_d33862f2-5362-463a-8c0a-2ad771e3dd1f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_d33862f2-5362-463a-8c0a-2ad771e3dd1f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_d33862f2-5362-463a-8c0a-2ad771e3dd1f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_d33862f2-5362-463a-8c0a-2ad771e3dd1f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_d33862f2-5362-463a-8c0a-2ad771e3dd1f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_0a87f453-a0d2-406f-b441-8648fb438b55" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_d33862f2-5362-463a-8c0a-2ad771e3dd1f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_0a87f453-a0d2-406f-b441-8648fb438b55" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_302abc1a-0d13-49f0-a69a-979520773e4a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_0a87f453-a0d2-406f-b441-8648fb438b55" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_302abc1a-0d13-49f0-a69a-979520773e4a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeAxis_184e98e6-5ceb-4a0c-9a88-029f8d832980" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_641c1b00-a601-4c63-849d-b4767edcb509" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeAxis_184e98e6-5ceb-4a0c-9a88-029f8d832980" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_184e98e6-5ceb-4a0c-9a88-029f8d832980_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_184e98e6-5ceb-4a0c-9a88-029f8d832980" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_184e98e6-5ceb-4a0c-9a88-029f8d832980_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_85688b0e-47e1-486f-9b5a-b62848dfd827" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_184e98e6-5ceb-4a0c-9a88-029f8d832980" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_85688b0e-47e1-486f-9b5a-b62848dfd827" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MaximumMember_8dc6ff6f-cc4c-47a4-927c-4157d339ac14" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MaximumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_85688b0e-47e1-486f-9b5a-b62848dfd827" xlink:to="loc_srt_MaximumMember_8dc6ff6f-cc4c-47a4-927c-4157d339ac14" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeNotionalAmount_17b76cf2-b7cd-4293-8f69-9b4b2029eed6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeNotionalAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeNotionalAmount_17b76cf2-b7cd-4293-8f69-9b4b2029eed6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfInterestRateSwapsEnteredDuringThePeriod_63d5258f-cfdb-44d3-9e98-c02f7a253deb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NumberOfInterestRateSwapsEnteredDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfInterestRateSwapsEnteredDuringThePeriod_63d5258f-cfdb-44d3-9e98-c02f7a253deb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_c543be3c-9c88-4e2e-9688-fbdf40fd2f66" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_c543be3c-9c88-4e2e-9688-fbdf40fd2f66" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgeGainLossToBeReclassifiedWithinTwelveMonths_d264edd4-a5e7-4a25-953a-ed34f9620764" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashFlowHedgeGainLossToBeReclassifiedWithinTwelveMonths"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashFlowHedgeGainLossToBeReclassifiedWithinTwelveMonths_d264edd4-a5e7-4a25-953a-ed34f9620764" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ReceivableForCollateralPostedRelatedToSwaps_ec34b562-ff67-42b5-be46-8220808781dd" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ReceivableForCollateralPostedRelatedToSwaps"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_afg_ReceivableForCollateralPostedRelatedToSwaps_ec34b562-ff67-42b5-be46-8220808781dd" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PayableToReturnCollateralRelatedToSwaps_623ba168-4837-411b-8906-b87da6946591" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PayableToReturnCollateralRelatedToSwaps"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_128c47d3-09c4-427e-a72e-40698a77f161" xlink:to="loc_afg_PayableToReturnCollateralRelatedToSwaps_623ba168-4837-411b-8906-b87da6946591" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesDerivativesincludedintheBalanceSheetatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DerivativesDerivativesincludedintheBalanceSheetatfairvalueDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesDerivativesincludedintheBalanceSheetatfairvalueDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_7d2c05df-e55c-40fa-9361-b8213b698b61" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_a375cc14-5d33-4c94-94b9-eca12558c27c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_7d2c05df-e55c-40fa-9361-b8213b698b61" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_a375cc14-5d33-4c94-94b9-eca12558c27c" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_c40664ef-02fd-4941-8281-80361af862c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_a375cc14-5d33-4c94-94b9-eca12558c27c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_c40664ef-02fd-4941-8281-80361af862c0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_c40664ef-02fd-4941-8281-80361af862c0_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_c40664ef-02fd-4941-8281-80361af862c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_c40664ef-02fd-4941-8281-80361af862c0_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_0787952d-7416-4d2b-89ca-b7e5999a84aa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_c40664ef-02fd-4941-8281-80361af862c0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_0787952d-7416-4d2b-89ca-b7e5999a84aa" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_03fefacd-3f1a-44ed-9c34-c35f1c007790" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_0787952d-7416-4d2b-89ca-b7e5999a84aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_03fefacd-3f1a-44ed-9c34-c35f1c007790" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_e138a76b-13a8-40ee-91f6-c9e45b901d14" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_0787952d-7416-4d2b-89ca-b7e5999a84aa" xlink:to="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_e138a76b-13a8-40ee-91f6-c9e45b901d14" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_fd83b72d-2482-44d4-a000-b3a80e294e33" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_0787952d-7416-4d2b-89ca-b7e5999a84aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_fd83b72d-2482-44d4-a000-b3a80e294e33" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cb19fd58-731f-4d70-93da-9666b54f304a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FairValuesDerivativesBalanceSheetLocationByDerivativeContractTypeByHedgingDesignationTable_a375cc14-5d33-4c94-94b9-eca12558c27c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cb19fd58-731f-4d70-93da-9666b54f304a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_cb19fd58-731f-4d70-93da-9666b54f304a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cb19fd58-731f-4d70-93da-9666b54f304a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_cb19fd58-731f-4d70-93da-9666b54f304a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_5835c562-a5e9-4f93-8cc3-f4961deb8848" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_cb19fd58-731f-4d70-93da-9666b54f304a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_5835c562-a5e9-4f93-8cc3-f4961deb8848" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_325df57c-014a-47af-b6e9-82c6d4565cb5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_5835c562-a5e9-4f93-8cc3-f4961deb8848" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_325df57c-014a-47af-b6e9-82c6d4565cb5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_7954243d-1224-4404-8a7a-f167866e88b9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NondesignatedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_5835c562-a5e9-4f93-8cc3-f4961deb8848" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NondesignatedMember_7954243d-1224-4404-8a7a-f167866e88b9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_6dc8005c-dc21-4d72-bf29-4e0df7e0b6d4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_7d2c05df-e55c-40fa-9361-b8213b698b61" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssets_6dc8005c-dc21-4d72-bf29-4e0df7e0b6d4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_f6e0d4fb-ee99-4202-9d29-507158ca968c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_7d2c05df-e55c-40fa-9361-b8213b698b61" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilities_f6e0d4fb-ee99-4202-9d29-507158ca968c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_13a22806-7969-4a3f-aeb7-4cfd694b4d7a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_7d2c05df-e55c-40fa-9361-b8213b698b61" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeAssetStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_13a22806-7969-4a3f-aeb7-4cfd694b4d7a" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilityStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_cdb43ae9-0f57-4388-a75e-fd9a2e716ce7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilityStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativesFairValueLineItems_7d2c05df-e55c-40fa-9361-b8213b698b61" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeLiabilityStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_cdb43ae9-0f57-4388-a75e-fd9a2e716ce7" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesGainslossesincludedintheStatementofEarningsforchangesinthefairvalueofderivativesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#DerivativesGainslossesincludedintheStatementofEarningsforchangesinthefairvalueofderivativesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/DerivativesGainslossesincludedintheStatementofEarningsforchangesinthefairvalueofderivativesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_9808552e-508a-4cf6-a4a3-a74400e4ee3b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_9808552e-508a-4cf6-a4a3-a74400e4ee3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_fea2cba5-b2b1-4c47-b4b8-e9db5ebafa36" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_fea2cba5-b2b1-4c47-b4b8-e9db5ebafa36" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_fea2cba5-b2b1-4c47-b4b8-e9db5ebafa36_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_fea2cba5-b2b1-4c47-b4b8-e9db5ebafa36" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_fea2cba5-b2b1-4c47-b4b8-e9db5ebafa36_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_396b08f1-60cf-4f03-bdbe-86a3f1ca91d6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationAxis_fea2cba5-b2b1-4c47-b4b8-e9db5ebafa36" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_396b08f1-60cf-4f03-bdbe-86a3f1ca91d6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_42dd4804-e50f-4c08-abb2-2f30075d3c64" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_HedgingDesignationDomain_396b08f1-60cf-4f03-bdbe-86a3f1ca91d6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentMember_42dd4804-e50f-4c08-abb2-2f30075d3c64" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_e865e378-2558-48b7-9b14-027dbb987147" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_e865e378-2558-48b7-9b14-027dbb987147" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e865e378-2558-48b7-9b14-027dbb987147_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_e865e378-2558-48b7-9b14-027dbb987147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_e865e378-2558-48b7-9b14-027dbb987147_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentRiskAxis_e865e378-2558-48b7-9b14-027dbb987147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_6e82a6e1-aa10-4a40-9566-eca18a572bd5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestRateSwapMember_6e82a6e1-aa10-4a40-9566-eca18a572bd5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_a697d75d-b9f1-4947-bc16-b59d7280cf61" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_afg_FixedMaturitySecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_a697d75d-b9f1-4947-bc16-b59d7280cf61" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_e08a1a46-5801-4083-b124-482df8495c10" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_afg_MortgageBackedSecuritiesWithEmbeddedDerivativesMember_e08a1a46-5801-4083-b124-482df8495c10" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_69f1b07f-e31e-474c-af5e-41d54fa7999e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TotalReturnSwapMember_69f1b07f-e31e-474c-af5e-41d54fa7999e" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FixedIndexedandVariableIndexedAnnuitiesEmbeddedDerivativesMember_97327840-87d6-4bc7-8d15-399cc82452d0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FixedIndexedandVariableIndexedAnnuitiesEmbeddedDerivativesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_afg_FixedIndexedandVariableIndexedAnnuitiesEmbeddedDerivativesMember_97327840-87d6-4bc7-8d15-399cc82452d0" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CallOptionMember_4f6da14a-8906-45a4-b926-10f65f8adb65" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CallOptionMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CallOptionMember_4f6da14a-8906-45a4-b926-10f65f8adb65" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PutOptionMember_6afa5751-bcd1-4f34-9201-2950329862c4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PutOptionMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PutOptionMember_6afa5751-bcd1-4f34-9201-2950329862c4" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherContractMember_c804d01b-2ec1-4ec8-876e-b5e8dca6edfa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherContractMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeContractTypeDomain_8c4f190b-8fc2-4847-87aa-eae8ac976190" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherContractMember_c804d01b-2ec1-4ec8-876e-b5e8dca6edfa" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_15a7d813-9a3e-4ea3-adc0-6c775cf51779" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_15a7d813-9a3e-4ea3-adc0-6c775cf51779" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_15a7d813-9a3e-4ea3-adc0-6c775cf51779_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_15a7d813-9a3e-4ea3-adc0-6c775cf51779" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_15a7d813-9a3e-4ea3-adc0-6c775cf51779_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_af6c8cd7-b884-4182-b018-1f86045af0ab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_15a7d813-9a3e-4ea3-adc0-6c775cf51779" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_af6c8cd7-b884-4182-b018-1f86045af0ab" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_a474c92d-f39f-4cc6-b737-689d34522a4a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_af6c8cd7-b884-4182-b018-1f86045af0ab" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_a474c92d-f39f-4cc6-b737-689d34522a4a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_24c71320-a10f-48b0-8dd1-8cc639fb2132" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_24c71320-a10f-48b0-8dd1-8cc639fb2132" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_24c71320-a10f-48b0-8dd1-8cc639fb2132_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_24c71320-a10f-48b0-8dd1-8cc639fb2132" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_24c71320-a10f-48b0-8dd1-8cc639fb2132_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_74f278ef-5d52-4cd3-b015-63cf7b23e948" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_24c71320-a10f-48b0-8dd1-8cc639fb2132" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_74f278ef-5d52-4cd3-b015-63cf7b23e948" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_13a687b1-68ca-442a-855e-75e59178dc98" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_74f278ef-5d52-4cd3-b015-63cf7b23e948" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_13a687b1-68ca-442a-855e-75e59178dc98" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_4afea670-2b61-47f2-bd47-f5eff3b3f57d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresTable_ccd67929-9ffb-42ee-a198-dfe5f34735bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_4afea670-2b61-47f2-bd47-f5eff3b3f57d" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_4afea670-2b61-47f2-bd47-f5eff3b3f57d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_4afea670-2b61-47f2-bd47-f5eff3b3f57d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_4afea670-2b61-47f2-bd47-f5eff3b3f57d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_abd426a0-3454-4e9d-8e73-3b034ad221ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationAxis_4afea670-2b61-47f2-bd47-f5eff3b3f57d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_abd426a0-3454-4e9d-8e73-3b034ad221ef" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_96d9811f-b9fe-463e-9b0a-7eff671e7189" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_abd426a0-3454-4e9d-8e73-3b034ad221ef" xlink:to="loc_afg_RealizedGainsLossesOnSecuritiesMember_96d9811f-b9fe-463e-9b0a-7eff671e7189" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_cde96d26-a1d0-4de5-9270-f7099068df9e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementLocationDomain_abd426a0-3454-4e9d-8e73-3b034ad221ef" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentIncomeMember_cde96d26-a1d0-4de5-9270-f7099068df9e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsNotDesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentsGainLossNet_4c02fb2a-23ba-4166-b893-5afc28b66be2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsNotDesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentsGainLossNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_9808552e-508a-4cf6-a4a3-a74400e4ee3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsNotDesignatedAsHedgingInstrumentsGainLossNet_4c02fb2a-23ba-4166-b893-5afc28b66be2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_39225786-bdc2-4888-ada4-6f7f075f327d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DerivativeInstrumentsAndHedgingActivitiesDisclosuresLineItems_9808552e-508a-4cf6-a4a3-a74400e4ee3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationFromAccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeCurrentPeriodBeforeTax_39225786-bdc2-4888-ada4-6f7f075f327d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ManagedInvestmentEntitiesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_96f6282f-95ab-477c-bb59-e472ed135c69" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_96f6282f-95ab-477c-bb59-e472ed135c69" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_426aa1dd-6cfc-4c44-b5fe-9d4bcb6153ed" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_96f6282f-95ab-477c-bb59-e472ed135c69" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_426aa1dd-6cfc-4c44-b5fe-9d4bcb6153ed" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_426aa1dd-6cfc-4c44-b5fe-9d4bcb6153ed_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_426aa1dd-6cfc-4c44-b5fe-9d4bcb6153ed" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_426aa1dd-6cfc-4c44-b5fe-9d4bcb6153ed_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1c309be9-1a03-4360-9e67-e92ca871d010" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_FinancialInstrumentAxis_426aa1dd-6cfc-4c44-b5fe-9d4bcb6153ed" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1c309be9-1a03-4360-9e67-e92ca871d010" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_159e8dc7-cc6a-4ddb-9cb2-4cbbd1fa9d22" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TransfersAndServicingOfFinancialInstrumentsTypesOfFinancialInstrumentsDomain_1c309be9-1a03-4360-9e67-e92ca871d010" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CollateralizedLoanObligationsMember_159e8dc7-cc6a-4ddb-9cb2-4cbbd1fa9d22" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_457eca42-9a81-4577-984b-835e215b8010" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_96f6282f-95ab-477c-bb59-e472ed135c69" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_457eca42-9a81-4577-984b-835e215b8010" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_457eca42-9a81-4577-984b-835e215b8010_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_457eca42-9a81-4577-984b-835e215b8010" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_457eca42-9a81-4577-984b-835e215b8010_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_0bf2e9b6-1a67-4f3d-a041-ec37db25f155" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_457eca42-9a81-4577-984b-835e215b8010" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_0bf2e9b6-1a67-4f3d-a041-ec37db25f155" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtObligationsMember_f0baaf35-703e-4075-8604-130c309547ab" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtObligationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_0bf2e9b6-1a67-4f3d-a041-ec37db25f155" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtObligationsMember_f0baaf35-703e-4075-8604-130c309547ab" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ManagedbyThirdPartiesMember_4c942d2d-71cc-4191-ba86-85276066ee64" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ManagedbyThirdPartiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_0bf2e9b6-1a67-4f3d-a041-ec37db25f155" xlink:to="loc_afg_ManagedbyThirdPartiesMember_4c942d2d-71cc-4191-ba86-85276066ee64" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_fbc6f243-189b-472a-8240-d4e3f3cab477" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_96f6282f-95ab-477c-bb59-e472ed135c69" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_fbc6f243-189b-472a-8240-d4e3f3cab477" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_fbc6f243-189b-472a-8240-d4e3f3cab477_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_fbc6f243-189b-472a-8240-d4e3f3cab477" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_fbc6f243-189b-472a-8240-d4e3f3cab477_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e14eb77-5362-49e2-a27e-2e3b032b86c8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_fbc6f243-189b-472a-8240-d4e3f3cab477" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e14eb77-5362-49e2-a27e-2e3b032b86c8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesMember_e1dd403d-ea22-4001-bf94-62ba7b78ed54" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e14eb77-5362-49e2-a27e-2e3b032b86c8" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesMember_e1dd403d-ea22-4001-bf94-62ba7b78ed54" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_bd24e4dd-6f46-4b92-b639-49d6b636add3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e14eb77-5362-49e2-a27e-2e3b032b86c8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_bd24e4dd-6f46-4b92-b639-49d6b636add3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_30835121-907b-4df7-ae90-562b0229c0dc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e14eb77-5362-49e2-a27e-2e3b032b86c8" xlink:to="loc_afg_NewCollateralizedLoanObligationTemporaryWarehousingEntitiesMember_30835121-907b-4df7-ae90-562b0229c0dc" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMinimum_ca9e4c92-4f9a-4a16-955d-fefdb40b93aa" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMinimum"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMinimum_ca9e4c92-4f9a-4a16-955d-fefdb40b93aa" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMaximum_34455f7e-f1ad-4708-b001-5c7ba025a3b6" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMaximum"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_PercentageOfInvestmentOfMostSubordinateDebtTrancheOfVariableInterestEntityMaximum_34455f7e-f1ad-4708-b001-5c7ba025a3b6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntities_673775a5-aa64-4344-8b87-950b3e3a83b5" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntities_673775a5-aa64-4344-8b87-950b3e3a83b5" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_61cd1fd4-42c1-4ca9-95e4-a1b2a9edcf5d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_61cd1fd4-42c1-4ca9-95e4-a1b2a9edcf5d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount_f3298579-952b-4a2b-8129-967e8a4ca6bf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMaximumLossExposureAmount_f3298579-952b-4a2b-8129-967e8a4ca6bf" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesFormedDuringThePeriod_ee61a96d-5784-4997-a942-067e4b3b2d92" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesFormedDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesFormedDuringThePeriod_ee61a96d-5784-4997-a942-067e4b3b2d92" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FaceValueOfLiabilitiesIssuedByManagedInvestmentEntitiesOnIssuanceDate_1f299fcd-2ecf-4737-bee1-15ff931c1a70" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FaceValueOfLiabilitiesIssuedByManagedInvestmentEntitiesOnIssuanceDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_FaceValueOfLiabilitiesIssuedByManagedInvestmentEntitiesOnIssuanceDate_1f299fcd-2ecf-4737-bee1-15ff931c1a70" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FaceAmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedAtIssuanceDate_6227820c-3473-4a85-b3fb-f4c1e91bbb0e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FaceAmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedAtIssuanceDate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_FaceAmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedAtIssuanceDate_6227820c-3473-4a85-b3fb-f4c1e91bbb0e" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesSubstantiallyLiquidatedDuringThePeriod_8deb3907-2fc0-4088-8374-2a61b8c2c2a7" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesSubstantiallyLiquidatedDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_NumberOfCollateralizedLoanObligationEntitiesSubstantiallyLiquidatedDuringThePeriod_8deb3907-2fc0-4088-8374-2a61b8c2c2a7" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityInvestments_f63bac23-c24e-430d-a016-caaea26c81cb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityInvestments_f63bac23-c24e-430d-a016-caaea26c81cb" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityDebt_8cc29314-34b9-480e-81b4-711f51ac88ab" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_DifferenceBetweenAggregateUnpaidPrincipalBalanceAndFairValueOfVariableInterestEntityDebt_8cc29314-34b9-480e-81b4-711f51ac88ab" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CarryingAmountOfVariableInterestEntityLoansInDefault_f500fb86-1e99-429c-9c9f-ac9461844a70" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CarryingAmountOfVariableInterestEntityLoansInDefault"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_CarryingAmountOfVariableInterestEntityLoansInDefault_f500fb86-1e99-429c-9c9f-ac9461844a70" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_Aggregateunpaidprincipalbalanceofvariableinterestentityloansindefault_2e17d28c-7f6c-4d71-b58c-ce5316b155dc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_Aggregateunpaidprincipalbalanceofvariableinterestentityloansindefault"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_afg_Aggregateunpaidprincipalbalanceofvariableinterestentityloansindefault_2e17d28c-7f6c-4d71-b58c-ce5316b155dc" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_085c9cf7-67be-4bf6-8ccd-c078ec37d8dc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_ed9f0833-3f2e-4c6e-8379-d0612a1faa66" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities_085c9cf7-67be-4bf6-8ccd-c078ec37d8dc" xlink:type="arc" order="13"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesProgressionofinvestmentinCLOtranchesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ManagedInvestmentEntitiesProgressionofinvestmentinCLOtranchesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesProgressionofinvestmentinCLOtranchesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_565a8e0d-b227-4b51-8e66-08d5cb865483" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_565a8e0d-b227-4b51-8e66-08d5cb865483" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_31d3546d-9925-4950-bb19-85fc3c95c964" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_565a8e0d-b227-4b51-8e66-08d5cb865483" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_31d3546d-9925-4950-bb19-85fc3c95c964" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_31d3546d-9925-4950-bb19-85fc3c95c964_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_31d3546d-9925-4950-bb19-85fc3c95c964" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_31d3546d-9925-4950-bb19-85fc3c95c964_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_7753c6ce-82b5-400a-a91e-94c4e18c960d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_31d3546d-9925-4950-bb19-85fc3c95c964" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_7753c6ce-82b5-400a-a91e-94c4e18c960d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_7bfdd62f-86b8-4373-b5f3-8a6152f3fcc5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_7753c6ce-82b5-400a-a91e-94c4e18c960d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_7bfdd62f-86b8-4373-b5f3-8a6152f3fcc5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_432a1bd0-3519-4bed-8d0d-959fab247a07" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_565a8e0d-b227-4b51-8e66-08d5cb865483" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_432a1bd0-3519-4bed-8d0d-959fab247a07" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_432a1bd0-3519-4bed-8d0d-959fab247a07_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_432a1bd0-3519-4bed-8d0d-959fab247a07" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_432a1bd0-3519-4bed-8d0d-959fab247a07_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_fb2c629d-324f-4269-a104-28cdd427c1c5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_432a1bd0-3519-4bed-8d0d-959fab247a07" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_fb2c629d-324f-4269-a104-28cdd427c1c5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_fd377e17-5cf7-494f-9983-039bf6000c95" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_fb2c629d-324f-4269-a104-28cdd427c1c5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_fd377e17-5cf7-494f-9983-039bf6000c95" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_b6e68d3a-87b6-4b4a-a221-1eb9b80cd632" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_b6e68d3a-87b6-4b4a-a221-1eb9b80cd632" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedDuringThePeriod_12c3b547-c58c-4992-a5cb-5cff1d5a6dc9" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedDuringThePeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_afg_AmountOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesPurchasedDuringThePeriod_12c3b547-c58c-4992-a5cb-5cff1d5a6dc9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedRelatedToSalesOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_f9473673-278b-4134-90b1-4a7403fce6a0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ProceedsReceivedRelatedToSalesOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedRelatedToSalesOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_f9473673-278b-4134-90b1-4a7403fce6a0" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedFromDistributionsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_5cb27cb3-3afc-439c-a40d-7f2bdf73b3a0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ProceedsReceivedFromDistributionsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_afg_ProceedsReceivedFromDistributionsOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_5cb27cb3-3afc-439c-a40d-7f2bdf73b3a0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueOfOwnershipOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_bffb8754-2dfc-411c-9c76-f93e21857714" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ChangeInFairValueOfOwnershipOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInFairValueOfOwnershipOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilities_bffb8754-2dfc-411c-9c76-f93e21857714" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ChangeInAccruedInterestOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesOwned_7338bd09-e883-4618-b62d-e34ca920c78c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ChangeInAccruedInterestOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesOwned"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_83f03627-e2a3-4f65-91d5-90542706851f" xlink:to="loc_afg_ChangeInAccruedInterestOfManagedInvestmentEntitiesLiabilitiesOwned_7338bd09-e883-4618-b62d-e34ca920c78c" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount_d582bf48-19d2-4d5f-a0a9-17e244dc8107" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityEntityMaximumLossExposureAmount"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesSelectedfinancialinformationrelatedtoCLOsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ManagedInvestmentEntitiesSelectedfinancialinformationrelatedtoCLOsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ManagedInvestmentEntitiesSelectedfinancialinformationrelatedtoCLOsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_be35bb47-26ef-497b-b403-7d7d392be356" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_afb50301-a8a7-48fe-9597-b02610b9ef02" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_be35bb47-26ef-497b-b403-7d7d392be356" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_afb50301-a8a7-48fe-9597-b02610b9ef02" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_99cbd8ef-a557-45cb-846d-b822856a67af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_afb50301-a8a7-48fe-9597-b02610b9ef02" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_99cbd8ef-a557-45cb-846d-b822856a67af" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_99cbd8ef-a557-45cb-846d-b822856a67af_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_99cbd8ef-a557-45cb-846d-b822856a67af" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_99cbd8ef-a557-45cb-846d-b822856a67af_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_f20b18af-67b8-45e7-bd83-2ccc5d8ca813" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_99cbd8ef-a557-45cb-846d-b822856a67af" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_f20b18af-67b8-45e7-bd83-2ccc5d8ca813" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_693a3b28-2cfa-4719-ae0b-25b370612deb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_f20b18af-67b8-45e7-bd83-2ccc5d8ca813" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityPrimaryBeneficiaryMember_693a3b28-2cfa-4719-ae0b-25b370612deb" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_e50b5f44-7345-484e-9b9e-f9534125ae29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_afb50301-a8a7-48fe-9597-b02610b9ef02" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_e50b5f44-7345-484e-9b9e-f9534125ae29" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_e50b5f44-7345-484e-9b9e-f9534125ae29_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_e50b5f44-7345-484e-9b9e-f9534125ae29" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_e50b5f44-7345-484e-9b9e-f9534125ae29_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_df062547-50bf-4a2a-9305-f375631592a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOperatingActivitiesSegmentAxis_e50b5f44-7345-484e-9b9e-f9534125ae29" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_df062547-50bf-4a2a-9305-f375631592a2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_d54ca1a5-6bb5-44fa-90b8-bf0f4f882fa1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_df062547-50bf-4a2a-9305-f375631592a2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentContinuingOperationsMember_d54ca1a5-6bb5-44fa-90b8-bf0f4f882fa1" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDiscontinuedOperationsMember_ed8bf2ec-b1a0-414d-89b2-09651d364d1b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDiscontinuedOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentOperatingActivitiesDomain_df062547-50bf-4a2a-9305-f375631592a2" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDiscontinuedOperationsMember_ed8bf2ec-b1a0-414d-89b2-09651d364d1b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_74a5e7f7-a63d-4dff-a7e7-5dd85a0b247a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfVariableInterestEntitiesTable_afb50301-a8a7-48fe-9597-b02610b9ef02" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_74a5e7f7-a63d-4dff-a7e7-5dd85a0b247a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_74a5e7f7-a63d-4dff-a7e7-5dd85a0b247a_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_74a5e7f7-a63d-4dff-a7e7-5dd85a0b247a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_74a5e7f7-a63d-4dff-a7e7-5dd85a0b247a_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_a7569363-992e-41ee-9d0f-0c63505e426a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementBalanceSheetAndAdditionalDisclosuresByDisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsAxis_74a5e7f7-a63d-4dff-a7e7-5dd85a0b247a" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_a7569363-992e-41ee-9d0f-0c63505e426a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_83c67ab9-673f-40d3-8018-c6eb0f2d0d99" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DisposalGroupsIncludingDiscontinuedOperationsNameDomain_a7569363-992e-41ee-9d0f-0c63505e426a" xlink:to="loc_afg_AnnuitySubsidiariesMember_83c67ab9-673f-40d3-8018-c6eb0f2d0d99" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_cf820d3d-f071-4024-9ce3-d94a1e309d74" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableInterestEntityLineItems_be35bb47-26ef-497b-b403-7d7d392be356" xlink:to="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_cf820d3d-f071-4024-9ce3-d94a1e309d74" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_d5159d53-e2d5-48f7-ab84-8b3a8ec7dcbf" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_cf820d3d-f071-4024-9ce3-d94a1e309d74" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_d5159d53-e2d5-48f7-ab84-8b3a8ec7dcbf" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsOfVariableInterestEntities_78a1c010-583e-4354-91f0-266687ed4260" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsOfVariableInterestEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_d5159d53-e2d5-48f7-ab84-8b3a8ec7dcbf" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsOfVariableInterestEntities_78a1c010-583e-4354-91f0-266687ed4260" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfLiabilitiesOfVariableInterestEntities_4c833d17-8500-42f4-88ed-8dce2b55a99f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfLiabilitiesOfVariableInterestEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_GainsLossesOnChangeInFairValueOfAssetsLiabilitiesOfCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_d5159d53-e2d5-48f7-ab84-8b3a8ec7dcbf" xlink:to="loc_afg_GainLossOnChangeInFairValueOfLiabilitiesOfVariableInterestEntities_4c833d17-8500-42f4-88ed-8dce2b55a99f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ManagementFeesPaidByVariableInterestEntities_acde4577-6e14-486c-b8a7-5f564ba1eb2d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ManagementFeesPaidByVariableInterestEntities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_cf820d3d-f071-4024-9ce3-d94a1e309d74" xlink:to="loc_afg_ManagementFeesPaidByVariableInterestEntities_acde4577-6e14-486c-b8a7-5f564ba1eb2d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EarningsLossesOfVariableInterestEntitiesAttributableToShareholders_0cf03f7e-9740-47c7-81a8-a8275377cfeb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EarningsLossesOfVariableInterestEntitiesAttributableToShareholders"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_FinancialInformationRelatedToCollateralizedLoanObligationsAbstract_cf820d3d-f071-4024-9ce3-d94a1e309d74" xlink:to="loc_afg_EarningsLossesOfVariableInterestEntitiesAttributableToShareholders_0cf03f7e-9740-47c7-81a8-a8275377cfeb" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/GoodwillandOtherIntangiblesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#GoodwillandOtherIntangiblesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/GoodwillandOtherIntangiblesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_a5e24e49-8a9c-435a-a1ce-bc4f7f7e1618" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_a5e24e49-8a9c-435a-a1ce-bc4f7f7e1618" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_65ec8453-d3e3-40bb-a24e-681169c169a7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_a5e24e49-8a9c-435a-a1ce-bc4f7f7e1618" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_65ec8453-d3e3-40bb-a24e-681169c169a7" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_65ec8453-d3e3-40bb-a24e-681169c169a7_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_65ec8453-d3e3-40bb-a24e-681169c169a7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_65ec8453-d3e3-40bb-a24e-681169c169a7_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_bef8bf92-7007-4fe2-8e3e-9aefbfd74679" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_65ec8453-d3e3-40bb-a24e-681169c169a7" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_bef8bf92-7007-4fe2-8e3e-9aefbfd74679" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_224412ef-6431-4c80-819c-edf9f97b57a0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_bef8bf92-7007-4fe2-8e3e-9aefbfd74679" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_224412ef-6431-4c80-819c-edf9f97b57a0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_4235d82b-c0e8-4beb-9d65-46db1fec5dbd" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_bef8bf92-7007-4fe2-8e3e-9aefbfd74679" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_4235d82b-c0e8-4beb-9d65-46db1fec5dbd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_1ff3e6d6-6a6e-49ca-8ca8-b8860963809f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_a5e24e49-8a9c-435a-a1ce-bc4f7f7e1618" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_1ff3e6d6-6a6e-49ca-8ca8-b8860963809f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_1ff3e6d6-6a6e-49ca-8ca8-b8860963809f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_1ff3e6d6-6a6e-49ca-8ca8-b8860963809f" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_1ff3e6d6-6a6e-49ca-8ca8-b8860963809f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_cd27d3a8-85e8-4f87-918f-5f74f2916f29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_1ff3e6d6-6a6e-49ca-8ca8-b8860963809f" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_cd27d3a8-85e8-4f87-918f-5f74f2916f29" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_be1de802-4690-405d-adbf-fa089ebe8c97" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_cd27d3a8-85e8-4f87-918f-5f74f2916f29" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_be1de802-4690-405d-adbf-fa089ebe8c97" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss_fb61bb21-b17d-45d2-ad43-0c567ebca0ad" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss_fb61bb21-b17d-45d2-ad43-0c567ebca0ad" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsNet_0ec3cddf-4fd3-43eb-938e-3c1d1321d0ce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsNet_0ec3cddf-4fd3-43eb-938e-3c1d1321d0ce" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAccumulatedAmortization_181e18e2-3f9b-402a-b06f-d2f58dcb1781" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAccumulatedAmortization"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAccumulatedAmortization_181e18e2-3f9b-402a-b06f-d2f58dcb1781" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AmortizationOfIntangibleAssets_17683527-8e25-463e-9d72-428b5344b671" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AmortizationOfIntangibleAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AmortizationOfIntangibleAssets_17683527-8e25-463e-9d72-428b5344b671" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AcquiredFiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsWeightedAverageUsefulLife_b5536eb3-5d6c-42b1-88ac-52db828f00cf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AcquiredFiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsWeightedAverageUsefulLife"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AcquiredFiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsWeightedAverageUsefulLife_b5536eb3-5d6c-42b1-88ac-52db828f00cf" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseNextTwelveMonths_1c843bf3-6419-48bd-933a-2ea9b3ca2501" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseNextTwelveMonths"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseNextTwelveMonths_1c843bf3-6419-48bd-933a-2ea9b3ca2501" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearTwo_fcfb96ef-2d59-42f3-b580-9e579a97d3f7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearTwo"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearTwo_fcfb96ef-2d59-42f3-b580-9e579a97d3f7" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearThree_442f427f-7b2c-4537-ba21-1bace32efddb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearThree"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearThree_442f427f-7b2c-4537-ba21-1bace32efddb" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearFour_e120967a-b2f6-4ebd-a8ab-8326e0a4d9e2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearFour"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearFour_e120967a-b2f6-4ebd-a8ab-8326e0a4d9e2" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearFive_de8b2a18-e8e3-47b1-b0d9-c06bf8795d12" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseYearFive_de8b2a18-e8e3-47b1-b0d9-c06bf8795d12" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseAfterYearFive_501c0efc-a5a6-47ac-beca-98d3f720b8e6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseAfterYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_d189dee4-5d55-4849-83e4-d2c5ba2b2f49" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_FiniteLivedIntangibleAssetsAmortizationExpenseAfterYearFive_501c0efc-a5a6-47ac-beca-98d3f720b8e6" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/GoodwillandOtherIntangiblesChangesinthecarryingvalueofgoodwillDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#GoodwillandOtherIntangiblesChangesinthecarryingvalueofgoodwillDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/GoodwillandOtherIntangiblesChangesinthecarryingvalueofgoodwillDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_16e320f9-a088-4dba-ae02-52d6b179277e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_7ee618a4-4677-4041-b29b-47d6f2e9ff14" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_16e320f9-a088-4dba-ae02-52d6b179277e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_7ee618a4-4677-4041-b29b-47d6f2e9ff14" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_e338594a-468e-4ec8-bfce-263f48402d88" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_7ee618a4-4677-4041-b29b-47d6f2e9ff14" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_e338594a-468e-4ec8-bfce-263f48402d88" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_e338594a-468e-4ec8-bfce-263f48402d88_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_e338594a-468e-4ec8-bfce-263f48402d88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_e338594a-468e-4ec8-bfce-263f48402d88_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_859b63a9-5eb5-43a0-b050-475a5b571b18" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_e338594a-468e-4ec8-bfce-263f48402d88" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_859b63a9-5eb5-43a0-b050-475a5b571b18" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_52fec9b6-aefa-4f39-b8b4-5700277be1b0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_859b63a9-5eb5-43a0-b050-475a5b571b18" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_52fec9b6-aefa-4f39-b8b4-5700277be1b0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_a940146b-9137-459b-8ad0-aef603df7a44" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_859b63a9-5eb5-43a0-b050-475a5b571b18" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_a940146b-9137-459b-8ad0-aef603df7a44" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_3f28c84f-41bd-4e4f-9738-bd089b1cb6a7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfGoodwillTable_7ee618a4-4677-4041-b29b-47d6f2e9ff14" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_3f28c84f-41bd-4e4f-9738-bd089b1cb6a7" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_3f28c84f-41bd-4e4f-9738-bd089b1cb6a7_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_3f28c84f-41bd-4e4f-9738-bd089b1cb6a7" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_3f28c84f-41bd-4e4f-9738-bd089b1cb6a7_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d23f480d-2ac4-40a7-9ec2-49f4919cbd15" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_3f28c84f-41bd-4e4f-9738-bd089b1cb6a7" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d23f480d-2ac4-40a7-9ec2-49f4919cbd15" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_f9fe1f41-bfea-4142-8ee3-3bb25968a612" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VerikaiIncMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d23f480d-2ac4-40a7-9ec2-49f4919cbd15" xlink:to="loc_afg_VerikaiIncMember_f9fe1f41-bfea-4142-8ee3-3bb25968a612" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Goodwill_41c1609b-0058-4ca7-97b8-ecbceb402f27" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Goodwill"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_16e320f9-a088-4dba-ae02-52d6b179277e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Goodwill_41c1609b-0058-4ca7-97b8-ecbceb402f27" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_d956bb51-a293-4a14-a195-770db2456fea" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_16e320f9-a088-4dba-ae02-52d6b179277e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillAcquiredDuringPeriod_d956bb51-a293-4a14-a195-770db2456fea" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss_cd90fc6f-b934-4382-b9ae-a3e8f0d0332f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillLineItems_16e320f9-a088-4dba-ae02-52d6b179277e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GoodwillImpairmentLoss_cd90fc6f-b934-4382-b9ae-a3e8f0d0332f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Goodwill_5409d3c8-b932-4e94-92ed-14b0f8f878d4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Goodwill"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#LongTermDebtNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_82d590bb-873f-4193-8fa7-5c50a633f124" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_82d590bb-873f-4193-8fa7-5c50a633f124" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_82d590bb-873f-4193-8fa7-5c50a633f124_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_82d590bb-873f-4193-8fa7-5c50a633f124" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_82d590bb-873f-4193-8fa7-5c50a633f124_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_825574fb-c631-45f7-9aa9-136c5c2c2397" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_82d590bb-873f-4193-8fa7-5c50a633f124" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_825574fb-c631-45f7-9aa9-136c5c2c2397" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_16ffaf31-954e-4859-9dd1-9608b3a5b641" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_825574fb-c631-45f7-9aa9-136c5c2c2397" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_16ffaf31-954e-4859-9dd1-9608b3a5b641" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_e1c116f0-ecb4-4cd3-ba83-e88b43866a3e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_e1c116f0-ecb4-4cd3-ba83-e88b43866a3e" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_e1c116f0-ecb4-4cd3-ba83-e88b43866a3e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_e1c116f0-ecb4-4cd3-ba83-e88b43866a3e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_e1c116f0-ecb4-4cd3-ba83-e88b43866a3e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_335aa60f-887c-4a54-ad0e-b00c2b8551ca" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_e1c116f0-ecb4-4cd3-ba83-e88b43866a3e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_335aa60f-887c-4a54-ad0e-b00c2b8551ca" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_954c2f85-20b0-47f6-8452-2c42c61abb09" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_335aa60f-887c-4a54-ad0e-b00c2b8551ca" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_954c2f85-20b0-47f6-8452-2c42c61abb09" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_0a1cf558-281c-43c1-a7c1-2c7b44d99139" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_335aa60f-887c-4a54-ad0e-b00c2b8551ca" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_0a1cf558-281c-43c1-a7c1-2c7b44d99139" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInAugust2026Member_31850499-0597-4116-9c81-09674035fceb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInAugust2026Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_335aa60f-887c-4a54-ad0e-b00c2b8551ca" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInAugust2026Member_31850499-0597-4116-9c81-09674035fceb" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateAxis_bb9b001b-881c-4f86-9a29-d59b60ba6752" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableRateAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateAxis_bb9b001b-881c-4f86-9a29-d59b60ba6752" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateDomain_bb9b001b-881c-4f86-9a29-d59b60ba6752_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableRateDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateAxis_bb9b001b-881c-4f86-9a29-d59b60ba6752" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateDomain_bb9b001b-881c-4f86-9a29-d59b60ba6752_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateDomain_1ba51313-4394-4e4a-a9c3-8e2415ad598e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VariableRateDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateAxis_bb9b001b-881c-4f86-9a29-d59b60ba6752" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateDomain_1ba51313-4394-4e4a-a9c3-8e2415ad598e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SecuredOvernightFinancingRateSofrOvernightIndexSwapRateMember_cab76dca-abba-4c80-9dd6-b09f18e08c6d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SecuredOvernightFinancingRateSofrOvernightIndexSwapRateMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VariableRateDomain_1ba51313-4394-4e4a-a9c3-8e2415ad598e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SecuredOvernightFinancingRateSofrOvernightIndexSwapRateMember_cab76dca-abba-4c80-9dd6-b09f18e08c6d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d45a216f-93d9-4d10-bd62-d229527a6757" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d45a216f-93d9-4d10-bd62-d229527a6757" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d45a216f-93d9-4d10-bd62-d229527a6757_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d45a216f-93d9-4d10-bd62-d229527a6757" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d45a216f-93d9-4d10-bd62-d229527a6757_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_a6d3f783-c2c9-484c-9108-e751663ee5c9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d45a216f-93d9-4d10-bd62-d229527a6757" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_a6d3f783-c2c9-484c-9108-e751663ee5c9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_05447575-ae58-4f10-bb9a-babe5cce322e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_a6d3f783-c2c9-484c-9108-e751663ee5c9" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_05447575-ae58-4f10-bb9a-babe5cce322e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeAxis_584f710b-4e22-40e6-81f3-15fa7a5f5697" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_2f9c06d7-8d97-4309-88b7-022faf7676ae" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeAxis_584f710b-4e22-40e6-81f3-15fa7a5f5697" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_584f710b-4e22-40e6-81f3-15fa7a5f5697_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_584f710b-4e22-40e6-81f3-15fa7a5f5697" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_584f710b-4e22-40e6-81f3-15fa7a5f5697_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_1d0c6b3f-b7aa-4015-bc32-05142acd673e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_584f710b-4e22-40e6-81f3-15fa7a5f5697" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_1d0c6b3f-b7aa-4015-bc32-05142acd673e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MinimumMember_9ebd0eef-d3eb-4b4e-b26d-18258be8292f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MinimumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_1d0c6b3f-b7aa-4015-bc32-05142acd673e" xlink:to="loc_srt_MinimumMember_9ebd0eef-d3eb-4b4e-b26d-18258be8292f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MaximumMember_3eb50244-f2c0-4dcb-ba4b-f3c2ce1b66e2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MaximumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_1d0c6b3f-b7aa-4015-bc32-05142acd673e" xlink:to="loc_srt_MaximumMember_3eb50244-f2c0-4dcb-ba4b-f3c2ce1b66e2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInNextTwelveMonths_86925625-337b-4d90-8603-59b2363add40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInNextTwelveMonths"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInNextTwelveMonths_86925625-337b-4d90-8603-59b2363add40" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearTwo_18037764-566c-4594-956f-b1d5072a43b3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearTwo"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearTwo_18037764-566c-4594-956f-b1d5072a43b3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearThree_7afee4c1-9359-4496-98f9-6b63cc3d5d45" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearThree"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearThree_7afee4c1-9359-4496-98f9-6b63cc3d5d45" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFour_d243607c-0c61-416f-a729-e604082149d9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFour"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFour_d243607c-0c61-416f-a729-e604082149d9" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFive_1141e949-b71c-4f01-8df5-66ca59d5ba52" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalInYearFive_1141e949-b71c-4f01-8df5-66ca59d5ba52" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalAfterYearFive_ecf79d9c-58a9-4046-a59a-2a2875d2245d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalAfterYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtByMaturityAbstract_a05ef4ae-af35-425b-91f7-df1abdf81ce9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebtMaturitiesRepaymentsOfPrincipalAfterYearFive_ecf79d9c-58a9-4046-a59a-2a2875d2245d" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchasedFaceAmount_54bb31a0-e692-4197-832e-a4c7cb64ddff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchasedFaceAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchasedFaceAmount_54bb31a0-e692-4197-832e-a4c7cb64ddff" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_0a5d0a97-e317-4560-bc56-0160ec8d2fc5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_0a5d0a97-e317-4560-bc56-0160ec8d2fc5" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchaseAmount_6c6d94e0-d542-46bc-ba31-edbff5dc69be" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchaseAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentRepurchaseAmount_6c6d94e0-d542-46bc-ba31-edbff5dc69be" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RepaymentsOfLongTermDebt_c1f30946-be8c-4977-8932-7bd858ea7edc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RepaymentsOfLongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RepaymentsOfLongTermDebt_c1f30946-be8c-4977-8932-7bd858ea7edc" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt_86ed0747-6693-4d8d-9333-3154aaedc957" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_GainsLossesOnExtinguishmentOfDebt_86ed0747-6693-4d8d-9333-3154aaedc957" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTerm_542d3daf-8d4f-477d-acea-e13c5a3d796c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTerm"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTerm_542d3daf-8d4f-477d-acea-e13c5a3d796c" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCreditFacilityMaximumBorrowingCapacity_fce13e3a-5f96-41d5-93a6-6620a54f7efc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LineOfCreditFacilityMaximumBorrowingCapacity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCreditFacilityMaximumBorrowingCapacity_fce13e3a-5f96-41d5-93a6-6620a54f7efc" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentBasisSpreadOnVariableRate1_02639a19-bbfb-43ff-bde0-f25ea12a7229" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentBasisSpreadOnVariableRate1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentBasisSpreadOnVariableRate1_02639a19-bbfb-43ff-bde0-f25ea12a7229" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCredit_06e084a6-e0ed-4c60-8e4a-3888288ca680" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LineOfCredit"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LineOfCredit_06e084a6-e0ed-4c60-8e4a-3888288ca680" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestPaid_4db2f689-82d9-4372-a449-c0d1c55d1e40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InterestPaid"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_cac78325-8426-44b9-b376-31f973afc001" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestPaid_4db2f689-82d9-4372-a449-c0d1c55d1e40" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtScheduleoflongtermdebtDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#LongTermDebtScheduleoflongtermdebtDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/LongTermDebtScheduleoflongtermdebtDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_491fa47d-9b31-42fb-bb28-74231e7432ee" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_1b8bfee3-3e47-4950-be25-4f00e2b91970" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_491fa47d-9b31-42fb-bb28-74231e7432ee" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_1b8bfee3-3e47-4950-be25-4f00e2b91970" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_dddb0f98-2847-4186-8988-630ed08fb9ed" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_1b8bfee3-3e47-4950-be25-4f00e2b91970" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_dddb0f98-2847-4186-8988-630ed08fb9ed" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_dddb0f98-2847-4186-8988-630ed08fb9ed_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_dddb0f98-2847-4186-8988-630ed08fb9ed" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_dddb0f98-2847-4186-8988-630ed08fb9ed_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_35f7e791-fc38-4e0a-a702-2f91baee87bb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeAxis_dddb0f98-2847-4186-8988-630ed08fb9ed" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_35f7e791-fc38-4e0a-a702-2f91baee87bb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_caaad574-fc3e-4e8c-b217-088302a4ef13" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_35f7e791-fc38-4e0a-a702-2f91baee87bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SeniorNotesMember_caaad574-fc3e-4e8c-b217-088302a4ef13" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtMember_e8eb99aa-5835-4e91-af19-38e2bc89ac02" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LongtermDebtTypeDomain_35f7e791-fc38-4e0a-a702-2f91baee87bb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubordinatedDebtMember_e8eb99aa-5835-4e91-af19-38e2bc89ac02" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_c5e8b222-3cca-475f-a1fc-ef103d89be40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_1b8bfee3-3e47-4950-be25-4f00e2b91970" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_c5e8b222-3cca-475f-a1fc-ef103d89be40" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_c5e8b222-3cca-475f-a1fc-ef103d89be40_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_c5e8b222-3cca-475f-a1fc-ef103d89be40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_c5e8b222-3cca-475f-a1fc-ef103d89be40_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentAxis_c5e8b222-3cca-475f-a1fc-ef103d89be40" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_9d104423-d581-4a5b-b856-b1032e719151" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInJune2047Member_9d104423-d581-4a5b-b856-b1032e719151" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_eefa394c-f0ae-40c5-968f-6fb45009881a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_SeniorNotesDueInApril2030Member_eefa394c-f0ae-40c5-968f-6fb45009881a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherLongtermDebtMember_c2e9bb81-09eb-4f40-b783-8a3e70dd5dca" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherLongtermDebtMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherLongtermDebtMember_c2e9bb81-09eb-4f40-b783-8a3e70dd5dca" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_e78a5db1-0793-4f7f-9516-48394904412c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInSeptember2060Member_e78a5db1-0793-4f7f-9516-48394904412c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_b88f4b72-fa3d-4f05-8e90-603d96f8dc77" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesdueinDecember2059Member_b88f4b72-fa3d-4f05-8e90-603d96f8dc77" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_204e9b8a-84f9-4b0f-bf10-986ad5f7ed6a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInJune2060Member_204e9b8a-84f9-4b0f-bf10-986ad5f7ed6a" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_9fff4225-0cf4-439a-aad7-530005b82925" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentNameDomain_68194e44-6f42-4a6c-95f6-e1f7135e7743" xlink:to="loc_afg_SubordinatedDebenturesDueInMarch2059Member_9fff4225-0cf4-439a-aad7-530005b82925" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_b73c82c3-6bba-4191-bece-858abc4b83cd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentTable_1b8bfee3-3e47-4950-be25-4f00e2b91970" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_b73c82c3-6bba-4191-bece-858abc4b83cd" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_b73c82c3-6bba-4191-bece-858abc4b83cd_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_b73c82c3-6bba-4191-bece-858abc4b83cd" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_b73c82c3-6bba-4191-bece-858abc4b83cd_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_46d0c5e1-a200-4232-b4c6-47569f4bc50b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_b73c82c3-6bba-4191-bece-858abc4b83cd" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_46d0c5e1-a200-4232-b4c6-47569f4bc50b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_56e7958d-a2d7-4fba-b01f-e6488e8a92f7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_46d0c5e1-a200-4232-b4c6-47569f4bc50b" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_56e7958d-a2d7-4fba-b01f-e6488e8a92f7" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_9f4e1d5b-ed1f-4f87-8d0c-694a539fa30d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_491fa47d-9b31-42fb-bb28-74231e7432ee" xlink:to="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_9f4e1d5b-ed1f-4f87-8d0c-694a539fa30d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentCarryingAmount_932a9832-b122-46da-925d-1a62234812a4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentCarryingAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_9f4e1d5b-ed1f-4f87-8d0c-694a539fa30d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentCarryingAmount_932a9832-b122-46da-925d-1a62234812a4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DeferredFinanceCostsNet_56140407-3475-45b0-816a-075d6d949e49" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DeferredFinanceCostsNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_9f4e1d5b-ed1f-4f87-8d0c-694a539fa30d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DeferredFinanceCostsNet_56140407-3475-45b0-816a-075d6d949e49" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_46c03782-2d85-46d4-864a-90012a41f082" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_SummaryOfCarryingValueOfLongTermDebtAbstract_9f4e1d5b-ed1f-4f87-8d0c-694a539fa30d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_46c03782-2d85-46d4-864a-90012a41f082" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_b418a0d2-31c9-4a65-a7f2-7d9030f97555" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentLineItems_491fa47d-9b31-42fb-bb28-74231e7432ee" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtInstrumentInterestRateStatedPercentage_b418a0d2-31c9-4a65-a7f2-7d9030f97555" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityPreferredstockauthorizedforissuanceDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ShareholdersEquityPreferredstockauthorizedforissuanceDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityPreferredstockauthorizedforissuanceDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_267634b9-0a0a-487e-8124-8ec1a26af4cf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable_eec536de-a730-4f89-879e-77ff23b98774" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_267634b9-0a0a-487e-8124-8ec1a26af4cf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable_eec536de-a730-4f89-879e-77ff23b98774" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_34d8990b-5735-4f87-a6f9-c03bf9af0c7d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfStockByClassTable_eec536de-a730-4f89-879e-77ff23b98774" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_34d8990b-5735-4f87-a6f9-c03bf9af0c7d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_34d8990b-5735-4f87-a6f9-c03bf9af0c7d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_34d8990b-5735-4f87-a6f9-c03bf9af0c7d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_34d8990b-5735-4f87-a6f9-c03bf9af0c7d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_489ee013-2604-42ef-bed0-572d3e3cf0b8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementClassOfStockAxis_34d8990b-5735-4f87-a6f9-c03bf9af0c7d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_489ee013-2604-42ef-bed0-572d3e3cf0b8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_VotingPreferredStockMember_77796fea-5a84-4884-badf-b86fa35aa622" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_VotingPreferredStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_489ee013-2604-42ef-bed0-572d3e3cf0b8" xlink:to="loc_afg_VotingPreferredStockMember_77796fea-5a84-4884-badf-b86fa35aa622" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_NonvotingPreferredStockMember_abbaa6a7-3834-4e69-a025-651c85171be4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_NonvotingPreferredStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockDomain_489ee013-2604-42ef-bed0-572d3e3cf0b8" xlink:to="loc_afg_NonvotingPreferredStockMember_abbaa6a7-3834-4e69-a025-651c85171be4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockSharesAuthorized_d4d18795-a5e9-4c65-8568-2ce3018b3cb4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PreferredStockSharesAuthorized"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_267634b9-0a0a-487e-8124-8ec1a26af4cf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockSharesAuthorized_d4d18795-a5e9-4c65-8568-2ce3018b3cb4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockNoParValue_b3879cd3-157d-4510-a5b0-87a4da22cdc6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PreferredStockNoParValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClassOfStockLineItems_267634b9-0a0a-487e-8124-8ec1a26af4cf" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PreferredStockNoParValue_b3879cd3-157d-4510-a5b0-87a4da22cdc6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ShareholdersEquityNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_0cfbe1de-aea0-4a81-b483-be1481bceb5c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_0cfbe1de-aea0-4a81-b483-be1481bceb5c" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_d132db7a-2a6f-41b7-bcca-a7f5c7c5d90e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_0cfbe1de-aea0-4a81-b483-be1481bceb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_d132db7a-2a6f-41b7-bcca-a7f5c7c5d90e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_d132db7a-2a6f-41b7-bcca-a7f5c7c5d90e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_d132db7a-2a6f-41b7-bcca-a7f5c7c5d90e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_d132db7a-2a6f-41b7-bcca-a7f5c7c5d90e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_946556a1-7efa-499d-a7d8-3c5461e0e713" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_d132db7a-2a6f-41b7-bcca-a7f5c7c5d90e" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_946556a1-7efa-499d-a7d8-3c5461e0e713" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember_8d4b9900-914f-4d0c-a4d9-466ca070869d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_946556a1-7efa-499d-a7d8-3c5461e0e713" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember_8d4b9900-914f-4d0c-a4d9-466ca070869d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember_bf389ba5-01d3-4e0d-a544-80255f22f180" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_946556a1-7efa-499d-a7d8-3c5461e0e713" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember_bf389ba5-01d3-4e0d-a544-80255f22f180" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeStockOptionMember_57156a4a-e7c2-416d-9be8-1413380951cf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EmployeeStockOptionMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_946556a1-7efa-499d-a7d8-3c5461e0e713" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeStockOptionMember_57156a4a-e7c2-416d-9be8-1413380951cf" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VestingAxis_253d4aa7-df44-400a-9af2-e916da433bba" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VestingAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_0cfbe1de-aea0-4a81-b483-be1481bceb5c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VestingAxis_253d4aa7-df44-400a-9af2-e916da433bba" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_253d4aa7-df44-400a-9af2-e916da433bba_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VestingDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingAxis_253d4aa7-df44-400a-9af2-e916da433bba" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_253d4aa7-df44-400a-9af2-e916da433bba_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_VestingDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingAxis_253d4aa7-df44-400a-9af2-e916da433bba" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheOneMember_a68645ac-0490-4bd0-81e6-c39d9c6a070d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheOneMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheOneMember_a68645ac-0490-4bd0-81e6-c39d9c6a070d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheTwoMember_df11bb98-6ebd-4615-a1bf-631ef8232c40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheTwoMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheTwoMember_df11bb98-6ebd-4615-a1bf-631ef8232c40" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheThreeMember_e0c4b3f1-40bd-4af5-817a-6949e4c4dd90" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheThreeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationAwardTrancheThreeMember_e0c4b3f1-40bd-4af5-817a-6949e4c4dd90" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShareBasedPaymentArrangementTrancheFourMember_30b4e2e7-d9d4-4bc9-b5f3-0a22d38a5e1a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShareBasedPaymentArrangementTrancheFourMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShareBasedPaymentArrangementTrancheFourMember_30b4e2e7-d9d4-4bc9-b5f3-0a22d38a5e1a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShareBasedPaymentArrangementTrancheFiveMember_60d834e6-7bad-41b0-87b4-d4c3a7ed79cc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShareBasedPaymentArrangementTrancheFiveMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_VestingDomain_a69f120c-8ef7-47ec-b46f-cdab4fdfaf96" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShareBasedPaymentArrangementTrancheFiveMember_60d834e6-7bad-41b0-87b4-d4c3a7ed79cc" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardNumberOfSharesAuthorized_d6c2779f-79d3-43ae-9453-628215f14335" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardNumberOfSharesAuthorized"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardNumberOfSharesAuthorized_d6c2779f-79d3-43ae-9453-628215f14335" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingPeriod1_de438d19-d378-40fc-ab45-9888ac28de73" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingPeriod1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingPeriod1_de438d19-d378-40fc-ab45-9888ac28de73" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriodTotalFairValue_2c3e5960-c129-4560-bad3-2ac4ec2c9339" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriodTotalFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriodTotalFairValue_2c3e5960-c129-4560-bad3-2ac4ec2c9339" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SharebasedCompensationArrangementBySharebasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingRightsPercentage_2781b3e8-5d43-4b8a-a800-553426094497" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SharebasedCompensationArrangementBySharebasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingRightsPercentage"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SharebasedCompensationArrangementBySharebasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingRightsPercentage_2781b3e8-5d43-4b8a-a800-553426094497" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingRightsPeriodBeforeVestingCommences_d1dcf38b-94c1-442e-aa85-1bc5cd3958d3" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingRightsPeriodBeforeVestingCommences"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardVestingRightsPeriodBeforeVestingCommences_d1dcf38b-94c1-442e-aa85-1bc5cd3958d3" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SharebasedCompensationArrangementBySharebasedPaymentAwardExpirationPeriod_a77a5929-d8bc-44e2-94c3-6037871a6d06" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SharebasedCompensationArrangementBySharebasedPaymentAwardExpirationPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SharebasedCompensationArrangementBySharebasedPaymentAwardExpirationPeriod_a77a5929-d8bc-44e2-94c3-6037871a6d06" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardOptionsExercisesInPeriodTotalIntrinsicValue_619d037b-f3cd-49e0-8b4d-c3a5a6ac3e76" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardOptionsExercisesInPeriodTotalIntrinsicValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardOptionsExercisesInPeriodTotalIntrinsicValue_619d037b-f3cd-49e0-8b4d-c3a5a6ac3e76" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromStockOptionsExercised_ebb28f86-661a-47e7-887b-5d757167422c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ProceedsFromStockOptionsExercised"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromStockOptionsExercised_ebb28f86-661a-47e7-887b-5d757167422c" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationTaxBenefitFromExerciseOfStockOptions_b81875b9-7297-4f20-8d3f-f37ef74a87b3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationTaxBenefitFromExerciseOfStockOptions"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationTaxBenefitFromExerciseOfStockOptions_b81875b9-7297-4f20-8d3f-f37ef74a87b3" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AllocatedShareBasedCompensationExpense_100312dc-c46f-4127-b1c6-b6626456fd93" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AllocatedShareBasedCompensationExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AllocatedShareBasedCompensationExpense_100312dc-c46f-4127-b1c6-b6626456fd93" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationTaxBenefitFromCompensationExpense_41fe8fcc-6afc-4239-8220-f666ef2098b2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationTaxBenefitFromCompensationExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationTaxBenefitFromCompensationExpense_41fe8fcc-6afc-4239-8220-f666ef2098b2" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationNonvestedAwardsTotalCompensationCostNotYetRecognizedPeriodForRecognition1_8217faa6-2499-467a-b314-ec152cc7c58a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationNonvestedAwardsTotalCompensationCostNotYetRecognizedPeriodForRecognition1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationNonvestedAwardsTotalCompensationCostNotYetRecognizedPeriodForRecognition1_8217faa6-2499-467a-b314-ec152cc7c58a" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationNonvestedAwardsTotalCompensationCostNotYetRecognized_c532cb73-6045-4c35-87a3-76e025cf380f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationNonvestedAwardsTotalCompensationCostNotYetRecognized"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_a5810bca-e539-4361-b209-ab82f68798fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EmployeeServiceShareBasedCompensationNonvestedAwardsTotalCompensationCostNotYetRecognized_c532cb73-6045-4c35-87a3-76e025cf380f" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityDatarelatingtograntsofrestrictedstockDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ShareholdersEquityDatarelatingtograntsofrestrictedstockDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityDatarelatingtograntsofrestrictedstockDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_523a25fa-addd-4f1c-a0c9-09b729f9f00c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_b7eeaba5-ef0a-4444-9bf5-0665d82bd095" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_523a25fa-addd-4f1c-a0c9-09b729f9f00c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_b7eeaba5-ef0a-4444-9bf5-0665d82bd095" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_ec0fedee-cb4d-491e-9d1e-54719247a319" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ScheduleOfShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardTable_b7eeaba5-ef0a-4444-9bf5-0665d82bd095" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_ec0fedee-cb4d-491e-9d1e-54719247a319" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_ec0fedee-cb4d-491e-9d1e-54719247a319_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_ec0fedee-cb4d-491e-9d1e-54719247a319" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_ec0fedee-cb4d-491e-9d1e-54719247a319_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_9c4d2e05-ecd0-47a2-98bd-7f8e2a694de0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AwardTypeAxis_ec0fedee-cb4d-491e-9d1e-54719247a319" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_9c4d2e05-ecd0-47a2-98bd-7f8e2a694de0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember_4f169228-7684-4219-8bf1-67a4b3b1f97d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain_9c4d2e05-ecd0-47a2-98bd-7f8e2a694de0" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember_4f169228-7684-4219-8bf1-67a4b3b1f97d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward_1864db2a-b054-4069-a603-f14db695fac6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_523a25fa-addd-4f1c-a0c9-09b729f9f00c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward_1864db2a-b054-4069-a603-f14db695fac6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedNumber_65eb02c7-4b0c-4ab4-ad48-d7e2568fce25" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedNumber"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward_1864db2a-b054-4069-a603-f14db695fac6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedNumber_65eb02c7-4b0c-4ab4-ad48-d7e2568fce25" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriod_4b8f435b-0697-4097-8226-60c8e041800f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward_1864db2a-b054-4069-a603-f14db695fac6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriod_4b8f435b-0697-4097-8226-60c8e041800f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriod_bca88bb5-f492-42fc-889a-ff28cd499cf0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward_1864db2a-b054-4069-a603-f14db695fac6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriod_bca88bb5-f492-42fc-889a-ff28cd499cf0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsForfeitedInPeriod_e9d181f1-7be6-4040-933c-dff202d793f6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsForfeitedInPeriod"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedRollForward_1864db2a-b054-4069-a603-f14db695fac6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsForfeitedInPeriod_e9d181f1-7be6-4040-933c-dff202d793f6" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedNumber_79bd8b41-4899-4444-8198-b5da59518210" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedNumber"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward_c3d00ba5-dc03-49f6-86ba-f4a3bb6e5536" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardLineItems_523a25fa-addd-4f1c-a0c9-09b729f9f00c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward_c3d00ba5-dc03-49f6-86ba-f4a3bb6e5536" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_f170f308-7de7-42c7-ab70-9255fd35aff9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward_c3d00ba5-dc03-49f6-86ba-f4a3bb6e5536" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_f170f308-7de7-42c7-ab70-9255fd35aff9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_bfb6eddf-7e66-4225-9f2c-9daa84181e1d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward_c3d00ba5-dc03-49f6-86ba-f4a3bb6e5536" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsGrantsInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_bfb6eddf-7e66-4225-9f2c-9daa84181e1d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_236865e8-e971-4847-94da-7302c4091ef3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward_c3d00ba5-dc03-49f6-86ba-f4a3bb6e5536" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsVestedInPeriodWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_236865e8-e971-4847-94da-7302c4091ef3" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsForfeituresWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_e6699d02-3d70-4cae-846d-bf624ba9579f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsForfeituresWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValueRollForward_c3d00ba5-dc03-49f6-86ba-f4a3bb6e5536" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsForfeituresWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_e6699d02-3d70-4cae-846d-bf624ba9579f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue_f98d265a-930a-41e6-b8b9-06591ed4f22a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementByShareBasedPaymentAwardEquityInstrumentsOtherThanOptionsNonvestedWeightedAverageGrantDateFairValue"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityProgressionofthecomponentsofaccumulatedothercomprehensiveincomeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ShareholdersEquityProgressionofthecomponentsofaccumulatedothercomprehensiveincomeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ShareholdersEquityProgressionofthecomponentsofaccumulatedothercomprehensiveincomeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable_b63e5268-5d7f-4334-b01e-bdef4e27ce05" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable_b63e5268-5d7f-4334-b01e-bdef4e27ce05" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_4b5521cc-ad01-4d9b-87b7-9707a78ce7ce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTable_b63e5268-5d7f-4334-b01e-bdef4e27ce05" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_4b5521cc-ad01-4d9b-87b7-9707a78ce7ce" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_4b5521cc-ad01-4d9b-87b7-9707a78ce7ce_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_4b5521cc-ad01-4d9b-87b7-9707a78ce7ce" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_4b5521cc-ad01-4d9b-87b7-9707a78ce7ce_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementEquityComponentsAxis_4b5521cc-ad01-4d9b-87b7-9707a78ce7ce" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedNetUnrealizedInvestmentGainLossMember_bcc66b0b-c0e0-40f2-9707-ae56e6283e65" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedNetUnrealizedInvestmentGainLossMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedNetUnrealizedInvestmentGainLossMember_bcc66b0b-c0e0-40f2-9707-ae56e6283e65" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedGainLossNetCashFlowHedgeParentMember_26590402-1c51-4cdc-ade6-d9c9519066bf" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedGainLossNetCashFlowHedgeParentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedGainLossNetCashFlowHedgeParentMember_26590402-1c51-4cdc-ade6-d9c9519066bf" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember_e0575966-3b51-42c3-90fe-7a0f664ae791" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedTranslationAdjustmentMember_e0575966-3b51-42c3-90fe-7a0f664ae791" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentMember_eec6f661-54c8-4435-9645-b7e4dd2b90a1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentMember_eec6f661-54c8-4435-9645-b7e4dd2b90a1" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_d4d02ce7-9ea1-4818-a6d1-41e5d2723c97" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EquityComponentDomain_c241d9d1-2bd7-42cc-9880-fb406314fe3c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeMember_d4d02ce7-9ea1-4818-a6d1-41e5d2723c97" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_54bbdd8c-6b2f-4ba6-a297-442e975496e5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_54bbdd8c-6b2f-4ba6-a297-442e975496e5" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_af706b52-6f22-46db-aa46-c302f720029f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_54bbdd8c-6b2f-4ba6-a297-442e975496e5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_af706b52-6f22-46db-aa46-c302f720029f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossBeforeTax_d4806062-aabc-49ad-9448-5a0efafeae37" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_54bbdd8c-6b2f-4ba6-a297-442e975496e5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossBeforeTax_d4806062-aabc-49ad-9448-5a0efafeae37" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTax_0a35fb23-b17d-4bdc-b7c9-85198e4b30b8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_54bbdd8c-6b2f-4ba6-a297-442e975496e5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossTax_0a35fb23-b17d-4bdc-b7c9-85198e4b30b8" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_8783710e-bb20-4dae-a793-5aa647b0ec85" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AOCIAttributableToParentNetOfTaxRollForward_54bbdd8c-6b2f-4ba6-a297-442e975496e5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_8783710e-bb20-4dae-a793-5aa647b0ec85" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax_21478eba-764f-4c20-ba6d-2f38640914f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTax"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax_12e53fac-71b2-476f-90fd-ad63f0575f3d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax_12e53fac-71b2-476f-90fd-ad63f0575f3d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodTax_885de31c-19b7-4e1a-8e7e-d0c12225c919" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodTax_885de31c-19b7-4e1a-8e7e-d0c12225c919" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax_cc1a370e-4522-4ef0-b9ca-9d2f88a98b8b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeUnrealizedHoldingGainLossOnSecuritiesArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax_cc1a370e-4522-4ef0-b9ca-9d2f88a98b8b" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTax_8c33c649-5052-447c-878b-8dc218a361ac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTax_8c33c649-5052-447c-878b-8dc218a361ac" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTax_146caa83-ed33-4ad7-aa2a-e4d372619f08" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTax_146caa83-ed33-4ad7-aa2a-e4d372619f08" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTax_05514425-af95-45e6-8c05-18b094ccbfb3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTax_05514425-af95-45e6-8c05-18b094ccbfb3" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_81f6a761-b742-4774-809e-34d5a5294340" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesBeforeTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_81f6a761-b742-4774-809e-34d5a5294340" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_4109ee6d-14c4-44e2-9e97-d7d44860dec1" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_4109ee6d-14c4-44e2-9e97-d7d44860dec1" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_5dbe99b8-e75a-45f6-b8d8-2d6373e89ecf" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIForSaleOfSecuritiesNetOfTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_5dbe99b8-e75a-45f6-b8d8-2d6373e89ecf" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentBeforeTax_49df2123-1735-4234-a784-3733844ee089" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentBeforeTax_49df2123-1735-4234-a784-3733844ee089" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesTax_6772e17f-a7ff-41f7-8ab1-467e4be8c190" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesTax_6772e17f-a7ff-41f7-8ab1-467e4be8c190" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentNetOfTax_5377ad63-39d4-464e-a34f-56c7bfefc564" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_DebtSecuritiesUnrealizedGainLossAbstract_ca3fa22b-ebca-4b47-b77a-ea7a332c6525" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossAvailableForSaleSecuritiesAdjustmentNetOfTax_5377ad63-39d4-464e-a34f-56c7bfefc564" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAndTax_e0225c6f-dbaa-4845-86ff-06e9cd5fc5b2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAndTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAndTax_e0225c6f-dbaa-4845-86ff-06e9cd5fc5b2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationTax_3822814c-5fdf-46cb-abfa-1fa6bc6762a3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationTax_3822814c-5fdf-46cb-abfa-1fa6bc6762a3" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAfterTax_9c66bc91-1560-49f2-b949-99894babc1f0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAfterTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossBeforeReclassificationAfterTax_9c66bc91-1560-49f2-b949-99894babc1f0" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTax_32d126b1-1ffe-428d-b159-1ee11eb30f2b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTax_32d126b1-1ffe-428d-b159-1ee11eb30f2b" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTax_5979adb2-3030-4d76-aa09-ff64082aaed1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTax_5979adb2-3030-4d76-aa09-ff64082aaed1" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTax_d9be4348-960e-4bc3-b2b5-739187870663" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTax_d9be4348-960e-4bc3-b2b5-739187870663" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_0d723db0-912d-4b13-a5c9-da388b1328f5" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationBeforeTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_0d723db0-912d-4b13-a5c9-da388b1328f5" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_065368f9-4706-470c-b20f-4784cb182623" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_065368f9-4706-470c-b20f-4784cb182623" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_a23eb213-01ff-40e4-8188-d82e6b2d7894" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossReclassificationAfterTaxDispositionOfSubsidiaries_a23eb213-01ff-40e4-8188-d82e6b2d7894" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationBeforeTax_2510435d-4672-42b9-96bd-15a24240f6a2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationBeforeTax_2510435d-4672-42b9-96bd-15a24240f6a2" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationTax_53ea3094-7c26-4088-8c79-b7765e59ed4b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationTax_53ea3094-7c26-4088-8c79-b7765e59ed4b" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationAndTax_5b2866f5-c48e-45cc-9e21-2dead9658b20" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationAndTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReclassificationOfCashFlowHedgeGainLossAbstract_80c26d99-a2d2-4754-aee3-57c5a585bf70" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossCashFlowHedgeGainLossAfterReclassificationAndTax_5b2866f5-c48e-45cc-9e21-2dead9658b20" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentBeforeTax_4474385d-6ed2-453b-ac08-e1fc01659aee" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentBeforeTax_4474385d-6ed2-453b-ac08-e1fc01659aee" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTranslationAdjustmentTax_2b941fb1-dafc-4050-85c7-90ffbd3574dc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTranslationAdjustmentTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTranslationAdjustmentTax_2b941fb1-dafc-4050-85c7-90ffbd3574dc" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentNetOfTax_704a11e9-f8d4-4b8d-9b62-d9f0e4ccfca2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossForeignCurrencyTransactionAndTranslationAdjustmentNetOfTax_704a11e9-f8d4-4b8d-9b62-d9f0e4ccfca2" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AccumulatedOtherComprehensiveIncomeLossLineItems_5e13d6fd-e1b4-44b0-84f5-220785c00147" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax_c59da720-1de7-4bb6-80ef-026fa01e5d6e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodBeforeTax_c59da720-1de7-4bb6-80ef-026fa01e5d6e" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodTax_17706dd5-af4f-4398-a217-daeb2cf81a1d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodTax_17706dd5-af4f-4398-a217-daeb2cf81a1d" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax_53417321-2126-46aa-b03b-54861bb37c09" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansNetUnamortizedGainLossArisingDuringPeriodNetOfTax_53417321-2126-46aa-b03b-54861bb37c09" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIBeforeTax_915b82f1-4b66-4029-a0d4-503ff7202d08" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIBeforeTax_915b82f1-4b66-4029-a0d4-503ff7202d08" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCITax_269a7d45-9466-4930-a6c7-628ab3c60a1b" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCITax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCITax_269a7d45-9466-4930-a6c7-628ab3c60a1b" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIAfterTax_e2d35f11-5d04-4c3c-b63a-e36f0ceabac4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIAfterTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossDefinedBenefitPlanPensionSettlementReclassificationAdjustmentFromAOCIAfterTax_e2d35f11-5d04-4c3c-b63a-e36f0ceabac4" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTax_86d318ce-9890-4f83-933e-68d9e041940c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTax_86d318ce-9890-4f83-933e-68d9e041940c" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansTax_b09ca795-761d-4033-8a6a-03189f84b58d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansTax_b09ca795-761d-4033-8a6a-03189f84b58d" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentNetOfTax_c0abe360-b6e9-4534-b570-1c27682c7ca1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeDefinedBenefitPlansAdjustmentBeforeTaxPortionAttributableToParentAbstract_750aa9c7-c56e-479e-b5a8-4c596e00b646" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossPensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitPlansAdjustmentNetOfTax_c0abe360-b6e9-4534-b570-1c27682c7ca1" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/IncomeTaxesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#IncomeTaxesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/IncomeTaxesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationTable_7e54da65-564f-430d-8688-6fef41067310" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationTable_7e54da65-564f-430d-8688-6fef41067310" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_431636e3-8fca-4c0f-8ad2-cb2048bd43a8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationTable_7e54da65-564f-430d-8688-6fef41067310" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_431636e3-8fca-4c0f-8ad2-cb2048bd43a8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_431636e3-8fca-4c0f-8ad2-cb2048bd43a8_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_431636e3-8fca-4c0f-8ad2-cb2048bd43a8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_431636e3-8fca-4c0f-8ad2-cb2048bd43a8_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_43af63b5-85ed-473e-9448-bc4b0bc70e94" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_431636e3-8fca-4c0f-8ad2-cb2048bd43a8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_43af63b5-85ed-473e-9448-bc4b0bc70e94" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_country_GB_2bc83d5b-cb12-4393-b52e-4feb49e47fd3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/country/2023/country-2023.xsd#country_GB"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_43af63b5-85ed-473e-9448-bc4b0bc70e94" xlink:to="loc_country_GB_2bc83d5b-cb12-4393-b52e-4feb49e47fd3" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeAxis_0d7c4308-3371-40b9-a0d3-104e1739d15f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationTable_7e54da65-564f-430d-8688-6fef41067310" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeAxis_0d7c4308-3371-40b9-a0d3-104e1739d15f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_0d7c4308-3371-40b9-a0d3-104e1739d15f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_0d7c4308-3371-40b9-a0d3-104e1739d15f" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_0d7c4308-3371-40b9-a0d3-104e1739d15f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_a7ffee68-d579-4c9b-a993-f50b80ff53b4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_0d7c4308-3371-40b9-a0d3-104e1739d15f" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_a7ffee68-d579-4c9b-a993-f50b80ff53b4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MaximumMember_35111cf1-cf98-4f30-a592-c4bf62b84749" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MaximumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_a7ffee68-d579-4c9b-a993-f50b80ff53b4" xlink:to="loc_srt_MaximumMember_35111cf1-cf98-4f30-a592-c4bf62b84749" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_79d02b3e-2b55-4e1a-b02a-6212c5c52433" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationTable_7e54da65-564f-430d-8688-6fef41067310" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_79d02b3e-2b55-4e1a-b02a-6212c5c52433" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_79d02b3e-2b55-4e1a-b02a-6212c5c52433_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_79d02b3e-2b55-4e1a-b02a-6212c5c52433" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_79d02b3e-2b55-4e1a-b02a-6212c5c52433_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e0b024cb-47ed-4fbb-a25b-ca48fdc060da" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_79d02b3e-2b55-4e1a-b02a-6212c5c52433" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e0b024cb-47ed-4fbb-a25b-ca48fdc060da" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_2ff0a3fe-0359-4b4c-a78c-a7a525117ed3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_e0b024cb-47ed-4fbb-a25b-ca48fdc060da" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_2ff0a3fe-0359-4b4c-a78c-a7a525117ed3" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EffectiveIncomeTaxRateReconciliationAtFederalStatutoryIncomeTaxRate_96a9fd63-3f0a-4b4e-83d9-363ec70ee0bd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EffectiveIncomeTaxRateReconciliationAtFederalStatutoryIncomeTaxRate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EffectiveIncomeTaxRateReconciliationAtFederalStatutoryIncomeTaxRate_96a9fd63-3f0a-4b4e-83d9-363ec70ee0bd" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromContinuingOperationsBeforeIncomeTaxesForeign_64aabf7b-115d-4334-881a-ca1b99fca374" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromContinuingOperationsBeforeIncomeTaxesForeign"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromContinuingOperationsBeforeIncomeTaxesForeign_64aabf7b-115d-4334-881a-ca1b99fca374" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLossCarryforwards_5b40cd87-151b-45a4-8053-e5f6d91142fd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLossCarryforwards"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLossCarryforwards_5b40cd87-151b-45a4-8053-e5f6d91142fd" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsThatWouldImpactEffectiveTaxRate_674fca5f-cbce-4357-8142-b35fe4f88477" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsThatWouldImpactEffectiveTaxRate"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsThatWouldImpactEffectiveTaxRate_674fca5f-cbce-4357-8142-b35fe4f88477" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsInterestOnIncomeTaxesExpense_5e7d5f1b-deb8-481f-9fe4-ab9a6eec68e7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsInterestOnIncomeTaxesExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsInterestOnIncomeTaxesExpense_5e7d5f1b-deb8-481f-9fe4-ab9a6eec68e7" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsInterestOnIncomeTaxesAccrued_0bdaa310-8354-4000-ad95-c4745f3e2cc9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsInterestOnIncomeTaxesAccrued"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsInterestOnIncomeTaxesAccrued_0bdaa310-8354-4000-ad95-c4745f3e2cc9" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsIncomeTaxPenaltiesExpense_b0101081-9b5e-4b86-9b24-eaa0a87339bb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsIncomeTaxPenaltiesExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsIncomeTaxPenaltiesExpense_b0101081-9b5e-4b86-9b24-eaa0a87339bb" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsIncomeTaxPenaltiesAccrued_75de777d-3251-4b4f-a6a7-fe0d84263990" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsIncomeTaxPenaltiesAccrued"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_UnrecognizedTaxBenefitsIncomeTaxPenaltiesAccrued_75de777d-3251-4b4f-a6a7-fe0d84263990" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxesPaidNet_df007f35-2675-4d8f-8575-c58455de52f1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxesPaidNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_IncomeTaxReconciliationLineItems_ced98d48-cfa4-4f1d-9b88-e593a376c5f4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxesPaidNet_df007f35-2675-4d8f-8575-c58455de52f1" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/IncomeTaxesOperatingandcapitallosscarryforwardsavailableDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#IncomeTaxesOperatingandcapitallosscarryforwardsavailableDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/IncomeTaxesOperatingandcapitallosscarryforwardsavailableDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardLineItems_85e19fc6-bf09-459a-916d-8d2f505f0cc4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardTable_4a6d0da9-4dfd-4a34-9a4a-7b9258ae1d98" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardLineItems_85e19fc6-bf09-459a-916d-8d2f505f0cc4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardTable_4a6d0da9-4dfd-4a34-9a4a-7b9258ae1d98" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_bfdf8cb0-8505-4a12-b192-704cf780af33" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardTable_4a6d0da9-4dfd-4a34-9a4a-7b9258ae1d98" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_bfdf8cb0-8505-4a12-b192-704cf780af33" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_bfdf8cb0-8505-4a12-b192-704cf780af33_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_bfdf8cb0-8505-4a12-b192-704cf780af33" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_bfdf8cb0-8505-4a12-b192-704cf780af33_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_06ba9366-36b1-4c49-9385-ee4038620792" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityAxis_bfdf8cb0-8505-4a12-b192-704cf780af33" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_06ba9366-36b1-4c49-9385-ee4038620792" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_country_US_4c4a3470-abd8-4026-bc52-35223130bb40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/country/2023/country-2023.xsd#country_US"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_06ba9366-36b1-4c49-9385-ee4038620792" xlink:to="loc_country_US_4c4a3470-abd8-4026-bc52-35223130bb40" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_country_GB_934c14c5-41c0-40a1-9e39-906daa4f4d40" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/country/2023/country-2023.xsd#country_GB"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxAuthorityDomain_06ba9366-36b1-4c49-9385-ee4038620792" xlink:to="loc_country_GB_934c14c5-41c0-40a1-9e39-906daa4f4d40" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesAxis_e7241624-dd0b-47f7-af97-0cd631675f02" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardTable_4a6d0da9-4dfd-4a34-9a4a-7b9258ae1d98" xlink:to="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesAxis_e7241624-dd0b-47f7-af97-0cd631675f02" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain_e7241624-dd0b-47f7-af97-0cd631675f02_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesAxis_e7241624-dd0b-47f7-af97-0cd631675f02" xlink:to="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain_e7241624-dd0b-47f7-af97-0cd631675f02_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain_98926130-942f-47c9-9a77-4f675461200c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesAxis_e7241624-dd0b-47f7-af97-0cd631675f02" xlink:to="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain_98926130-942f-47c9-9a77-4f675461200c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ExpirationDateOneMember_c7922456-31f9-4343-9b85-4a15400575d9" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ExpirationDateOneMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_OperatingLossCarryForwardExpirationDatesDomain_98926130-942f-47c9-9a77-4f675461200c" xlink:to="loc_afg_ExpirationDateOneMember_c7922456-31f9-4343-9b85-4a15400575d9" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLossCarryforwards_2b61f17c-3bc7-40d6-bd55-333c84d53602" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingLossCarryforwards"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_TaxCreditCarryforwardLineItems_85e19fc6-bf09-459a-916d-8d2f505f0cc4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingLossCarryforwards_2b61f17c-3bc7-40d6-bd55-333c84d53602" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/ContingenciesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#ContingenciesNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/ContingenciesNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesTable_81e3b76c-c4fc-4a4d-a444-3580be882439" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LossContingenciesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesTable_81e3b76c-c4fc-4a4d-a444-3580be882439" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_748fcd45-0257-4989-9621-6e210397fe72" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesTable_81e3b76c-c4fc-4a4d-a444-3580be882439" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_748fcd45-0257-4989-9621-6e210397fe72" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_748fcd45-0257-4989-9621-6e210397fe72_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_748fcd45-0257-4989-9621-6e210397fe72" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_748fcd45-0257-4989-9621-6e210397fe72_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_0e4dae47-8e63-4a44-80a5-a4fc672ade6d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_748fcd45-0257-4989-9621-6e210397fe72" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_0e4dae47-8e63-4a44-80a5-a4fc672ade6d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialAsbestosAndEnvironmentalReservesMember_926b6e39-5a0c-45ab-bcaf-95a1edf721fb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialAsbestosAndEnvironmentalReservesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_0e4dae47-8e63-4a44-80a5-a4fc672ade6d" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialAsbestosAndEnvironmentalReservesMember_926b6e39-5a0c-45ab-bcaf-95a1edf721fb" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesByNatureOfContingencyAxis_f7c1c667-e1ec-4d1f-a04e-370a249c0df1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LossContingenciesByNatureOfContingencyAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesTable_81e3b76c-c4fc-4a4d-a444-3580be882439" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesByNatureOfContingencyAxis_f7c1c667-e1ec-4d1f-a04e-370a249c0df1" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_f7c1c667-e1ec-4d1f-a04e-370a249c0df1_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesByNatureOfContingencyAxis_f7c1c667-e1ec-4d1f-a04e-370a249c0df1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_f7c1c667-e1ec-4d1f-a04e-370a249c0df1_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_9ebb7e45-9c1c-49fd-ac1d-a89e82c383dd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesByNatureOfContingencyAxis_f7c1c667-e1ec-4d1f-a04e-370a249c0df1" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_9ebb7e45-9c1c-49fd-ac1d-a89e82c383dd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyGroupMember_4f1af1f1-6cdc-4793-873c-ede010ca3d46" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyGroupMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_9ebb7e45-9c1c-49fd-ac1d-a89e82c383dd" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyGroupMember_4f1af1f1-6cdc-4793-873c-ede010ca3d46" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_AmericanPremierAndItsSubsidiariesMember_6e1626d4-9c8a-4b1c-80e7-7ebd10198125" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_AmericanPremierAndItsSubsidiariesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_9ebb7e45-9c1c-49fd-ac1d-a89e82c383dd" xlink:to="loc_afg_AmericanPremierAndItsSubsidiariesMember_6e1626d4-9c8a-4b1c-80e7-7ebd10198125" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_GafriMember_e7695e7f-4fbd-4062-a981-3925ed1fe393" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_GafriMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingencyNatureDomain_9ebb7e45-9c1c-49fd-ac1d-a89e82c383dd" xlink:to="loc_afg_GafriMember_e7695e7f-4fbd-4062-a981-3925ed1fe393" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EnvironmentalLossContingencyStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_5850f848-d772-452c-aec2-8f70df8fea2e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EnvironmentalLossContingencyStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EnvironmentalLossContingencyStatementOfFinancialPositionExtensibleEnumeration_5850f848-d772-452c-aec2-8f70df8fea2e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease_9a1c9771-0eb1-46ce-aad8-a98ca2597dce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsNetPeriodIncreaseDecrease_9a1c9771-0eb1-46ce-aad8-a98ca2597dce" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsGross_9bc80540-e414-46cd-a6b2-495b1e291faa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForAsbestosAndEnvironmentalClaimsGross_9bc80540-e414-46cd-a6b2-495b1e291faa" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_d60c97cc-46f8-4216-aaa0-9fa5518af1ce" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_d60c97cc-46f8-4216-aaa0-9fa5518af1ce" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AccrualForEnvironmentalLossContingencies_5b40c1ec-7175-4a33-8354-e2aaa04b1c5f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AccrualForEnvironmentalLossContingencies"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LossContingenciesLineItems_7758453a-d22e-4d3e-896d-7366f7dbdfdd" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AccrualForEnvironmentalLossContingencies_5b40c1ec-7175-4a33-8354-e2aaa04b1c5f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceNarrativeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceNarrativeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_01518137-f360-4dd9-bf9c-84e6b95741f8" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_01518137-f360-4dd9-bf9c-84e6b95741f8" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_90d9fbf9-fa20-4289-953c-32278375be69" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_01518137-f360-4dd9-bf9c-84e6b95741f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_90d9fbf9-fa20-4289-953c-32278375be69" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_90d9fbf9-fa20-4289-953c-32278375be69_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_90d9fbf9-fa20-4289-953c-32278375be69" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_90d9fbf9-fa20-4289-953c-32278375be69_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_f3737b18-82b6-475d-acf4-f48389cc56ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_90d9fbf9-fa20-4289-953c-32278375be69" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_f3737b18-82b6-475d-acf4-f48389cc56ef" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_16b70076-ca8b-4c6e-9370-82f1bee78ff6" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_f3737b18-82b6-475d-acf4-f48389cc56ef" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_16b70076-ca8b-4c6e-9370-82f1bee78ff6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_3e83f337-e540-4b55-a3a2-598b53e2f004" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductOrServiceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_01518137-f360-4dd9-bf9c-84e6b95741f8" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_3e83f337-e540-4b55-a3a2-598b53e2f004" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_3e83f337-e540-4b55-a3a2-598b53e2f004_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_3e83f337-e540-4b55-a3a2-598b53e2f004" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_3e83f337-e540-4b55-a3a2-598b53e2f004_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_02253c85-9df8-4a1f-be2f-16189c5a9ae5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_3e83f337-e540-4b55-a3a2-598b53e2f004" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_02253c85-9df8-4a1f-be2f-16189c5a9ae5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CatastropheBondsMember_17d628a9-517b-44f6-9a1b-91de1b52d163" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CatastropheBondsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_02253c85-9df8-4a1f-be2f-16189c5a9ae5" xlink:to="loc_afg_CatastropheBondsMember_17d628a9-517b-44f6-9a1b-91de1b52d163" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherProvisionsForClaimsOfPriorYearsMember_9a12cc27-5f8e-4617-9225-b2560510fc2a" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherProvisionsForClaimsOfPriorYearsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_02253c85-9df8-4a1f-be2f-16189c5a9ae5" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherProvisionsForClaimsOfPriorYearsMember_9a12cc27-5f8e-4617-9225-b2560510fc2a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember_6f7b4e0e-aeeb-4373-a170-01fe5a563617" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_02253c85-9df8-4a1f-be2f-16189c5a9ae5" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_WorkersCompensationInsuranceMember_6f7b4e0e-aeeb-4373-a170-01fe5a563617" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_26943562-b428-42ac-b309-bd878f05f170" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_01518137-f360-4dd9-bf9c-84e6b95741f8" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_26943562-b428-42ac-b309-bd878f05f170" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_26943562-b428-42ac-b309-bd878f05f170_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_26943562-b428-42ac-b309-bd878f05f170" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_26943562-b428-42ac-b309-bd878f05f170_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_51b46773-28a4-4656-99cf-cf4bef93331d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_26943562-b428-42ac-b309-bd878f05f170" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_51b46773-28a4-4656-99cf-cf4bef93331d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CatastropheBondsMember_eed5ed26-a6a1-48cd-9c08-7fa18caf7cd4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CatastropheBondsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_51b46773-28a4-4656-99cf-cf4bef93331d" xlink:to="loc_afg_CatastropheBondsMember_eed5ed26-a6a1-48cd-9c08-7fa18caf7cd4" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeAxis_9037d54c-5bb9-477a-aedf-6374c8e72b2e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_01518137-f360-4dd9-bf9c-84e6b95741f8" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeAxis_9037d54c-5bb9-477a-aedf-6374c8e72b2e" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_9037d54c-5bb9-477a-aedf-6374c8e72b2e_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_9037d54c-5bb9-477a-aedf-6374c8e72b2e" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_9037d54c-5bb9-477a-aedf-6374c8e72b2e_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_RangeMember_88dbccc9-1699-4bab-a0aa-a92d9f950bee" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_RangeMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeAxis_9037d54c-5bb9-477a-aedf-6374c8e72b2e" xlink:to="loc_srt_RangeMember_88dbccc9-1699-4bab-a0aa-a92d9f950bee" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_MaximumMember_9eeb292c-f046-4380-ab16-6d02490b1ede" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_MaximumMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_RangeMember_88dbccc9-1699-4bab-a0aa-a92d9f950bee" xlink:to="loc_srt_MaximumMember_9eeb292c-f046-4380-ab16-6d02490b1ede" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsHeldByInsuranceRegulators_5a366206-090d-4e78-b265-3efa75a43440" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsHeldByInsuranceRegulators"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsHeldByInsuranceRegulators_5a366206-090d-4e78-b265-3efa75a43440" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_WorkersCompensationDiscountPercent_7a0aba23-a671-4961-b335-d733178ea660" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_WorkersCompensationDiscountPercent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_WorkersCompensationDiscountPercent_7a0aba23-a671-4961-b335-d733178ea660" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationContractsDiscountedLiabilitiesAmount_db560e40-2b9f-42b2-93a6-ec4fc32460c9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationContractsDiscountedLiabilitiesAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationContractsDiscountedLiabilitiesAmount_db560e40-2b9f-42b2-93a6-ec4fc32460c9" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_WorkersCompensationDiscountPriorYearAmount_330006a1-be34-4380-b5d9-d97ef7835fe1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_WorkersCompensationDiscountPriorYearAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_WorkersCompensationDiscountPriorYearAmount_330006a1-be34-4380-b5d9-d97ef7835fe1" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DeferredPolicyAcquisitionCostAmortizationExpense_0746489d-a95c-4e7a-8f4e-7c73ec7fccc0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DeferredPolicyAcquisitionCostAmortizationExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DeferredPolicyAcquisitionCostAmortizationExpense_0746489d-a95c-4e7a-8f4e-7c73ec7fccc0" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryAmountAvailableForDividendPaymentsWithoutRegulatoryApproval_9d10a1cd-6e98-4781-a829-ed13f214e7f6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryAmountAvailableForDividendPaymentsWithoutRegulatoryApproval"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryAmountAvailableForDividendPaymentsWithoutRegulatoryApproval_9d10a1cd-6e98-4781-a829-ed13f214e7f6" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DividendsCommonStockCash_44f38d87-00d9-4081-b635-6c2300a4840f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DividendsCommonStockCash"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DividendsCommonStockCash_44f38d87-00d9-4081-b635-6c2300a4840f" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_DividendPaymentsWithoutViolatingMostRestrictiveDebtCovenants_ee27b039-02b5-4f9b-9fb2-ace0811aeadc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_DividendPaymentsWithoutViolatingMostRestrictiveDebtCovenants"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_afg_DividendPaymentsWithoutViolatingMostRestrictiveDebtCovenants_ee27b039-02b5-4f9b-9fb2-ace0811aeadc" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionPolicyExcessRetentionPercentage_82ee5c5f-9a06-4dd7-9b6e-f22a83a9c3fe" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionPolicyExcessRetentionPercentage"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionPolicyExcessRetentionPercentage_82ee5c5f-9a06-4dd7-9b6e-f22a83a9c3fe" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionExcessRetentionAmountReinsuredPerEvent_9695a518-2de6-4203-92af-4b149cde1e30" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionExcessRetentionAmountReinsuredPerEvent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionExcessRetentionAmountReinsuredPerEvent_9695a518-2de6-4203-92af-4b149cde1e30" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionAmountRetainedPerEvent_ebe1c246-c571-490e-b0da-735f107870c0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionAmountRetainedPerEvent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionAmountRetainedPerEvent_ebe1c246-c571-490e-b0da-735f107870c0" xlink:type="arc" order="10"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ReinsuranceCoverageAnnualCostForCatastropheBondStructure_cbbac560-28d9-4b4a-9152-797210b0786c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ReinsuranceCoverageAnnualCostForCatastropheBondStructure"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_3d154ffc-2d4e-4084-bad1-ebb0159451ac" xlink:to="loc_afg_ReinsuranceCoverageAnnualCostForCatastropheBondStructure_cbbac560-28d9-4b4a-9152-797210b0786c" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceAnalysisofchangesintheliabilityforlossesandlossadjustmentexpensesnetofreinsuranceDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceAnalysisofchangesintheliabilityforlossesandlossadjustmentexpensesnetofreinsuranceDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceAnalysisofchangesintheliabilityforlossesandlossadjustmentexpensesnetofreinsuranceDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseLineItems_d2c3339e-4255-4948-83d2-437ee7006135" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseTable_a9f32f50-9ece-496c-a7e9-588fc2116068" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseLineItems_d2c3339e-4255-4948-83d2-437ee7006135" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseTable_a9f32f50-9ece-496c-a7e9-588fc2116068" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_34042651-45c4-4b96-8a85-81b2bad05928" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductOrServiceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseTable_a9f32f50-9ece-496c-a7e9-588fc2116068" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_34042651-45c4-4b96-8a85-81b2bad05928" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_34042651-45c4-4b96-8a85-81b2bad05928_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_34042651-45c4-4b96-8a85-81b2bad05928" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_34042651-45c4-4b96-8a85-81b2bad05928_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_07e74ccd-e009-4b84-89ad-c3e161d0a3cd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_34042651-45c4-4b96-8a85-81b2bad05928" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_07e74ccd-e009-4b84-89ad-c3e161d0a3cd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherProvisionsForClaimsOfPriorYearsMember_62e4165e-84a6-43c7-b82e-09e299f72b50" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherProvisionsForClaimsOfPriorYearsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_07e74ccd-e009-4b84-89ad-c3e161d0a3cd" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherProvisionsForClaimsOfPriorYearsMember_62e4165e-84a6-43c7-b82e-09e299f72b50" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseLineItems_d2c3339e-4255-4948-83d2-437ee7006135" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability_dd2e45bc-ab24-4d22-860a-5e9831bef94f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability_dd2e45bc-ab24-4d22-860a-5e9831bef94f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_0babfc5b-4310-491c-a174-c1dfacf33f13" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_0babfc5b-4310-491c-a174-c1dfacf33f13" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet_114d21b2-9fcf-4872-99aa-219e0c86804a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet_114d21b2-9fcf-4872-99aa-219e0c86804a" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementalInformationForPropertyCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritersCurrentYearClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense_4c7ace1b-db8f-4bfc-8cca-17bfa7f6f07e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementalInformationForPropertyCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritersCurrentYearClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementalInformationForPropertyCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritersCurrentYearClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense_4c7ace1b-db8f-4bfc-8cca-17bfa7f6f07e" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaimsAbstract_db815cc4-71a0-42d6-97c4-b0e36fdbd002" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaimsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaimsAbstract_db815cc4-71a0-42d6-97c4-b0e36fdbd002" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementalInformationForPropertyCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritersPriorYearClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense_3b3dcf4e-f019-4a91-8f4b-4e4eb36c50cb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementalInformationForPropertyCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritersPriorYearClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaimsAbstract_db815cc4-71a0-42d6-97c4-b0e36fdbd002" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementalInformationForPropertyCasualtyInsuranceUnderwritersPriorYearClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpense_3b3dcf4e-f019-4a91-8f4b-4e4eb36c50cb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaims1_41a48a1c-3a70-48ad-8ff5-804f84715c04" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaims1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaimsAbstract_db815cc4-71a0-42d6-97c4-b0e36fdbd002" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseIncurredClaims1_41a48a1c-3a70-48ad-8ff5-804f84715c04" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidAbstract_c814852a-eabb-43c3-b2b6-1edd6be347aa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidAbstract_c814852a-eabb-43c3-b2b6-1edd6be347aa" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidCurrentYear1_9d8f7f40-8f01-448c-9bf9-4fdf18986da4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidCurrentYear1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidAbstract_c814852a-eabb-43c3-b2b6-1edd6be347aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidCurrentYear1_9d8f7f40-8f01-448c-9bf9-4fdf18986da4" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidPriorYears1_f9faec66-f432-4785-b724-ae8bc8cf1b80" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidPriorYears1"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidAbstract_c814852a-eabb-43c3-b2b6-1edd6be347aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidPriorYears1_f9faec66-f432-4785-b724-ae8bc8cf1b80" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsForLossesAndLossAdjustmentExpense_ce2005af-bd88-430b-bcd1-6238aad76362" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsForLossesAndLossAdjustmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseClaimsPaidAbstract_c814852a-eabb-43c3-b2b6-1edd6be347aa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsForLossesAndLossAdjustmentExpense_ce2005af-bd88-430b-bcd1-6238aad76362" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseForeignCurrencyTranslationGainLoss_1df0de20-626d-4bb0-a5ba-7eac3cbc3e5c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseForeignCurrencyTranslationGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNetAbstract_142592ea-a0f7-44d3-a50d-e2f2050c5ea6" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseForeignCurrencyTranslationGainLoss_1df0de20-626d-4bb0-a5ba-7eac3cbc3e5c" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet_21b676c1-d2d3-4544-b318-bfd2bbb0d2b7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_b2f3fd96-9a47-4cff-85ee-4b940a358bb3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability_ec2f63ec-f87b-4c28-8a43-19503691ea67" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceReconciliationofincurredandpaidclaimsdevelopmentinformationtotheaggregatecarryingamountoftheliabilityforunpaidlossesandLAEDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceReconciliationofincurredandpaidclaimsdevelopmentinformationtotheaggregatecarryingamountoftheliabilityforunpaidlossesandLAEDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceReconciliationofincurredandpaidclaimsdevelopmentinformationtotheaggregatecarryingamountoftheliabilityforunpaidlossesandLAEDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityTable_2a56704d-4e6a-47b4-9d22-e9b0630fb683" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityTable_2a56704d-4e6a-47b4-9d22-e9b0630fb683" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_af8e88ab-bf2e-4da6-97e9-102ed2120496" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityTable_2a56704d-4e6a-47b4-9d22-e9b0630fb683" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_af8e88ab-bf2e-4da6-97e9-102ed2120496" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_af8e88ab-bf2e-4da6-97e9-102ed2120496_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_af8e88ab-bf2e-4da6-97e9-102ed2120496" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_af8e88ab-bf2e-4da6-97e9-102ed2120496_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_bf8af4ec-baca-4335-805b-3850b915f527" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_af8e88ab-bf2e-4da6-97e9-102ed2120496" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_bf8af4ec-baca-4335-805b-3850b915f527" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_13e5b25e-46b6-495e-8d4a-174e0d2bfe16" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_bf8af4ec-baca-4335-805b-3850b915f527" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_13e5b25e-46b6-495e-8d4a-174e0d2bfe16" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_8c67b1fc-ec78-4b2b-af02-5582897d27fb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityTable_2a56704d-4e6a-47b4-9d22-e9b0630fb683" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_8c67b1fc-ec78-4b2b-af02-5582897d27fb" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_8c67b1fc-ec78-4b2b-af02-5582897d27fb_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_8c67b1fc-ec78-4b2b-af02-5582897d27fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_8c67b1fc-ec78-4b2b-af02-5582897d27fb_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_08d0e609-f5c9-470d-9654-96ca8cc0acd9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_8c67b1fc-ec78-4b2b-af02-5582897d27fb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_08d0e609-f5c9-470d-9654-96ca8cc0acd9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_9c5071ab-9c0a-45cf-92f5-b653854fd1e0" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_08d0e609-f5c9-470d-9654-96ca8cc0acd9" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_9c5071ab-9c0a-45cf-92f5-b653854fd1e0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_5823c104-f91a-4066-bd1f-7e0caaa81bcb" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_08d0e609-f5c9-470d-9654-96ca8cc0acd9" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_5823c104-f91a-4066-bd1f-7e0caaa81bcb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_e10aea3e-d6a3-4e0f-accf-bfc529b64bec" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_08d0e609-f5c9-470d-9654-96ca8cc0acd9" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_e10aea3e-d6a3-4e0f-accf-bfc529b64bec" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_fb6e91f4-7292-4aa1-a39e-0d04bf31b2b4" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_08d0e609-f5c9-470d-9654-96ca8cc0acd9" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_fb6e91f4-7292-4aa1-a39e-0d04bf31b2b4" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_f92c0e02-f431-40b4-b938-72f8ccc55240" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityTable_2a56704d-4e6a-47b4-9d22-e9b0630fb683" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_f92c0e02-f431-40b4-b938-72f8ccc55240" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_f92c0e02-f431-40b4-b938-72f8ccc55240_default" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_f92c0e02-f431-40b4-b938-72f8ccc55240" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_f92c0e02-f431-40b4-b938-72f8ccc55240_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_adf03204-15d6-4dfc-8ad5-92743cf367ea" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceAxis_f92c0e02-f431-40b4-b938-72f8ccc55240" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_adf03204-15d6-4dfc-8ad5-92743cf367ea" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ReservesForForeignOperationsMember_4c0c1484-19de-4de5-9110-5ef6e6a66c05" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ReservesForForeignOperationsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_adf03204-15d6-4dfc-8ad5-92743cf367ea" xlink:to="loc_afg_ReservesForForeignOperationsMember_4c0c1484-19de-4de5-9110-5ef6e6a66c05" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialAsbestosAndEnvironmentalReservesMember_1b5ec75c-28e2-448f-95fd-f8fb97244442" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialAsbestosAndEnvironmentalReservesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_adf03204-15d6-4dfc-8ad5-92743cf367ea" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialAsbestosAndEnvironmentalReservesMember_1b5ec75c-28e2-448f-95fd-f8fb97244442" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherReservesMember_fc4c9725-100f-401f-bae2-a497bcae3959" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherReservesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceDomain_adf03204-15d6-4dfc-8ad5-92743cf367ea" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherReservesMember_fc4c9725-100f-401f-bae2-a497bcae3959" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_7023e5bc-3b01-4c62-8f7d-5ace2d4c0e2e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_7023e5bc-3b01-4c62-8f7d-5ace2d4c0e2e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimAdjustmentExpenseOtherReconcilingItem_0656ec7f-8a57-4652-921f-4b1988fdd121" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimAdjustmentExpenseOtherReconcilingItem"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimAdjustmentExpenseOtherReconcilingItem_0656ec7f-8a57-4652-921f-4b1988fdd121" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseAccumulatedUnallocatedClaimAdjustmentExpense_71765db0-6c7d-4229-897a-f25dd799f469" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseAccumulatedUnallocatedClaimAdjustmentExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseAccumulatedUnallocatedClaimAdjustmentExpense_71765db0-6c7d-4229-897a-f25dd799f469" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet_5dc8fbde-2f01-4351-b7dd-bab737776b98" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpenseNet_5dc8fbde-2f01-4351-b7dd-bab737776b98" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_19082b5d-6167-4f34-8970-16f100482612" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableForUnpaidClaimsAndClaimsAdjustments_19082b5d-6167-4f34-8970-16f100482612" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability_dd529d31-fdfa-4495-bfbb-41d026f5d057" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsReconciliationOfClaimsDevelopmentToLiabilityLineItems_e459180f-01bb-4e1d-9fa8-ef74f1b65bd4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilityForClaimsAndClaimsAdjustmentExpensePropertyCasualtyLiability_dd529d31-fdfa-4495-bfbb-41d026f5d057" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceShortdurationinsurancecontractsclaimsdevelopmentDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceShortdurationinsurancecontractsclaimsdevelopmentDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceShortdurationinsurancecontractsclaimsdevelopmentDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable_a6444f1a-77dd-4f63-9c04-9ba0ae98b29b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable_a6444f1a-77dd-4f63-9c04-9ba0ae98b29b" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_a0cb3ffd-ec7d-4c59-a29b-7eed8ecd8123" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable_a6444f1a-77dd-4f63-9c04-9ba0ae98b29b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_a0cb3ffd-ec7d-4c59-a29b-7eed8ecd8123" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_a0cb3ffd-ec7d-4c59-a29b-7eed8ecd8123_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_a0cb3ffd-ec7d-4c59-a29b-7eed8ecd8123" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_a0cb3ffd-ec7d-4c59-a29b-7eed8ecd8123_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_b53b6525-377e-4996-966b-262b2644fb6f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_a0cb3ffd-ec7d-4c59-a29b-7eed8ecd8123" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_b53b6525-377e-4996-966b-262b2644fb6f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_b1c71695-a607-4d68-a248-e14d1e0dc083" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_b53b6525-377e-4996-966b-262b2644fb6f" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_b1c71695-a607-4d68-a248-e14d1e0dc083" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_2aab8520-4cd2-4083-bd5e-e8797af3a044" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable_a6444f1a-77dd-4f63-9c04-9ba0ae98b29b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_2aab8520-4cd2-4083-bd5e-e8797af3a044" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_2aab8520-4cd2-4083-bd5e-e8797af3a044_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_2aab8520-4cd2-4083-bd5e-e8797af3a044" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_2aab8520-4cd2-4083-bd5e-e8797af3a044_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_da7d313a-c521-4ae5-a58c-840d4c254036" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_2aab8520-4cd2-4083-bd5e-e8797af3a044" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_da7d313a-c521-4ae5-a58c-840d4c254036" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_3f65fd04-357a-46ab-afce-239b01a3c80d" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_da7d313a-c521-4ae5-a58c-840d4c254036" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_3f65fd04-357a-46ab-afce-239b01a3c80d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_2a87b466-d238-4903-aef4-d5bb4e5f882b" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_da7d313a-c521-4ae5-a58c-840d4c254036" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_2a87b466-d238-4903-aef4-d5bb4e5f882b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_a93c5095-bd23-4d5d-93b1-b05b92cd1306" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_da7d313a-c521-4ae5-a58c-840d4c254036" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_a93c5095-bd23-4d5d-93b1-b05b92cd1306" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_0e9745ca-93e8-4195-ac71-46b7e59288fe" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_da7d313a-c521-4ae5-a58c-840d4c254036" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_0e9745ca-93e8-4195-ac71-46b7e59288fe" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationAxis_6fc1fa56-436c-446f-a066-498038c3b393" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable_a6444f1a-77dd-4f63-9c04-9ba0ae98b29b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationAxis_6fc1fa56-436c-446f-a066-498038c3b393" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain_6fc1fa56-436c-446f-a066-498038c3b393_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationAxis_6fc1fa56-436c-446f-a066-498038c3b393" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain_6fc1fa56-436c-446f-a066-498038c3b393_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain_e5e21912-b31a-4ec3-9384-35c5787d01a3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationAxis_6fc1fa56-436c-446f-a066-498038c3b393" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain_e5e21912-b31a-4ec3-9384-35c5787d01a3" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ExcludesShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityforUnpaidClaimsandAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNotSeparatelyPresentedMember_029ec465-97ad-4be5-9743-dd06be22a67f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ExcludesShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityforUnpaidClaimsandAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNotSeparatelyPresentedMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimDurationDomain_e5e21912-b31a-4ec3-9384-35c5787d01a3" xlink:to="loc_afg_ExcludesShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityforUnpaidClaimsandAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNotSeparatelyPresentedMember_029ec465-97ad-4be5-9743-dd06be22a67f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearAxis_0c9d3d6e-2229-4ba7-a3ec-250843d2d38d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsClaimsDevelopmentTable_a6444f1a-77dd-4f63-9c04-9ba0ae98b29b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearAxis_0c9d3d6e-2229-4ba7-a3ec-250843d2d38d" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_0c9d3d6e-2229-4ba7-a3ec-250843d2d38d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearAxis_0c9d3d6e-2229-4ba7-a3ec-250843d2d38d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_0c9d3d6e-2229-4ba7-a3ec-250843d2d38d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearAxis_0c9d3d6e-2229-4ba7-a3ec-250843d2d38d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2014Member_2100c8f2-29e7-4dbf-a48d-5b2343da8de6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2014Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2014Member_2100c8f2-29e7-4dbf-a48d-5b2343da8de6" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2015Member_28a83bb5-731c-421e-b07b-9a522627c83a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2015Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2015Member_28a83bb5-731c-421e-b07b-9a522627c83a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2016Member_3132e15f-b1d0-4c58-bb91-ba0f92e7c16e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2016Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2016Member_3132e15f-b1d0-4c58-bb91-ba0f92e7c16e" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2017Member_2c309a7b-b6d3-4c07-8c27-b004600cf509" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2017Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2017Member_2c309a7b-b6d3-4c07-8c27-b004600cf509" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2018Member_5b617d09-809f-4b73-a622-b9e41b1815ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2018Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYear2018Member_5b617d09-809f-4b73-a622-b9e41b1815ef" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2019Member_db973eb3-f04e-4c4b-a49a-31ea99a86e2c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2019Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2019Member_db973eb3-f04e-4c4b-a49a-31ea99a86e2c" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2020Member_3b3ec067-5462-4c32-93a4-8339d7b285ac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2020Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2020Member_3b3ec067-5462-4c32-93a4-8339d7b285ac" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2021Member_8af7a3b6-27ae-4cb1-9473-0bc6ccaa9c94" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2021Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2021Member_8af7a3b6-27ae-4cb1-9473-0bc6ccaa9c94" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2022Member_f9a953ff-42af-4c5a-aa3f-bcac6b027b25" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2022Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2022Member_f9a953ff-42af-4c5a-aa3f-bcac6b027b25" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2023Member_1c1d6a9c-f42d-4bf7-8587-81a0529480de" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2023Member"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsAccidentYearDomain_3a04780b-1adc-45ad-943b-3293e51974d9" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortDurationInsuranceContractAccidentYear2023Member_1c1d6a9c-f42d-4bf7-8587-81a0529480de" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsIncurredClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_fa4671d2-c23c-46fb-892d-3ee3fdaebdb2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsIncurredClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsIncurredClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_fa4671d2-c23c-46fb-892d-3ee3fdaebdb2" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsIncurredButNotReportedIbnrClaimsLiabilityNet_d9f93ab2-c4a8-4b48-b607-af653795bde2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsIncurredButNotReportedIbnrClaimsLiabilityNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsIncurredButNotReportedIbnrClaimsLiabilityNet_d9f93ab2-c4a8-4b48-b607-af653795bde2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsNumberOfReportedClaims_67644662-f545-4545-ae3c-c26cbd3385c2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsNumberOfReportedClaims"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsNumberOfReportedClaims_67644662-f545-4545-ae3c-c26cbd3385c2" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsCumulativePaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_95b82002-ccb6-4a29-8251-65c0506f237d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsCumulativePaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsCumulativePaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_95b82002-ccb6-4a29-8251-65c0506f237d" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsCumulativePercentagePaidofIncurredClaimsandAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_0ce438bc-bf0c-47e5-9ab9-8b1ee39d485b" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsCumulativePercentagePaidofIncurredClaimsandAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsCumulativePercentagePaidofIncurredClaimsandAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_0ce438bc-bf0c-47e5-9ab9-8b1ee39d485b" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNetNotSeparatelyPresented_d2502eaa-7095-4d68-829a-ab8dcab3d71d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNetNotSeparatelyPresented"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNetNotSeparatelyPresented_d2502eaa-7095-4d68-829a-ab8dcab3d71d" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_f98afae4-fc67-46f2-9e9c-5a4c2050f825" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ClaimsDevelopmentLineItems_fc4363ba-3919-42eb-b8fd-c65283d33f45" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsLiabilityForUnpaidClaimsAndAllocatedClaimAdjustmentExpenseNet_f98afae4-fc67-46f2-9e9c-5a4c2050f825" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceShortdurationinsurancecontractshistoricalclaimsdurationDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceShortdurationinsurancecontractshistoricalclaimsdurationDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceShortdurationinsurancecontractshistoricalclaimsdurationDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationTable_0eaea640-6d5f-4a67-9585-08139b4edcb4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationTable_0eaea640-6d5f-4a67-9585-08139b4edcb4" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_892f2f95-2ffe-45e2-bec3-83e35e4ad43d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationTable_0eaea640-6d5f-4a67-9585-08139b4edcb4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_892f2f95-2ffe-45e2-bec3-83e35e4ad43d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_892f2f95-2ffe-45e2-bec3-83e35e4ad43d_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_892f2f95-2ffe-45e2-bec3-83e35e4ad43d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_892f2f95-2ffe-45e2-bec3-83e35e4ad43d_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_df1e2a65-eada-458d-907d-a1e76488336c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_892f2f95-2ffe-45e2-bec3-83e35e4ad43d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_df1e2a65-eada-458d-907d-a1e76488336c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_73bb9270-412e-45f7-a24c-0228c32e3190" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_df1e2a65-eada-458d-907d-a1e76488336c" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_73bb9270-412e-45f7-a24c-0228c32e3190" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1409cf6-3252-4974-893a-6a9920fb9b26" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationTable_0eaea640-6d5f-4a67-9585-08139b4edcb4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1409cf6-3252-4974-893a-6a9920fb9b26" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_a1409cf6-3252-4974-893a-6a9920fb9b26_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1409cf6-3252-4974-893a-6a9920fb9b26" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_a1409cf6-3252-4974-893a-6a9920fb9b26_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_d0e4e800-134b-4bd5-a733-7d0e0413e672" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsAxis_a1409cf6-3252-4974-893a-6a9920fb9b26" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_d0e4e800-134b-4bd5-a733-7d0e0413e672" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_8f5ee847-565e-4623-aee0-56384aa4c0ab" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_d0e4e800-134b-4bd5-a733-7d0e0413e672" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyPropertyAndTransportationInsuranceMember_8f5ee847-565e-4623-aee0-56384aa4c0ab" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_c7507ba6-ec63-4fa4-b7b0-79de073d984c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_d0e4e800-134b-4bd5-a733-7d0e0413e672" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyCasualtyInsuranceMember_c7507ba6-ec63-4fa4-b7b0-79de073d984c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_315b2548-4a06-4657-848e-b8cc4013c6ff" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_d0e4e800-134b-4bd5-a733-7d0e0413e672" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyFinancialInsuranceMember_315b2548-4a06-4657-848e-b8cc4013c6ff" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_bf892af4-2aa9-4a6f-badc-78e9fc13b13e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SubsegmentsDomain_d0e4e800-134b-4bd5-a733-7d0e0413e672" xlink:to="loc_afg_SpecialtyOtherInsuranceMember_bf892af4-2aa9-4a6f-badc-78e9fc13b13e" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearOne_4eb1df6c-bc0e-41c6-939b-61335a80f007" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearOne"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearOne_4eb1df6c-bc0e-41c6-939b-61335a80f007" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTwo_177566b5-9db9-43fa-a5de-2eeb75308ce6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTwo"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTwo_177566b5-9db9-43fa-a5de-2eeb75308ce6" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearThree_b9053af9-3cac-455e-9440-22d4602e08a8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearThree"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearThree_b9053af9-3cac-455e-9440-22d4602e08a8" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFour_2e8f79a0-a8e4-4c92-a6c5-632e7ff1440b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFour"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFour_2e8f79a0-a8e4-4c92-a6c5-632e7ff1440b" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFive_4bb0d221-7350-4be9-8e89-8189e2969b21" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFive"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFive_4bb0d221-7350-4be9-8e89-8189e2969b21" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSix_cc116cbd-26ba-46e1-8ee8-f4e7798ff8f0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSix"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSix_cc116cbd-26ba-46e1-8ee8-f4e7798ff8f0" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSeven_f90db162-2ac0-4d99-b057-1fd12b63bf69" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSeven"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSeven_f90db162-2ac0-4d99-b057-1fd12b63bf69" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearEight_21d3fdc6-d113-446c-9a21-b2bb1ca250b8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearEight"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearEight_21d3fdc6-d113-446c-9a21-b2bb1ca250b8" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearNine_1ff392b1-dbca-442f-90e7-2519b364318e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearNine"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearNine_1ff392b1-dbca-442f-90e7-2519b364318e" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTen_0fcf8c28-94b2-40da-8afe-60df991a1d26" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTen"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTen_0fcf8c28-94b2-40da-8afe-60df991a1d26" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearOne_ea2aae29-9fbd-4fc3-a56b-33e25e71de1d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearOne"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTwoCumulative_967f7fa6-cbcb-40c1-b022-b77b1a18d976" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTwoCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTwoCumulative_967f7fa6-cbcb-40c1-b022-b77b1a18d976" xlink:type="arc" order="11"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearThreeCumulative_e5575371-dc41-42ac-8513-02f076f04ab1" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearThreeCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearThreeCumulative_e5575371-dc41-42ac-8513-02f076f04ab1" xlink:type="arc" order="12"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFourCumulative_59913b0b-a157-48c6-b0f8-7bbff45012ea" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFourCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFourCumulative_59913b0b-a157-48c6-b0f8-7bbff45012ea" xlink:type="arc" order="13"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFiveCumulative_7dec4c1d-d327-4984-9a7f-31ba3cef9cfe" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFiveCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearFiveCumulative_7dec4c1d-d327-4984-9a7f-31ba3cef9cfe" xlink:type="arc" order="14"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSixCumulative_d6e3ffb8-e403-4784-b8bf-90880011af97" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSixCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSixCumulative_d6e3ffb8-e403-4784-b8bf-90880011af97" xlink:type="arc" order="15"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSevenCumulative_2f07e8c3-ebd7-4a32-8f0a-1783cc93d201" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSevenCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearSevenCumulative_2f07e8c3-ebd7-4a32-8f0a-1783cc93d201" xlink:type="arc" order="16"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearEightCumulative_2ab263e0-3153-40b2-9334-cb9d369c4982" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearEightCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearEightCumulative_2ab263e0-3153-40b2-9334-cb9d369c4982" xlink:type="arc" order="17"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearNineCumulative_6e92f632-ce4e-46fe-aeea-eebc33bbb268" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearNineCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearNineCumulative_6e92f632-ce4e-46fe-aeea-eebc33bbb268" xlink:type="arc" order="18"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTenCumulative_b9be45fe-14f0-4a3c-8379-00e541298211" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTenCumulative"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationLineItems_731907b5-a08d-4481-a595-97d2e6f9a401" xlink:to="loc_afg_ShortdurationInsuranceContractsHistoricalClaimsDurationYearTenCumulative_b9be45fe-14f0-4a3c-8379-00e541298211" xlink:type="arc" order="19"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceNetearningsandcapitalandsurplusonastatutorybasisfortheinsurancesubsidiariesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceNetearningsandcapitalandsurplusonastatutorybasisfortheinsurancesubsidiariesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceNetearningsandcapitalandsurplusonastatutorybasisfortheinsurancesubsidiariesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesLineItems_ae6f0941-79cb-4c53-bbf4-c332273c65ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesTable_714ec995-9679-42c6-b6de-6665cd90936b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesLineItems_ae6f0941-79cb-4c53-bbf4-c332273c65ff" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesTable_714ec995-9679-42c6-b6de-6665cd90936b" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_dbc275bd-cb6a-47b8-b5f6-984a6ecb8724" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductOrServiceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesTable_714ec995-9679-42c6-b6de-6665cd90936b" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_dbc275bd-cb6a-47b8-b5f6-984a6ecb8724" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_dbc275bd-cb6a-47b8-b5f6-984a6ecb8724_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_dbc275bd-cb6a-47b8-b5f6-984a6ecb8724" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_dbc275bd-cb6a-47b8-b5f6-984a6ecb8724_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_d3efd5ef-734f-41d2-a4d7-24e4348d3c98" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_dbc275bd-cb6a-47b8-b5f6-984a6ecb8724" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_d3efd5ef-734f-41d2-a4d7-24e4348d3c98" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_62282d10-c91f-4d1c-9a2d-f4d026ad371f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_d3efd5ef-734f-41d2-a4d7-24e4348d3c98" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_62282d10-c91f-4d1c-9a2d-f4d026ad371f" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_StatutoryInformationAbstract_c8a9af9e-f2ed-4e58-b9b1-3830fe8ea533" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_StatutoryInformationAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesLineItems_ae6f0941-79cb-4c53-bbf4-c332273c65ff" xlink:to="loc_afg_StatutoryInformationAbstract_c8a9af9e-f2ed-4e58-b9b1-3830fe8ea533" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryNetIncomeAmount_e399b6fa-626a-4af7-be1c-a37fd8195180" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryNetIncomeAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_StatutoryInformationAbstract_c8a9af9e-f2ed-4e58-b9b1-3830fe8ea533" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryNetIncomeAmount_e399b6fa-626a-4af7-be1c-a37fd8195180" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryCapitalAndSurplusBalance_58b73f02-18d5-4236-a0ab-59a0468834d4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryCapitalAndSurplusBalance"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_StatutoryInformationAbstract_c8a9af9e-f2ed-4e58-b9b1-3830fe8ea533" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatutoryAccountingPracticesStatutoryCapitalAndSurplusBalance_58b73f02-18d5-4236-a0ab-59a0468834d4" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceReinsuranceinformationtableincludingassumedcededandrecoveriesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceReinsuranceinformationtableincludingassumedcededandrecoveriesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceReinsuranceinformationtableincludingassumedcededandrecoveriesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceTable_6d65027e-197b-4cb7-8fc1-1a7f62843dc7" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceTable_6d65027e-197b-4cb7-8fc1-1a7f62843dc7" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_e589b1b9-1fc9-4691-9380-834bc0a0a446" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductOrServiceAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceTable_6d65027e-197b-4cb7-8fc1-1a7f62843dc7" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_e589b1b9-1fc9-4691-9380-834bc0a0a446" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_e589b1b9-1fc9-4691-9380-834bc0a0a446_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_e589b1b9-1fc9-4691-9380-834bc0a0a446" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_e589b1b9-1fc9-4691-9380-834bc0a0a446_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_7df7ec2f-3af0-4a68-ad2a-8e39579581fa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductOrServiceAxis_e589b1b9-1fc9-4691-9380-834bc0a0a446" xlink:to="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_7df7ec2f-3af0-4a68-ad2a-8e39579581fa" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_b0234f93-127f-4554-b672-e7639b79e149" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ProductsAndServicesDomain_7df7ec2f-3af0-4a68-ad2a-8e39579581fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PropertyLiabilityAndCasualtyInsuranceSegmentMember_b0234f93-127f-4554-b672-e7639b79e149" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DirectPremiumsWritten_bda6b745-7933-4d21-8a28-1a7fbc2e137a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DirectPremiumsWritten"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DirectPremiumsWritten_bda6b745-7933-4d21-8a28-1a7fbc2e137a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssumedPremiumsWritten_624016e3-44fc-4cb7-858f-ad765c8b1d57" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssumedPremiumsWritten"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssumedPremiumsWritten_624016e3-44fc-4cb7-858f-ad765c8b1d57" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CededPremiumsWritten_5cfac211-c2a2-472b-ad65-629cd42332f6" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CededPremiumsWritten"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CededPremiumsWritten_5cfac211-c2a2-472b-ad65-629cd42332f6" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenNet_3c21576f-7343-492b-a930-1c7baf03c5af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsWrittenNet_3c21576f-7343-492b-a930-1c7baf03c5af" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_DirectPremiumsEarned_aec4e57d-375a-4456-91c3-1b5e52911829" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_DirectPremiumsEarned"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_DirectPremiumsEarned_aec4e57d-375a-4456-91c3-1b5e52911829" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssumedPremiumsEarned_5925fbb6-455c-47ff-8db8-c6aa64268df1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssumedPremiumsEarned"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssumedPremiumsEarned_5925fbb6-455c-47ff-8db8-c6aa64268df1" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CededPremiumsEarned_746e3fba-02ec-499c-8eda-d2c3c0920795" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CededPremiumsEarned"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CededPremiumsEarned_746e3fba-02ec-499c-8eda-d2c3c0920795" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNet_053677e3-f2ce-4869-8bd2-227450f07445" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNet"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsEarnedNet_053677e3-f2ce-4869-8bd2-227450f07445" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceEffectOnClaimsAndBenefitsIncurredAmountCeded_d75f9142-b1b0-406c-8460-c95a62f2fd5e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceEffectOnClaimsAndBenefitsIncurredAmountCeded"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceEffectOnClaimsAndBenefitsIncurredAmountCeded_d75f9142-b1b0-406c-8460-c95a62f2fd5e" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionAmountRetainedPerEvent_1529904a-03e0-4423-a8b2-db264524be44" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionAmountRetainedPerEvent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_EffectsOfReinsuranceLineItems_5a9b8970-c844-4a16-ba4e-8dcca2471b9c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRetentionAmountRetainedPerEvent_1529904a-03e0-4423-a8b2-db264524be44" xlink:type="arc" order="9"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceRecoverablesfromreinsuranceprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsuranceRecoverablesfromreinsuranceprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsuranceRecoverablesfromreinsuranceprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_446bdbdb-a7cd-46c8-a195-9c7fd1c7aa37" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_af2343ba-1ccb-462e-a56b-da902a745dfc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_446bdbdb-a7cd-46c8-a195-9c7fd1c7aa37" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_af2343ba-1ccb-462e-a56b-da902a745dfc" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_08518ff0-683c-48e2-a77d-8e069ba4ed9f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_af2343ba-1ccb-462e-a56b-da902a745dfc" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_08518ff0-683c-48e2-a77d-8e069ba4ed9f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_08518ff0-683c-48e2-a77d-8e069ba4ed9f_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_08518ff0-683c-48e2-a77d-8e069ba4ed9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_08518ff0-683c-48e2-a77d-8e069ba4ed9f_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4b4637d6-b934-4a19-844d-dd0de43549ff" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_08518ff0-683c-48e2-a77d-8e069ba4ed9f" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4b4637d6-b934-4a19-844d-dd0de43549ff" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_58909e63-66e4-4db9-8ebc-8d873a7ba324" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_4b4637d6-b934-4a19-844d-dd0de43549ff" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_58909e63-66e4-4db9-8ebc-8d873a7ba324" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_3400a513-df7b-40f2-8ded-b45a5dac8edb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_446bdbdb-a7cd-46c8-a195-9c7fd1c7aa37" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_3400a513-df7b-40f2-8ded-b45a5dac8edb" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance_3559ec9a-37f5-46f8-8f25-00bbe20f873d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_3400a513-df7b-40f2-8ded-b45a5dac8edb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance_3559ec9a-37f5-46f8-8f25-00bbe20f873d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_aa2de711-688b-4773-a833-cd625777b221" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_3400a513-df7b-40f2-8ded-b45a5dac8edb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossPeriodIncreaseDecrease_aa2de711-688b-4773-a833-cd625777b221" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableCreditLossExpenseReversal_c5ae9de6-a002-4d55-bbcd-12083c741cbd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableCreditLossExpenseReversal"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_3400a513-df7b-40f2-8ded-b45a5dac8edb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableCreditLossExpenseReversal_c5ae9de6-a002-4d55-bbcd-12083c741cbd" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceLossOnUncollectibleAccountsInPeriodAmount_7d1b69e8-bdfb-4b63-9464-988401b9596f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceLossOnUncollectibleAccountsInPeriodAmount"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverableAllowanceForCreditLossRollForward_3400a513-df7b-40f2-8ded-b45a5dac8edb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceLossOnUncollectibleAccountsInPeriodAmount_7d1b69e8-bdfb-4b63-9464-988401b9596f" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance_df99aae5-77c1-4bfd-a344-6b6ffa38a378" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ReinsuranceRecoverablesAllowance"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsurancePremiumsreceivableprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#InsurancePremiumsreceivableprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/InsurancePremiumsreceivableprogressionofallowanceforexpectedcreditlossesDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_62e2b3d3-9910-4aa3-b0fc-c19b3f524020" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_3fd6eba1-f244-44b3-aef4-ec67d9ee5473" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InsuranceTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_62e2b3d3-9910-4aa3-b0fc-c19b3f524020" xlink:to="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_3fd6eba1-f244-44b3-aef4-ec67d9ee5473" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c40212b9-1dc9-4599-814b-e38d75dafffb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceTable_3fd6eba1-f244-44b3-aef4-ec67d9ee5473" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c40212b9-1dc9-4599-814b-e38d75dafffb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c40212b9-1dc9-4599-814b-e38d75dafffb_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c40212b9-1dc9-4599-814b-e38d75dafffb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_c40212b9-1dc9-4599-814b-e38d75dafffb_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_e80a6f8f-aee0-47ac-b858-c7a7d8d39c6d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAxis_c40212b9-1dc9-4599-814b-e38d75dafffb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_e80a6f8f-aee0-47ac-b858-c7a7d8d39c6d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_a7bdb70e-19a6-45b1-9d14-f39c2136db99" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CropRiskServicesMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BusinessAcquisitionAcquireeDomain_e80a6f8f-aee0-47ac-b858-c7a7d8d39c6d" xlink:to="loc_afg_CropRiskServicesMember_a7bdb70e-19a6-45b1-9d14-f39c2136db99" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_51a444c1-a91f-4841-b654-29abef7d8f3b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_afg_InsuranceLineItems_62e2b3d3-9910-4aa3-b0fc-c19b3f524020" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_51a444c1-a91f-4841-b654-29abef7d8f3b" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts_96e01e76-e5be-4636-8459-945e5b37ccc0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_51a444c1-a91f-4841-b654-29abef7d8f3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts_96e01e76-e5be-4636-8459-945e5b37ccc0" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsPeriodIncreaseDecrease_cc5634fe-a2ac-4c44-819d-c681c25ef724" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsPeriodIncreaseDecrease"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_51a444c1-a91f-4841-b654-29abef7d8f3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsPeriodIncreaseDecrease_cc5634fe-a2ac-4c44-819d-c681c25ef724" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumReceivableCreditLossExpenseReversal_2d025e0d-45a9-417b-b1a4-337faf36f6b5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumReceivableCreditLossExpenseReversal"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_51a444c1-a91f-4841-b654-29abef7d8f3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumReceivableCreditLossExpenseReversal_2d025e0d-45a9-417b-b1a4-337faf36f6b5" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsWriteOffsAgainstAllowance_f515b085-9e1a-405c-bdb1-4628568a3bac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsWriteOffsAgainstAllowance"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsRollForward_51a444c1-a91f-4841-b654-29abef7d8f3b" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccountsWriteOffsAgainstAllowance_f515b085-9e1a-405c-bdb1-4628568a3bac" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts_5cf61c7c-94dc-4a8c-93e0-89b849a48b74" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PremiumsReceivableAllowanceForDoubtfulAccounts"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedBalanceSheetDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedBalanceSheetDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedBalanceSheetDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_57f78087-586e-44a9-885b-881b39bc6690" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_4b001a82-2fc0-4c30-8e5c-d3de582774c9" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_57f78087-586e-44a9-885b-881b39bc6690" xlink:to="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_4b001a82-2fc0-4c30-8e5c-d3de582774c9" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d2bbd25b-4866-40fb-a557-26e133666282" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_4b001a82-2fc0-4c30-8e5c-d3de582774c9" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d2bbd25b-4866-40fb-a557-26e133666282" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d2bbd25b-4866-40fb-a557-26e133666282_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d2bbd25b-4866-40fb-a557-26e133666282" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_d2bbd25b-4866-40fb-a557-26e133666282_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_1ab00855-eea3-4de3-a3ca-29e42925601c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_d2bbd25b-4866-40fb-a557-26e133666282" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_1ab00855-eea3-4de3-a3ca-29e42925601c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_47861040-69a1-4ed4-9ab8-78c4f6db5e2c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_1ab00855-eea3-4de3-a3ca-29e42925601c" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_47861040-69a1-4ed4-9ab8-78c4f6db5e2c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfFinancialPositionAbstract_94cf5ba4-3296-4954-a5a1-e945277979ee" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOfFinancialPositionAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_57f78087-586e-44a9-885b-881b39bc6690" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfFinancialPositionAbstract_94cf5ba4-3296-4954-a5a1-e945277979ee" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfFinancialPositionAbstract_94cf5ba4-3296-4954-a5a1-e945277979ee" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_c1cc6bff-40c2-4928-83bb-dea74ac8845f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_c1cc6bff-40c2-4928-83bb-dea74ac8845f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecurities_4d42cffd-7b00-4e33-b50e-eb4178cde69e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecurities_4d42cffd-7b00-4e33-b50e-eb4178cde69e" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsInAffiliatesSubsidiariesAssociatesAndJointVentures_2b1cb416-19d4-4968-859c-78307ff22178" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentsInAffiliatesSubsidiariesAssociatesAndJointVentures"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentsInAffiliatesSubsidiariesAssociatesAndJointVentures_2b1cb416-19d4-4968-859c-78307ff22178" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherInvestments_2f353e49-5fae-460c-a648-b0d1ca94505e" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherInvestments_2f353e49-5fae-460c-a648-b0d1ca94505e" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssets_b142a123-c485-4142-b5e2-bbcd6467eb9d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherAssets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherAssets_b142a123-c485-4142-b5e2-bbcd6467eb9d" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Assets_e057cecb-5658-4db4-a860-464c96af1458" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Assets"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract_98fb2ff7-9e75-4c10-a3b7-7b6db2f3f9f8" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Assets_e057cecb-5658-4db4-a860-464c96af1458" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_58f99859-824c-45df-bb0e-6232f0a01592" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfFinancialPositionAbstract_94cf5ba4-3296-4954-a5a1-e945277979ee" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_58f99859-824c-45df-bb0e-6232f0a01592" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_c03d3879-7b33-4d2e-acce-5df9babe984d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_58f99859-824c-45df-bb0e-6232f0a01592" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LongTermDebt_c03d3879-7b33-4d2e-acce-5df9babe984d" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities_4067bfb8-0ed3-42d6-81fe-d2129678efbd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_58f99859-824c-45df-bb0e-6232f0a01592" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities_4067bfb8-0ed3-42d6-81fe-d2129678efbd" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_13bbdaaa-1961-4fde-8eea-ece6f4db5418" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_58f99859-824c-45df-bb0e-6232f0a01592" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockholdersEquity_13bbdaaa-1961-4fde-8eea-ece6f4db5418" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquity_ab073060-6071-4783-bc2f-3929289e2924" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquityAbstract_58f99859-824c-45df-bb0e-6232f0a01592" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesAndStockholdersEquity_ab073060-6071-4783-bc2f-3929289e2924" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofEarningsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofEarningsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofEarningsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_3af0f91a-6e9c-4e1e-97e1-32b45685f37c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_19ff208e-eede-4261-b938-7b16da2bba1b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_3af0f91a-6e9c-4e1e-97e1-32b45685f37c" xlink:to="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_19ff208e-eede-4261-b938-7b16da2bba1b" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_826381c2-efc7-4d35-ba99-3109bc7347d2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_19ff208e-eede-4261-b938-7b16da2bba1b" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_826381c2-efc7-4d35-ba99-3109bc7347d2" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_826381c2-efc7-4d35-ba99-3109bc7347d2_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_826381c2-efc7-4d35-ba99-3109bc7347d2" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_826381c2-efc7-4d35-ba99-3109bc7347d2_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_076517e2-dc4e-4652-b7a3-e4d0ece16c21" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_826381c2-efc7-4d35-ba99-3109bc7347d2" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_076517e2-dc4e-4652-b7a3-e4d0ece16c21" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_37ce2e42-c3fc-426f-89c0-08af0bf2550c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_076517e2-dc4e-4652-b7a3-e4d0ece16c21" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_37ce2e42-c3fc-426f-89c0-08af0bf2550c" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_3af0f91a-6e9c-4e1e-97e1-32b45685f37c" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_c1f48f66-eb1c-4007-9534-020a380b1449" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_c1f48f66-eb1c-4007-9534-020a380b1449" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityInDistributedPretaxEarningsOfConsolidatedSubsidiaries_1a8a7c88-a232-4b85-a27b-3d572511585c" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EquityInDistributedPretaxEarningsOfConsolidatedSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_c1f48f66-eb1c-4007-9534-020a380b1449" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityInDistributedPretaxEarningsOfConsolidatedSubsidiaries_1a8a7c88-a232-4b85-a27b-3d572511585c" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_EquityInUndistributedPretaxEarningsOfConsolidatedSubsidiaries_495c40c6-8f35-43d2-9be5-3301a7c47ffc" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_EquityInUndistributedPretaxEarningsOfConsolidatedSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_c1f48f66-eb1c-4007-9534-020a380b1449" xlink:to="loc_afg_EquityInUndistributedPretaxEarningsOfConsolidatedSubsidiaries_495c40c6-8f35-43d2-9be5-3301a7c47ffc" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncome_cea22c4f-c565-450b-9e69-acdcd3cebd03" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_c1f48f66-eb1c-4007-9534-020a380b1449" xlink:to="loc_afg_InvestmentAndOtherIncome_cea22c4f-c565-450b-9e69-acdcd3cebd03" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_24086471-fafe-469d-8fb9-6759c46a91cc" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_Revenues"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_RevenuesAbstract_c1f48f66-eb1c-4007-9534-020a380b1449" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_Revenues_24086471-fafe-469d-8fb9-6759c46a91cc" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_743173c4-f501-4c5e-b25a-e3297b7396af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_743173c4-f501-4c5e-b25a-e3297b7396af" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_InterestExpenseOnIntercompanyBorrowings_0cc4a72c-ea46-49ae-ab04-ced7d791d437" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_InterestExpenseOnIntercompanyBorrowings"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_743173c4-f501-4c5e-b25a-e3297b7396af" xlink:to="loc_afg_InterestExpenseOnIntercompanyBorrowings_0cc4a72c-ea46-49ae-ab04-ced7d791d437" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InterestExpense_1eddf77f-ebb0-4c42-af2e-084561b8cfc1" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InterestExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_743173c4-f501-4c5e-b25a-e3297b7396af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_InterestExpense_1eddf77f-ebb0-4c42-af2e-084561b8cfc1" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherCostAndExpenseOperating_d408fa2f-c07b-4d75-b2c6-011796c7d665" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherCostAndExpenseOperating"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_743173c4-f501-4c5e-b25a-e3297b7396af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherCostAndExpenseOperating_d408fa2f-c07b-4d75-b2c6-011796c7d665" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpenses_f0fd074d-cdaa-4322-a0b4-c418cb909d29" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpenses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpensesAbstract_743173c4-f501-4c5e-b25a-e3297b7396af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_BenefitsLossesAndExpenses_f0fd074d-cdaa-4322-a0b4-c418cb909d29" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss_ad2ca6f6-7137-4a7f-823d-e16924fa4213" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OperatingIncomeLoss_ad2ca6f6-7137-4a7f-823d-e16924fa4213" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit_0301aedf-266a-4e17-836c-9c19835de7f2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit_0301aedf-266a-4e17-836c-9c19835de7f2" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_a74fcdcd-2dd7-4500-a035-71e4a6d96403" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract_66184565-cd0a-4097-810c-ef3fbbd900fa" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_a74fcdcd-2dd7-4500-a035-71e4a6d96403" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofComprehensiveIncomeDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofComprehensiveIncomeDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofComprehensiveIncomeDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_2111a08a-72dc-4682-b2d7-4ca0ef71e27d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_ea54267e-64c5-4569-b723-a742cff04080" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_2111a08a-72dc-4682-b2d7-4ca0ef71e27d" xlink:to="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_ea54267e-64c5-4569-b723-a742cff04080" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6ea0c724-5931-423e-8337-85623362fa4b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_ea54267e-64c5-4569-b723-a742cff04080" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6ea0c724-5931-423e-8337-85623362fa4b" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6ea0c724-5931-423e-8337-85623362fa4b_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6ea0c724-5931-423e-8337-85623362fa4b" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6ea0c724-5931-423e-8337-85623362fa4b_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_069a19af-ff8a-446d-8d09-8890a24b7ecd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6ea0c724-5931-423e-8337-85623362fa4b" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_069a19af-ff8a-446d-8d09-8890a24b7ecd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_eef112e7-297d-4074-a4a1-39734b8deacb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_069a19af-ff8a-446d-8d09-8890a24b7ecd" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_eef112e7-297d-4074-a4a1-39734b8deacb" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfIncomeAndComprehensiveIncomeAbstract_00c70233-f8e4-43a4-a3b8-6d016ca74d4d" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOfIncomeAndComprehensiveIncomeAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_2111a08a-72dc-4682-b2d7-4ca0ef71e27d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfIncomeAndComprehensiveIncomeAbstract_00c70233-f8e4-43a4-a3b8-6d016ca74d4d" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_54ddb11b-7bbb-41ba-9baf-dd6afea6696f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfIncomeAndComprehensiveIncomeAbstract_00c70233-f8e4-43a4-a3b8-6d016ca74d4d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_54ddb11b-7bbb-41ba-9baf-dd6afea6696f" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTaxPortionAttributableToParent_e5e317d2-412c-41db-b20f-9257657a8301" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTaxPortionAttributableToParent"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfIncomeAndComprehensiveIncomeAbstract_00c70233-f8e4-43a4-a3b8-6d016ca74d4d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherComprehensiveIncomeLossNetOfTaxPortionAttributableToParent_e5e317d2-412c-41db-b20f-9257657a8301" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ComprehensiveIncomeNetOfTax_7fb09a88-4771-4cdf-80ac-0d73b1805fcb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ComprehensiveIncomeNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfIncomeAndComprehensiveIncomeAbstract_00c70233-f8e4-43a4-a3b8-6d016ca74d4d" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ComprehensiveIncomeNetOfTax_7fb09a88-4771-4cdf-80ac-0d73b1805fcb" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofCashFlowsDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofCashFlowsDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/CondensedFinancialInformationofParentCompanyCondensedStatementofCashFlowsDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_bf349faa-32ed-4d7e-bc0f-b739cec01e98" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_5dd2b649-e39b-4484-9e13-5ca6a0f168eb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_bf349faa-32ed-4d7e-bc0f-b739cec01e98" xlink:to="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_5dd2b649-e39b-4484-9e13-5ca6a0f168eb" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6e1bbf62-7c36-4ae2-b03a-83b5a0aae4c5" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_srt_ScheduleOfCondensedFinancialStatementsTable_5dd2b649-e39b-4484-9e13-5ca6a0f168eb" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6e1bbf62-7c36-4ae2-b03a-83b5a0aae4c5" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e1bbf62-7c36-4ae2-b03a-83b5a0aae4c5_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6e1bbf62-7c36-4ae2-b03a-83b5a0aae4c5" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_6e1bbf62-7c36-4ae2-b03a-83b5a0aae4c5_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_2a1f7c68-51a3-4bde-8fd8-61a4455df7a8" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesAxis_6e1bbf62-7c36-4ae2-b03a-83b5a0aae4c5" xlink:to="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_2a1f7c68-51a3-4bde-8fd8-61a4455df7a8" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_c2ba0223-d668-44ae-b7fb-47c690335e9a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_ParentCompanyMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_ConsolidatedEntitiesDomain_2a1f7c68-51a3-4bde-8fd8-61a4455df7a8" xlink:to="loc_srt_ParentCompanyMember_c2ba0223-d668-44ae-b7fb-47c690335e9a" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_CondensedFinancialStatementsCaptionsLineItems_bf349faa-32ed-4d7e-bc0f-b739cec01e98" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_7d45abdd-90dd-438e-ae11-2f65dd032390" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_7d45abdd-90dd-438e-ae11-2f65dd032390" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_f13d03ab-a963-4acd-93b8-fa1c34ba3439" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_7d45abdd-90dd-438e-ae11-2f65dd032390" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetIncomeLoss_f13d03ab-a963-4acd-93b8-fa1c34ba3439" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToReconcileNetIncomeLossToCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_0292b07a-ff47-4905-9cfc-3f3937783d43" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AdjustmentsToReconcileNetIncomeLossToCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_7d45abdd-90dd-438e-ae11-2f65dd032390" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToReconcileNetIncomeLossToCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_0292b07a-ff47-4905-9cfc-3f3937783d43" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromSubsidiariesNetOfTax_f1fc47f4-a6a4-451e-bdad-5604d445699a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromSubsidiariesNetOfTax"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToReconcileNetIncomeLossToCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_0292b07a-ff47-4905-9cfc-3f3937783d43" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromSubsidiariesNetOfTax_f1fc47f4-a6a4-451e-bdad-5604d445699a" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashDividendsPaidToParentCompanyByConsolidatedSubsidiaries_019670aa-3061-46ec-bab1-3af82c22420f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashDividendsPaidToParentCompanyByConsolidatedSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToReconcileNetIncomeLossToCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_0292b07a-ff47-4905-9cfc-3f3937783d43" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashDividendsPaidToParentCompanyByConsolidatedSubsidiaries_019670aa-3061-46ec-bab1-3af82c22420f" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_OtherOperatingActivitiesCondensedConsolidatingCashFlowStatement_feeabd41-5b23-4fdf-8a34-a536bd54e765" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_OtherOperatingActivitiesCondensedConsolidatingCashFlowStatement"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AdjustmentsToReconcileNetIncomeLossToCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_0292b07a-ff47-4905-9cfc-3f3937783d43" xlink:to="loc_afg_OtherOperatingActivitiesCondensedConsolidatingCashFlowStatement_feeabd41-5b23-4fdf-8a34-a536bd54e765" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivities_e7c15841-2dc2-4c5f-813f-048d6cd15e1c" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivitiesAbstract_7d45abdd-90dd-438e-ae11-2f65dd032390" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivities_e7c15841-2dc2-4c5f-813f-048d6cd15e1c" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_CapitalContributionsToSubsidiaries_f9f0385f-6bef-4527-b8bd-64824f75c392" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_CapitalContributionsToSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_afg_CapitalContributionsToSubsidiaries_f9f0385f-6bef-4527-b8bd-64824f75c392" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ReturnsOfCapitalFromSubsidiaries_c6bcd322-2cc9-4708-a1ea-2514fdc5baf2" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ReturnsOfCapitalFromSubsidiaries"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_afg_ReturnsOfCapitalFromSubsidiaries_c6bcd322-2cc9-4708-a1ea-2514fdc5baf2" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PurchasesOfInvestmentsPropertyAndEquipment_a3023052-0099-4603-a029-376ff801a09f" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PurchasesOfInvestmentsPropertyAndEquipment"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_afg_PurchasesOfInvestmentsPropertyAndEquipment_a3023052-0099-4603-a029-376ff801a09f" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_205fbe71-2ea3-4d64-850a-24b95be45b89" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsToAcquireBusinessesGross_205fbe71-2ea3-4d64-850a-24b95be45b89" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromSaleMaturityAndCollectionsOfInvestments_792c5460-80d0-4cc0-be0e-11aba362c974" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ProceedsFromSaleMaturityAndCollectionsOfInvestments"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromSaleMaturityAndCollectionsOfInvestments_792c5460-80d0-4cc0-be0e-11aba362c974" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_ProceedsFromSalesOfInvestmentsPropertyAndEquipment_be8292fc-8101-49e7-a8d7-589c66e74318" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_ProceedsFromSalesOfInvestmentsPropertyAndEquipment"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_afg_ProceedsFromSalesOfInvestmentsPropertyAndEquipment_be8292fc-8101-49e7-a8d7-589c66e74318" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinesses_9292d271-7bfc-4ca6-8dae-7c83476295ef" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinesses"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromDivestitureOfBusinesses_9292d271-7bfc-4ca6-8dae-7c83476295ef" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivities_030f641d-63a1-4910-9782-faa08d41fee2" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivitiesAbstract_b5f46749-2442-463a-bbcb-3b7df914d8af" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInInvestingActivities_030f641d-63a1-4910-9782-faa08d41fee2" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RepaymentsOfLongTermDebt_7a65bb1c-5cd8-4624-a3b9-fc325d13f414" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RepaymentsOfLongTermDebt"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RepaymentsOfLongTermDebt_7a65bb1c-5cd8-4624-a3b9-fc325d13f414" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromIssuanceOfCommonStock_a365a18b-cdb0-4e19-947c-795db06059d4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ProceedsFromIssuanceOfCommonStock"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_ProceedsFromIssuanceOfCommonStock_a365a18b-cdb0-4e19-947c-795db06059d4" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsForRepurchaseOfCommonStock_920623ee-dcb6-44e5-afaf-1982bb3a5ced" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsForRepurchaseOfCommonStock"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsForRepurchaseOfCommonStock_920623ee-dcb6-44e5-afaf-1982bb3a5ced" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsOfDividendsCommonStock_636fee2b-3a41-42d8-be00-b0f257b6aa32" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_PaymentsOfDividendsCommonStock"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_PaymentsOfDividendsCommonStock_636fee2b-3a41-42d8-be00-b0f257b6aa32" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivities_59dca076-ade2-4429-a489-b8da83611613" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivitiesAbstract_ef6aba72-6375-40ad-ab2b-8fa0116dded3" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_NetCashProvidedByUsedInFinancingActivities_59dca076-ade2-4429-a489-b8da83611613" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashCashEquivalentsRestrictedCashAndRestrictedCashEquivalentsPeriodIncreaseDecreaseIncludingExchangeRateEffect_06a0f20e-16e7-45a5-a3c7-7a3e4c2ae414" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashCashEquivalentsRestrictedCashAndRestrictedCashEquivalentsPeriodIncreaseDecreaseIncludingExchangeRateEffect"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashCashEquivalentsRestrictedCashAndRestrictedCashEquivalentsPeriodIncreaseDecreaseIncludingExchangeRateEffect_06a0f20e-16e7-45a5-a3c7-7a3e4c2ae414" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_f23466a5-e160-44f0-937e-0ffe398dc76f" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementOfCashFlowsAbstract_8e39dd70-a085-458e-b0f4-82a3bd521506" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_f23466a5-e160-44f0-937e-0ffe398dc76f" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue_3ca81145-3001-427e-9baa-c59e93866343" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://www.afginc.com/role/SupplementaryInsuranceInformationTableDetails" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#SupplementaryInsuranceInformationTableDetails"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://www.afginc.com/role/SupplementaryInsuranceInformationTableDetails" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentTable_c649f357-67df-4880-8893-14007d7683d4" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/srt/2023/elts/srt-2023.xsd#srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentTable"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/all" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentTable_c649f357-67df-4880-8893-14007d7683d4" xlink:type="arc" order="1" xbrldt:closed="true" xbrldt:contextElement="segment"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_81ee8d4a-1fbe-46a3-a153-4576839207cb" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/hypercube-dimension" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentTable_c649f357-67df-4880-8893-14007d7683d4" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_81ee8d4a-1fbe-46a3-a153-4576839207cb" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_81ee8d4a-1fbe-46a3-a153-4576839207cb_default" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-default" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_81ee8d4a-1fbe-46a3-a153-4576839207cb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_81ee8d4a-1fbe-46a3-a153-4576839207cb_default" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_441c61d5-7785-459c-944f-a19ce265d6ac" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SegmentDomain"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/dimension-domain" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_StatementBusinessSegmentsAxis_81ee8d4a-1fbe-46a3-a153-4576839207cb" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_441c61d5-7785-459c-944f-a19ce265d6ac" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_3821c5c6-9633-45be-9ddd-b767f4beb47e" xlink:href="afg-20231231.xsd#afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_441c61d5-7785-459c-944f-a19ce265d6ac" xlink:to="loc_afg_PropertyAndCasualtyInsuranceMember_3821c5c6-9633-45be-9ddd-b767f4beb47e" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_5165a8d8-6851-4053-8da7-91317d945433" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_SegmentDomain_441c61d5-7785-459c-944f-a19ce265d6ac" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_CorporateAndOtherMember_5165a8d8-6851-4053-8da7-91317d945433" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationDeferredPolicyAcquisitionCosts_0584a7b7-7945-4a77-910e-365870a1b1a0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationDeferredPolicyAcquisitionCosts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationDeferredPolicyAcquisitionCosts_0584a7b7-7945-4a77-910e-365870a1b1a0" xlink:type="arc" order="0"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationLiabilityForFuturePolicyBenefitsLossesClaimsAndLossExpenseReserves_22ca7a60-a9bd-4296-9515-89565524d7dd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationLiabilityForFuturePolicyBenefitsLossesClaimsAndLossExpenseReserves"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationLiabilityForFuturePolicyBenefitsLossesClaimsAndLossExpenseReserves_22ca7a60-a9bd-4296-9515-89565524d7dd" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationUnearnedPremiums_aa36758c-004e-4e40-9569-6208c202f8dd" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationUnearnedPremiums"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationUnearnedPremiums_aa36758c-004e-4e40-9569-6208c202f8dd" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationPremiumRevenue_fb3e97fe-aaf2-4a3a-af03-1619f0a04954" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationPremiumRevenue"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationPremiumRevenue_fb3e97fe-aaf2-4a3a-af03-1619f0a04954" xlink:type="arc" order="3"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationNetInvestmentIncome_f97bbb54-45d6-4266-b782-cae59db35b31" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationNetInvestmentIncome"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationNetInvestmentIncome_f97bbb54-45d6-4266-b782-cae59db35b31" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBenefitsClaimsLossesAndSettlementExpense_2792c105-7b45-4d16-b871-1eda870008ad" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBenefitsClaimsLossesAndSettlementExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBenefitsClaimsLossesAndSettlementExpense_2792c105-7b45-4d16-b871-1eda870008ad" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationAmortizationOfDeferredPolicyAcquisitionCosts_52d18eaa-3fa3-4946-b141-6815b7599dd0" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationAmortizationOfDeferredPolicyAcquisitionCosts"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationAmortizationOfDeferredPolicyAcquisitionCosts_52d18eaa-3fa3-4946-b141-6815b7599dd0" xlink:type="arc" order="6"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationOtherOperatingExpense_992fb552-30a8-4a8f-9ad9-3743f4b8107b" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationOtherOperatingExpense"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationOtherOperatingExpense_992fb552-30a8-4a8f-9ad9-3743f4b8107b" xlink:type="arc" order="7"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationPremiumsWritten_02b1fbac-af00-4a9b-811c-b1095f5bdb2a" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationPremiumsWritten"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_srt_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationBySegmentLineItems_27060dbc-6342-4e4c-bb65-758f14e60bda" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_SupplementaryInsuranceInformationPremiumsWritten_02b1fbac-af00-4a9b-811c-b1095f5bdb2a" xlink:type="arc" order="8"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://fasb.org/us-gaap/role/eedm/ExtensibleEnumerationLists" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-roles-2023.xsd#eedm"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://fasb.org/us-gaap/role/eedm/ExtensibleEnumerationLists" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationsNetOfTaxAttributableToReportingEntity" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_IncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationsNetOfTaxAttributableToReportingEntity"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_IncomeLossFromDiscontinuedOperationsNetOfTaxAttributableToReportingEntity" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_IncomeStatementAbstract" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_MarketableSecuritiesRealizedGainLoss" xlink:type="arc" order="2"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RealEstateFundsMember" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RealEstateFundsMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_InvestmentTypeCategorizationMember" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RealEstateFundsMember" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AssetsAbstract"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_AssetsAbstract" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_AvailableForSaleSecuritiesDebtSecurities" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesCurrentAbstract" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_LiabilitiesCurrentAbstract"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_OtherLiabilities"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_LiabilitiesCurrentAbstract" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_OtherLiabilities" xlink:type="arc" order="1"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
  <link:roleRef roleURI="http://xbrl.sec.gov/ecd/AwardTypeOnly" xlink:type="simple" xlink:href="https://xbrl.sec.gov/ecd/2023/ecd-2023.xsd#AwardTypeOnly"/>
  <link:definitionLink xlink:role="http://xbrl.sec.gov/ecd/AwardTypeOnly" xlink:type="extended">
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_StockCompensationPlanMember" xlink:type="arc" order="4"/>
    <link:loc xlink:type="locator" xlink:label="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember" xlink:href="https://xbrl.fasb.org/us-gaap/2023/elts/us-gaap-2023.xsd#us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember"/>
    <link:definitionArc xlink:arcrole="http://xbrl.org/int/dim/arcrole/domain-member" xlink:from="loc_us-gaap_ShareBasedCompensationArrangementsByShareBasedPaymentAwardAwardTypeAndPlanNameDomain" xlink:to="loc_us-gaap_RestrictedStockMember" xlink:type="arc" order="5"/>
  </link:definitionLink>
</link:linkbase>
